WI Charles Duke of Lower Lorraine is elected King of France instead of Hugh Capet?

King Louis V died in late May of 987, either accidentally or of poisoning by his mother; at the time of his death, he was again trying Adalberon for treason. He left no legitimate heirs, so his uncle Charles, the Duke of Lower Lorraine, was advanced as the hereditary successor to the throne. But the clergy, including both Adalberon and Gerbert (who later became Popr Sylvester II), argued eloquently for Hugh Capet, who was not only of noble blood but had proven himself through his actions and his military might. Capet was elected to the Frankish throne and Adalberon crowned him, all within two months of Louis V's death. Thus the Carolingian dynasty ended and the Capetian began.
WI Charles had won the election? How is this altering History? Any thoughts?
 

Susano

Banned
Charles already had been crowned counter-king once with the support of German King Otto II., and was already considered a traitor in France hence. He was a vasall of a foreign King and once had waged on France, so, yeah, I can see why they picked Capet. Hugo Capet would have to do something to really piss off an alienate many French nobles - but what that could be I have no idea.
 
Top