I may be making a mistake in doing this, I am a relativity new member and post infrequently, but I think your decision to discipline this poster is placing a chill on free speech. No doubt blatant name calling needs to be disciplined (that I know well, you should see what it is like on a Boxing forum) and at other times censured and sometimes even censored, but this wasn't blatant name calling, it was a thought out opinion, maybe right maybe wrong. (I happen to be of the Catholic faith and I don't agree with the post; although his remark regarding a greater tolerance to social ranking I think maybe I do agree with.) He even then went on to suggest that it made them more "conscientious" towards indigenous people (which I guess could then be considered a slur on Protestants), but when reading his post I didn't feel like I was reading 'hate,' just an opinion. As I stated I am not sure I am allowed to challenge you on this, (and I am sure your job is a thankless one) but your action does give me a 'chill.'
I almost said something in tune with this earlier but was worried I might be punished too. I totally agree. Misuse of powers imo. I feel bad that the guy got punished for a valuable comment on my question.
Discussion of Moderator Actions should be posted here:
https://www.alternatehistory.com/forum/threads/hall-of-infamy-eleven11.432317/page-338#post-17871656
In brief: Board policies prohibit bigotry, including that expressed toward religious groups as well as nationalities, ethnic groups, gender, orientation, disability, etc. Board policies also prohibit trolling, flamebaiting, and a number of other activities. The idea is to allow a place where members can discuss issue but do so without any of the prohibited practices.