Why the Chinese play cricket (an Imperial Federation timeline)

Very nice, like the "realness" of it. Everything seems gamed out.
It sort of is, I have a very crude combat system to work out results. Based on a combat value per thousand troops. For example The 1st WW BEF has a value of 10 per 1000, the Prewar Chinese regulars 7 per1000, Provincials and Southern new units 5, Northern new units and boxers 3. This gives a raw score (currently standing at 1785 for the North and 1340 for the South if you take the entire army). There are various modifiers of course, ForEx Boxers get +1 on the offensive, while by mid 1903 the South gets a universal +1 for it's superior command and control structure (bring their raw score to 1610 in reality). There are various modifiers for terrain, defensive positions, morale state etc. For each battle I work a ratio based the modified combat strengths of opposing forces involved in any battle to give the odds. Throw a three trusty D6 to give a raw battle result, then the commanders shift it up (good) or down (bad) based on competence. This gives a final battle result, casualty figures and supplies consumed. 25% of non permanent casualties return to active service in a week, the next 35% in a month and the final 40% at 10% per month over the next four months..

Then I take percentage casualties suffered, compare with the troop quality, leadership factors, supply state, overall strategic situation etc and a D6 roll to check for a morale shift. This is a simple 1 to 10 score for the entire force (though some units such as Boxers can have a separate result). Higher is better, if it is at 9 or better the army is buoyed which gives a combat advantage next battle, at 5 unsteady, 4 shaken, 3 demoralised. Unsteady or lower troops have a combat disadvantage next battle. Shaken troops can potentially refuse to continue, demoralised troops can potentially break as well, all of which become more likely the lower the morale obviously. Finally I look at it and decide if any fudging is required, thus far none has been.

BTW currently the North is on a base morale 5 and South base morale 4. Neither is doing well in that respect lol.
 
Last edited:
Some quick notes on the organisations of the two sides armies. Currently both sides use the prewar Qing organisation based around a 12,500 strong combined arms division with 10,000 infantry (five two battalion regiments), 1,000 cavalry (one two battalion regiment), a five battery artillery regiment (16 field guns, four field howitzers), a field engineer unit and small support and command unit. 70% of both sides are these combat formations, leaving a 30% support tail (the big weakness of the Chinese armies of the period ITTL). However the South is just starting to move away from this pattern by increasing the ratio of support services to combat units. This will ultimately increase their combat effectiveness. Undoubtedly the North will be forced to follow suit.
 
SO who has the North picked to be their emperor? They can't continue a state of affairs where they are openly waging war on an emperor without an emperor of their own. Cixi herself cannot provide legitimacy as a mere former concubine of a previous emperor.
 
Last edited:
SO who has the North picked to be their emperor? They can't continue a state of affairs where they are openly waging war on an emperor without an emperor of their own. Cixi herself cannot provide legitimacy as a mere former concubine of a previous emperor.

Absolutely correct. Pujun, born 1885, son of Zaiyi, Prince Duan as the Xuantong Emperor. In Jan 1900 Cixi was able to get enough support in the Qing Grand Council for it to vote for the Guangxu Emperor to abdicate. However the Guangxu Emperor wasn't formally deposed until his escape from the Forbidden City in July 1900. Cixi retained her position as regent, supported by Prince Duan and from memory Ronglu. He theoretically began ruling in his own right in 1902, however effective power remained in the hands of Cixi and Prince Duan.
 
July-Sept 1903: Helping your friends
~July-Sept 1903: Helping your friends

July 1903: The Northern Qing governor of Sichuan Provinces dies unexpectedly. While a new Northern Qing governor is installed quickly, Deshou's death allows the Southern Qing to gain control of part of the province, including the major city of Chongqing, though the vital Chengdu Arsenal remains under Northern Qing control.

July 1903: With the successful end of the Boer War last year, the Edinburgh Imperial Conference takes on a more positive tone than the Melbourne Conference of 1901, with the primary focus returning to Imperial integration and economics rather than security. Indeed the primary discussion centres around determining the future nature of the Empire. The conference includes delegations from both the Orange River and Transvaal Colonies, headed by Martinus Steyn and Shaik Burger respectively and including several former Boer Generals. The experience of the Boer War have driven support for some form of Imperial Federation to unprecedented levels throughout the Empire and the there is general consensus this is the future of the Empire, However there is no agreement as to what form any such Imperial Federation should take. While all agree the current Imperial common market should be maintained and even extended, there is fierce debate over the political structure of any future federation. In an effort to resolve this, it is agreed the Imperial Security Council should be renamed simply the Imperial Council and produce a report giving various options for the next Imperial Conference. The matter of Chile's future relationship with the Empire is also raised. It is acknowledged Chile has become the Empire's strongest and most reliable ally, particularly since its commitment of troops to the Boer War. In recognition of this, the Conference offers to include a Chilean observer on the Imperial Council, an offer gladly accepted.

July 1903: While the issue of a future Imperial Federation is the prime focus of the Edinburgh Imperial Conference, security matters, particularly regarding China are not ignored. With the fall of Nanjing, many fear the Southern Qing are close to collapse. With the recent revelation of the secret contacts between the Northern Qing and Russians, most regard this with great concern. In light of this, the Conference resolves to increase military support for the Southern Qing to shore up their position. In an expression of their new position in the Empire, the Chileans offer to send military advisers to the Southern Qing and supply them with military hardware in return for being included in the 1889 Imperial Fores Act, which would allow them to purchase replacement equipment at reduced cost. After some discussion, the British agree to modify the act to include the Chileans. Naval matters are also raised. With the growing strength of the Imperial German Navy, many fear the Royal Navy may need to be concentrated in Europe in any future war with Germany, stripping the Dominions of their defence. These fears will result in the Edinburgh Doctrine whereby the British guarantee sufficient forces will be maintained throughout the Empire to ensure Imperial security in the event of any war in Europe. Additional the Dominions agree in principle to form their own navies to ensure a certain minimum level of naval presence in their waters. Finally, the Esher Commission's report generates considerable discussion, with many recommendations being controversial. Nevertheless, the Conference eventually agrees to fully implement its recommendations. At the close of the Conference agreement is reached for the next conference to be held in Quebec in 1905.

July 1903: With the likelihood of war between Russia and Japan growing and the Northern Qing desperately short of weapons and equipment due to the heavy losses they have sustained, the Northern Qing offer to provide supplies, labour and intelligence in any future war with Japan. With their supply line to the Far East totally dependent on the incomplete Trans-Siberian Railway, the Russians agree. However the majority of the material supplied will be obsolete surplus hardware.

July 1903: Despite Northern Qing efforts to keep their agreement with the Russians secret, spies provide the Southern Qing with detailed information regarding the new agreement. Despite reservations from Grand Chancellor Zhang Zhidong and Foreign Minister Sun Yat-sen, the Guangxu Emperor passes the information to the British. Viceroy of India Lord Curzon, holding deep fears about Russian expansion into the Chinese tributary state of Tibet, immediately orders a military expedition launched to ensure Tibet does not fall into the Russian sphere.

August 1903: With the Madsen light machine gun now widely deployed by the Southern Qing, they have found its virtues are not limited to its low cost. While not as capable of prolonged fire as the Maxim and having some issues feeding rimless ammunition, its portability allow it to rapidly provide fire support where needed. The Southern Qing are now issuing Madsens at the company level, allowing the Maxims to be concentrated to provide mass sustained fire at critical points. These advantages have not been lost on the Northern Qing, who are now also ordering the Madsen in large numbers.

August 1903: As part of his reforms of the US Army, Secretary of War Elihu Root replaces the position of Commanding General of the US Army with a German style General Staff headed by a Chief of Staff.

August 1903: With the Northern Qing conquest Jiangsu Province and subsequent Southern Qing retreat back into Zhejiang Province, the Southern Qing position has suffered a major blow. With the recent agreement with the Russians to supply much needed military hardware, Dowager Empress Cixi believes the Southern Qing are on the verge of collapse and a general offensive should be launched to finally crush them. However this is strongly opposed by Northern Qing Commander in Chief Prince Zhuang, with support from the head of the foreign service Qixiu and commander of the Beifang Army Yuan Shikai.

August 1903: British signal intercepts with the Japanese and US under the Three Eyes Agreement considerable German support for Russia in its ongoing occupation of Manchuria. With it clear the Russians have no intention of withdrawing their forces and are simply using negotiations as a means to strengthen their position, The Japanese suggest a joint ultimatum to force a withdrawal. However neither the British nor US are willing to commit to what could become a general European war, though they do agree to provide substantial loans and other support for the Japanese in the event of war.

August 1903: The debate over the form of future battleships in the Royal Navy has eventual favoured the 'all big gun' advocates. However it is felt particularly care should be taken with the design of such as ship and the 1903/04 estimates only include three additional battleships, with a committee formed to design an 'all big gun' ship for the 1904/5 program. In a move toward this concept, the New Zealand class dispenses with the 6” guns entirely in favour of four 12” and ten 9.2” guns. To free up the name for the new battleship, the older cruiser New Zealand is to be renamed. The initial proposal to rename her Hengist creates huge opposition from New Zealand and eventually the name Zealandia is selected. The estimates also include two classes of specialist shallow draft monitors for coastal bombardment, the four strong Fusilier class armed with a single 9.2” gun and ten Bombard class mounting two 6” guns taken from obsolete cruisers scheduled for disposal.

September 1903: In keeping with the commitments the Balfour government made at the Edinburgh Imperial Conference, the Foreign Military Assistance Act is passed. Under the terms of the act, parliament is empowered to vote to declare a foreign country to be either a friendly or alternatively allied nation. The act allows allied nations assistance on the same basis as Dominions under the Imperial Forces Act 1889, while friendly nations may be allowed access to equipment and supplies at 'advantageous' prices as determined by cabinet. With the act passed, parliament immediately votes to declare Chile an allied nation and the Southern Qing a friendly nation. With its new status as an allied nation confirmed, Chile immediately orders 50,000 SMLE rifles, with their existing stock of older Lee-Enfield rifles and carbines as part payment. The Chileans new rifles are provided from existing stocks, with the now 'surplus' ex Chilean weapons, along with six 26-knotter destroyers and four Rattlesnake class torpedo gunboats, supplied to the Southern Qing as a friendly nation at a token price.

September 1903: After the landslide Conservative victory Liberal Party chief whip Herbert Gladstone and Labour Party secretary Ramsay MacDonald reach a secret agreement not to stand candidates against each other in order to avoid splitting the anti Conservative vote. While only applying to the upcoming 1904 election, it is the first major cooperation between the two left wing parties.

September 1903: Australian Premier Edmund resigns to take up the position of chief justice in the newly created Australia Supreme Court, His position as Premier is taken by Alfred Deakin, who continues his pro Imperial and protectionist policies.
 
Last edited:
In a minor alteration, I've renamed the Xi'an Chinese as the Northern Qing and Nanjing Chinese as Southern Qing. This I think would be how historians ITTL would refer to the two factions. I've gone back and retroactively changed the previous chapters to reflect this.
 
More details need to be hashed out but the Imperial federation is shaping up.

And the path to war between russia and Japan is heading fast
 
More details need to be hashed out but the Imperial federation is shaping up.

And the path to war between russia and Japan is heading fast
A major spanner is about to be thrown into the move toward an imperial federation, one which was unavoidable. And the Russo-Japanese War is unavoidable, just TTLs version will have some unexpected flow on effects.
 
A major spanner is about to be thrown into the move toward an imperial federation, one which was unavoidable. And the Russo-Japanese War is unavoidable, just TTLs version will have some unexpected flow on effects.
Hope they can solve it and can't wait for nicky to get this much needed reality check
 
China as at August 1903
China Civil War 0308.png

Base maps from Free SVG Maps and used under the terms of Creative Commons Attribution - Non-Commercial 4.0 Intentional
 
Oct-Dec 1903: Getting what you want
~Oct-Dec 1903: Getting what you want

October 1903: With tensions between Japan in Russia over Manchuria growing, Japanese ambassador to the US Takahira Kogorō holds urgent talks with President Roosevelt, resulting in the US issuing a strong statement of support for the Japanese position. To reinforce this statement, Roosevelt orders four battleships and two armoured cruisers be deployed to the Philippines to strengthen the US Asiatic Squadron. This clear display of US support will markedly increase Japanese willingness to commit to war and further improve US-Japanese relations.

October 1903: After careful preparations an expeditionary force of 4,000 British and Indian Army troops under Brigadier James MacDonald is dispatched to Tibet to ensure it remains under Southern Qing control. While the thirteenth Dalai Lama has been raising troops to counter the expedition, he is fully aware his forces are utterly outmatched by the British and therefore he orders them to fall back, making no aggressive moves towards the British.

October 1903: The Northern Qing are not alone in believing a Southern Qing defeat is imminent, with international opinion overwhelming of the same mind. Nevertheless, there are a handful of observers who do not hold with this view. Among them is Yuan Shikai, commander of the troops which faced the recent limited Southern Qing offensive in Jiangxi Province. As the only Northern Qing commander who has had to attempt to defend against a Southern Qing attack, he is convinced they are far from collapse. In fact, in light of the Jiangxi offensive and other recent minor battles, he believes the Southern Qing are on the brink of a significant recovery Fearing the general offensive being contemplated by the Northern Qing Grand Council will very possibly end in disaster he makes secret contact with German representatives, seeking to gain their support for a coup to overthrow the Northern Qing administration. While hesitant, the Germans find his offer of additional concessions in Shandong Province, along with the expansion of their interests into the British sphere in Jiangsu Province attractive. Therefore, while unwilling to give any firm commitment at this point, they do agree to reconsider the matter if circumstances change.

October 1903: With the growing importance of electrical power and support for devolution in Britain, the Electrical Power Industry Act is passed. The act imposes forced mergers on the British electrical supply industry, rationalising it into five large regional companies, one each in England, Ireland, Scotland, Wales, and Ulster while granting the relevant Regional Assemblies authority to regulate the industry within a legislatively established framework of national technical standards, intended to ensure interoperability.

October 1903: With the end of the Boer War, the Imperial Army Corps in Egypt called for by the Melbourne Imperial Conference in 1901 is finally created. Consisting of two infantry divisions each consisting of twelve infantry battalions organised into three brigades, supported by a pioneer and cyclist battalion along with three field artillery battalions each with four six gun batteries, with a heavy battery with four guns attached at divisional level. The Corps will also include a three battalion cavalry brigade and a battalion of three four gun horse artillery batteries. The final component of the Corps will be a brigade with the four Royal Marine Light Infantry battalions and four batteries of Royal Marine Artillery each with four mountain guns. The Corps will incorporate the majority of the existing Egyptian garrison which is reduced to one third of the size of the Egyptian Army.

November 1903: After intense debate in the Northern Qing Grand Council, Dowager Empress Cixi's view regarding an immediate general offensive against the Southern Qing was accepted in early October. With only a month of preparations, the Northern Qing launch what they believe will be the campaign to bring final victory in the Chinese Civil war. Yuan Shikai's Beifang Army is to attack into Jiangxi Province toward Nanchang, Guixiang's Yousheng Army into Hunan, while Dong Fuxiang's Nanfang Army will attack into Southern Qing held Sichuan and then into Yunnan. However, while both Dong Fuxiang and Guixiang throw the full weight of their forces against the Southern Qing, Yuan Shikai chooses to hold back, only making week probing attacks against General Chen Jiongming's First Army. This proves vital, allowing the First Army to divert substantial reinforcements to the hard pressed Second Army, while General Yin Chang's Third Army conducts a gradual fighting withdrawal, extracting the maximum casualties for the ground conceded.

November 1903: In an effort to displace support for Japan and discourage German intervention in any war in the Far East, the British parliament votes to declare Japan a friendly nation under the Foreign Military Assistance Act.

November 1903: With Colombia unwilling to accept the US terms for the construction of a canal across the Isthmus of Panama, the US has shift its focus to supporting separatist rebels in Panama. Believing correctly they have US support, Panamanian rebels declare their independence. The movement of Colombian troops to crush the rebellion is hindered by the refusal of the US controlled Panama Railway to allow its uses by Colombia, while US warships are deployed to prevent Colombian forces movement by sea. The US formally recognises the independence of Panama ten days after their declaration of independence, making it clear to Colombia they will tolerate no intervention. With this Panama effectively succeeds from Colombia. Within days, the US negotiate the Hay-Bunau-Varilla Treaty allowing them to construct the canal on the same terms as the Hay-Herrán Treaty. The treaty is negotiated via telegraph between US Secretary of State James Hay and the French chief engineer of the canal project Phillipe-Jean Bunau-Varilla with no Panamanian involvement. The treaty will be met with a great deal of opposition by the Panamanian population and became a major issue in relations between the two nations almost immediately. The blatant US involvement in Panamanian independence will also create huge resentment in Colombia, with them attempting to imitate Chile and move into the British sphere of influence. While their hopes in this regard are buoyed by their Alfred close relations with Chile, the British are reluctant to jeopardise their relations with the US and will only respond coolly, though British commercial interests will take advantage of Colombian hostility toward the US to expand into the country.

November 1903: After six years of construction and £70,000 {£70,228} of cost overruns, the Shannon hydroelectric scheme in Ireland begins producing power. With an output of 40MW, the scheme is the largest hydroelectric station in the world, capable of supplying all of Ireland's needs, though the project has included a submarine power cable landing in Wales to enable the scheme to also supply power the mainland Britain. The scheme will result in a major increase in the industrial development not only of Ireland, but also Wales.

November 1903: French politics have now settled in five broad factions, the radical left republicans, the left wing liberals, the centrist moderates, the right wing conservatives and the far right boulangists, with all but the republicans and boulangists firmly committed to the new monarchy. In this new environment, the French Imperial Assembly elections result in Waldeck-Rousseau's moderates taking the largest single share of the vote. However while the radicals and boulangists continue to perform poorly, the conservatives and to a lesser extent liberals increase their representation. Nevertheless, Waldeck-Rousseau is able to form a government with support from the liberals. Waldeck-Rousseau will continue his cautious policy of national reconciliation and rebuilding after the chaos of the Dreyfuss Affair in domestic matters, with foreign policy remaining focused on maintaining the Entente with Russia, Improving relations with Britain and seeking to avoid any increase in European tensions.

December 1903: With the likelihood of war between Japan and Russia growing, talks between Japanese Foreign Minister Komura Jutarō and US Secretary of State John Hay result in the Hay-Komura Agreement whereby the US agrees to adopt a policy of benevolent neutrality in the event of war. This agreement, along with the earlier British vote declaring Japan an friendly nation, will result in Germany becoming reluctant to intervene in any war between Japan and Russia.

December 1903: The second Australian federal election is held. The election results in a finely balanced parliament with the Protectionist Party holding 26 seats, Fee Trade Party 24 seats, Labour Party 22 seats and independents three seats. The Protectionist remains in government in coalition with the Labour Party, continuing their pro Imperial and protectionist policies.

December 1903: Orville and Wilber Wright make the first powered flight in the US, with their Wright Flyer No 1, making a 37m controlled flight. However it required a catapult assisted take off, with the Wrights not making a self powered take off until October 1905. However, unlike Santos Dumont, they patent all their developments, greatly hindering the development of aviation in the US.
 
Last edited:
...eight general merchant ships which will be converted to dedicated troop transport ships.
This requires quite a lot of work - not so much because of the holds (you can put in muti-tier sets of bunks) but because there's insufficient water storage on the average tramp, not to mention heads and general plumbing facilities. And a merchant's galley is inadequate to feed more than a couple of score men.

As ever, I am impressed by the amount of research and thought that has gone into this.
 
Last edited:
Top