WI: Bukharin led Soviet Union

What would have happened if Bukharin and the Right Opposition had been able to contain/oust both the Left Opposition and Stalin. How would this affect Soviet domestic and foreign policy, as well as their relationship with Communist parties in other countries?
 
Collectivization would not proceed foward and the New Economic Policy would remain in place well into the 40s. Exactly how the Soviet economy would proceed I can't tell exactly. Massive industrialization programs would probably be created and enacted, as it at large a long-term goal of the Bolshevisks but the political impact will be radically different. It all depends on how the Right Opposition deals with the noveau riche NEPmen, whose existence was an existential threat to the Soviet state.
 
Every indication I've heard is that he was just not someone who had the type of initiative to lead. He was probably in the best place place he could be as editor of the Pravda. Bukharin/Zinoviev/Kamenev remains a strong idea for a ruling coalition.
 
I'm going to disagree with assertions that Kamenev and Zinoviev would agree to a ruling coalition with Bukharin. The issue is that Kamenev and Zinoviev were ideologically close to Trotsky even though they hated his guts as much as just about the rest of the Bolsheviks, and they fundamentally disagreed heavily with Bukharin about economic and social policy. The NEP is a strong example, particularly in the power struggle after Lenin's death and Trotsky's expulsion - whereas Kamenev and Zinoviev wanted to be rid of it because it wasn't ideologically sound, the Right wanted to keep it because it worked. If Bukharin was going to enter a ruling coalition with anyone, it would have been with figures like Rykov and Tomsky, who had previously served in pretty strong positions within the Soviet government.
 
Top