alternatehistory.com

Hey guys, i'm starting this thread as a sort of game if you will. Its called "who would win in a fight?" The rules are simple. You select a famous general through out history, put him up against another general, select the number of men on both sides, what century, and let the discussion begin. Also, you cannot take a general from the 17th century and put him against some one in the 20th century. And visa versa. Okay, I'll start it.

Who: General Braxton Bragg vs. General George McCllelan.

When: Mid- 19th century.

# of Men: each side has 75,000 men with an equal number of infantry, cavalry, and artillery.

Who would win and why?

Let the discussion begin!
Top