WI: Alternate Election of 1892?

Was doing a little bit of reading on the election of 1892, and wondered about how changing the nominations would go. Rather than Harrison and Cleveland, how would a contest go between James G. Blaine and David B. Hill (the respective Republican and Democratic second choices for the presidential nomination)?
 
There's absolutely no way that the Republicans wouldn't renominate the incumbent President and the Democrats fail to nominate their popular returning ex-President, but for the sake of argument let's say it happens.

Harrison's Republican administration still gets blamed for the economic downturn, and whoever the Democrats nominate likely wins (in this case David B. Hill). Blaine was still damaged goods from 1888, and he still has the reputation of corruptness and anti-Catholicism that would damage his chances in the traditionally Republican north. James Weaver and the Populists likely do better than OTL.
 
There's absolutely no way that the Republicans wouldn't renominate the incumbent President and the Democrats fail to nominate their popular returning ex-President, but for the sake of argument let's say it happens.

Harrison's Republican administration still gets blamed for the economic downturn, and whoever the Democrats nominate likely wins (in this case David B. Hill). Blaine was still damaged goods from 1888, and he still has the reputation of corruptness and anti-Catholicism that would damage his chances in the traditionally Republican north. James Weaver and the Populists likely do better than OTL.
Ah well, I didn't think it was likely either, but I thought I may as well ask. It's possible Hill's Tammany connections might make him a bit unpalatable to some.

You might be able to have Cleveland fall down a flight of stairs if that makes a Democratic choice a bit more realistic. Harrison really wasn't enthusiastic about being renominated IOTL, maybe that coupled with his childrens' deaths and poor health just cause him to give up on trying to beat Blaine?
 
Last edited:
Top