I've listening to Gary W. Gallagher's lecture "Robert E. Lee and his high command" and his comments on Stonewall Jackson and James Longstreet and the got me rethinking some ideas for a TL I have. He gives a few points on their successes and shortcomings and his opinions on how well they would have performed if having been made full generals.
Since I've been thinking about alternate careers for both these men, including the idea of putting one in charge of the Army of Tenn., I'd like to hear what others have to say on how well they think either man could preform if given such a responsibility and why.