which of these candidate would you vote for? (year by year)

I need some thought here, as this will be for a timeline, which of these administration would you have voted for or against.

Bonus points if you can suggest good opponents for their election.

Also keep in mind you wouldn't know specific things from OTL, like the the Manson killings.

The List:

1869: Ulysses S. Grant/Schuyler Colfax (R)
1873: Ulysses S. Grant/Henry Wilson (R)
1877: Isaac Parker/William A. Wheeler (R)
1881: Winfield Scott Hancock/Thomas Andrews Hendricks (D)
1885: Winfield Scott Hancock/Grover Cleveland (D)
1889: Grover Cleveland/Robert E. Lee Jr. (D)
1893: Grover Cleveland/Robert E. Lee Jr. (D)
1897: Robert E. Lee Jr./William Jennings Bryan(D)
1901: Robert E. Lee Jr./William Jennings Bryan(D)
1905: William Jennings Byran/ Eugene V. Debs (Populist)
1909: Theodore Roosevelt/Walter M Chandler (Bull Moose Party)
1913: Theodore Roosevelt/James G. Woodward (Bull Moose)
1917: Theodore Roosevelt/James G. Woodward (Bull Moose)
1921: Upton Sinclair/Eugene V. Debs (Populist)
1922: Eugene V. Debs/Robert M. LaFollette, Sr. (Socialist, after Sinclair's assassination)
1925: Calvin Coolidge/Henry Cabot Lodge (Republican/Bull Moose)
1929: Calvin Coolidge/Nicholas Longworth (Republican/ Bull Moose but the Bull Moose party hardly existed at this time.)
1933: Al Smith/Franklin Roosevelt (Populist/Democrats)
1937: Al Smith/Gerardo Machado (Populist)
1941: Fiorello La Guardia/Wendell Willkie (Republican)
1945: Fiorello La Guardia/Wendell Willkie (Republican)
1949: George S. Patton/Omar Bradley (American)
1953: Frank P. Zeidler/Henry A. Wallace (Socialist)
1957: George S. Patton/Omar Bradley (American)
1961: John F Kennedy/Richard Nixon (R)
1965: John F Kennedy/Richard Nixon (R)
1969: Ferdinand Marcos/John Tower (R)
1973: Ferdinand Marcos/ John Connally (R)
1977: John Connally/Strom Thurmond (R)
1981: Ronald Reagan/ Robert F. Kennedy (R)
1985: Ronald Reagan/ Robert F. Kennedy (R)
1989: John Glenn/Charles Wilson (Democrat)
1993: John Glenn/Charles Wilson (Democrat)
1997: Charles Manson/Bill Clinton (D)
2000: Bill Clinton/ Hilary Clinton (D) (Charles Manson dies in office)
2001: Martin Luther King III / Al Gore (I)
2005: Martin Luther King III / Al Gore (I)
2009: Maria Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo/David Rockefeller Jr (Libertarian)
 
1869: Ulysses S. Grant/Schuyler Colfax (R)
1873: Ulysses S. Grant/Henry Wilson (R)
1877: Isaac Parker/William A. Wheeler (R)
1881: Winfield Scott Hancock/Thomas Andrews Hendricks (D)
1885: Winfield Scott Hancock/Grover Cleveland (D)
1889: Grover Cleveland/Robert E. Lee Jr. (D)
1893: Grover Cleveland/Robert E. Lee Jr. (D)
1897: Robert E. Lee Jr./William Jennings Bryan(D)
1901: Robert E. Lee Jr./William Jennings Bryan(D)
1905: William Jennings Byran/ Eugene V. Debs (Populist)
1909: Theodore Roosevelt/Walter M Chandler (Bull Moose Party)
1913: Theodore Roosevelt/James G. Woodward (Bull Moose)
1917: Theodore Roosevelt/James G. Woodward (Bull Moose)
1921: Upton Sinclair/Eugene V. Debs (Populist)
1922: Eugene V. Debs/Robert M. LaFollette, Sr. (Socialist, after Sinclair's assassination)
1925: Calvin Coolidge/Henry Cabot Lodge (Republican/Bull Moose)
1929: Calvin Coolidge/Nicholas Longworth (Republican/ Bull Moose but the Bull Moose party hardly existed at this time.)
1933: Al Smith/Franklin Roosevelt (Populist/Democrats)
1937: Al Smith/Gerardo Machado (Populist)
1941: Fiorello La Guardia/Wendell Willkie (Republican)
1945: Fiorello La Guardia/Wendell Willkie (Republican)
1949: George S. Patton/Omar Bradley (American)
1953: Frank P. Zeidler/Henry A. Wallace (Socialist)
1957: George S. Patton/Omar Bradley (American)
1961: John F Kennedy/Richard Nixon (R)
1965: John F Kennedy/Richard Nixon (R)
1969: Ferdinand Marcos/John Tower (R)
1973: Ferdinand Marcos/ John Connally (R)
1977: John Connally/Strom Thurmond (R)
1981: Ronald Reagan/ Robert F. Kennedy (R)
1985: Ronald Reagan/ Robert F. Kennedy (R)
1989: John Glenn/Charles Wilson (Democrat)
1993: John Glenn/Charles Wilson (Democrat)
1997: Charles Manson/Bill Clinton (D)
2000: Bill Clinton/ Hilary Clinton (D) (Charles Manson dies in office)
2001: Martin Luther King III / Al Gore (I)
2005: Martin Luther King III / Al Gore (I)
2009: Maria Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo/David Rockefeller Jr (Libertarian)
Votes for are in bold.
 
It's kind of hard to say whether or not I would vote for a person if I don't know who they are running against. But as to whether or not I view them favorably:

1869: Ulysses S. Grant/Schuyler Colfax (R)
1873: Ulysses S. Grant/Henry Wilson (R)
1877: Isaac Parker/William A. Wheeler (R)
1881: Winfield Scott Hancock/Thomas Andrews Hendricks (D)
1885: Winfield Scott Hancock/Grover Cleveland (D)
1889: Grover Cleveland/Robert E. Lee Jr. (D)
1893: Grover Cleveland/Robert E. Lee Jr. (D)
1897: Robert E. Lee Jr./William Jennings Bryan(D)
1901: Robert E. Lee Jr./William Jennings Bryan(D)
1905: William Jennings Byran/ Eugene V. Debs (Populist)
1909: Theodore Roosevelt/Walter M Chandler (Bull Moose Party)
1913: Theodore Roosevelt/James G. Woodward (Bull Moose)
1917: Theodore Roosevelt/James G. Woodward (Bull Moose)
1921: Upton Sinclair/Eugene V. Debs (Populist)
1922: Eugene V. Debs/Robert M. LaFollette, Sr. (Socialist, after Sinclair's assassination)
1925: Calvin Coolidge/Henry Cabot Lodge (Republican/Bull Moose)
1929: Calvin Coolidge/Nicholas Longworth (Republican/ Bull Moose but the Bull Moose party hardly existed at this time.)
1933: Al Smith/Franklin Roosevelt (Populist/Democrats)
1937: Al Smith/Gerardo Machado (Populist)
1941: Fiorello La Guardia/Wendell Willkie (Republican)
1945: Fiorello La Guardia/Wendell Willkie (Republican)
1949: George S. Patton/Omar Bradley (American)
1953: Frank P. Zeidler/Henry A. Wallace (Socialist)
1957: George S. Patton/Omar Bradley (American)
1961: John F Kennedy/Richard Nixon (R)
1965: John F Kennedy/Richard Nixon (R)
1969: Ferdinand Marcos/John Tower (R)
1973: Ferdinand Marcos/ John Connally (R)
1977: John Connally/Strom Thurmond (R)
1981: Ronald Reagan/ Robert F. Kennedy (R)
1985: Ronald Reagan/ Robert F. Kennedy (R)
1989: John Glenn/Charles Wilson (Democrat)
1993: John Glenn/Charles Wilson (Democrat)
1997: Charles Manson/Bill Clinton (D)
2000: Bill Clinton/ Hilary Clinton (D) (Charles Manson dies in office)
2001: Martin Luther King III / Al Gore (I)
2005: Martin Luther King III / Al Gore (I)
2009: Maria Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo/David Rockefeller Jr (Libertarian)

Btw, I'm assuming the dates you give is the year of the tickets' innauguration. Unless you used some weird POD to shift all Presidential elections by a year. Also, I think having a husband-wife pair on the same ticket is ASB unless you butterflied away people's ill-feelings toward Nepotism. Unless of course Hillary Clinton isn't married to Bill ITTL and you are just using that name so that we won't be confused. Also, I love the whole thing with the Kennedys being Republicans. :D
 
1869: Ulysses S. Grant/Schuyler Colfax (R)
1873: Ulysses S. Grant/Henry Wilson (R)

1877: Isaac Parker/William A. Wheeler (R)
1881: Winfield Scott Hancock/Thomas Andrews Hendricks (D)
1885: Winfield Scott Hancock/Grover Cleveland (D)
1889: Grover Cleveland/Robert E. Lee Jr. (D)
1893: Grover Cleveland/Robert E. Lee Jr. (D)
1897: Robert E. Lee Jr./William Jennings Bryan(D)
1901: Robert E. Lee Jr./William Jennings Bryan(D)
1905: William Jennings Byran/ Eugene V. Debs (Populist)
1909: Theodore Roosevelt/Walter M Chandler (Bull Moose Party)
1913: Theodore Roosevelt/James G. Woodward (Bull Moose)
1917: Theodore Roosevelt/James G. Woodward (Bull Moose)
1921: Upton Sinclair/Eugene V. Debs (Populist)
1922: Eugene V. Debs/Robert M. LaFollette, Sr. (Socialist, after Sinclair's assassination)

1925: Calvin Coolidge/Henry Cabot Lodge (Republican/Bull Moose)
1929: Calvin Coolidge/Nicholas Longworth (Republican/ Bull Moose but the Bull Moose party hardly existed at this time.)
1933: Al Smith/Franklin Roosevelt (Populist/Democrats)
1937: Al Smith/Gerardo Machado (Populist)
1941: Fiorello La Guardia/Wendell Willkie (Republican)
1945: Fiorello La Guardia/Wendell Willkie (Republican)

1949: George S. Patton/Omar Bradley (American)
1953: Frank P. Zeidler/Henry A. Wallace (Socialist)
1957: George S. Patton/Omar Bradley (American)
1961: John F Kennedy/Richard Nixon (R)
1965: John F Kennedy/Richard Nixon (R)

1969: Ferdinand Marcos/John Tower (R)
1973: Ferdinand Marcos/ John Connally (R)
1977: John Connally/Strom Thurmond (R)
1981: Ronald Reagan/ Robert F. Kennedy (R)
1985: Ronald Reagan/ Robert F. Kennedy (R)
1989: John Glenn/Charles Wilson (Democrat)
1993: John Glenn/Charles Wilson (Democrat)

1997: Charles Manson/Bill Clinton (D)
2000: Bill Clinton/ Hilary Clinton (D) (Charles Manson dies in office)
2001: Martin Luther King III / Al Gore (I)
2005: Martin Luther King III / Al Gore (I)

2009: Maria Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo/David Rockefeller Jr (Libertarian)
 
Bill made Hilary the VP against everyone's advice, note they were not really elected due to Manson's death.

And yes, It's by inauguration.
 
1869: Ulysses S. Grant/Schuyler Colfax (R)
1873: Ulysses S. Grant/Henry Wilson (R)

1877: Isaac Parker/William A. Wheeler (R)
1881: Winfield Scott Hancock/Thomas Andrews Hendricks (D)
1885: Winfield Scott Hancock/Grover Cleveland (D)
1889: Grover Cleveland/Robert E. Lee Jr. (D)
1893: Grover Cleveland/Robert E. Lee Jr. (D)
1897: Robert E. Lee Jr./William Jennings Bryan(D)
1901: Robert E. Lee Jr./William Jennings Bryan(D)
1905: William Jennings Byran/ Eugene V. Debs (Populist)
1909: Theodore Roosevelt/Walter M Chandler (Bull Moose Party)
1913: Theodore Roosevelt/James G. Woodward (Bull Moose)
1917: Theodore Roosevelt/James G. Woodward (Bull Moose)

1921: Upton Sinclair/Eugene V. Debs (Populist)
1922: Eugene V. Debs/Robert M. LaFollette, Sr. (Socialist, after Sinclair's assassination)
1925: Calvin Coolidge/Henry Cabot Lodge (Republican/Bull Moose)
1929: Calvin Coolidge/Nicholas Longworth (Republican/ Bull Moose but the Bull Moose party hardly existed at this time.)
1933: Al Smith/Franklin Roosevelt (Populist/Democrats)
1937: Al Smith/Gerardo Machado (Populist)
1941: Fiorello La Guardia/Wendell Willkie (Republican)
1945: Fiorello La Guardia/Wendell Willkie (Republican)

1949: George S. Patton/Omar Bradley (American)
1953: Frank P. Zeidler/Henry A. Wallace (Socialist)
1957: George S. Patton/Omar Bradley (American)
1961: John F Kennedy/Richard Nixon (R)
1965: John F Kennedy/Richard Nixon (R)

1969: Ferdinand Marcos/John Tower (R)
1973: Ferdinand Marcos/ John Connally (R)
1977: John Connally/Strom Thurmond (R)
1981: Ronald Reagan/ Robert F. Kennedy (R)
1985: Ronald Reagan/ Robert F. Kennedy (R)

1989: John Glenn/Charles Wilson (Democrat)
1993: John Glenn/Charles Wilson (Democrat)
1997: Charles Manson/Bill Clinton (D)
2000: Bill Clinton/ Hilary Clinton (D) (Charles Manson dies in office)
2001: Martin Luther King III / Al Gore (I)
2005: Martin Luther King III / Al Gore (I)
2009: Maria Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo/David Rockefeller Jr (Libertarian)

As much as I love Patton, wouldn't vote for him as a President. At all. He'd be a good head of department of defense or maybe at best a VP, but not President.
 

Penelope

Banned
1869: Ulysses S. Grant/Schuyler Colfax (R)
1873: Ulysses S. Grant/Henry Wilson (R)
1877: Isaac Parker/William A. Wheeler (R)
1881: Winfield Scott Hancock/Thomas Andrews Hendricks (D)
1885: Winfield Scott Hancock/Grover Cleveland (D)
1889: Grover Cleveland/Robert E. Lee Jr. (D)
1893: Grover Cleveland/Robert E. Lee Jr. (D)
1897: Robert E. Lee Jr./William Jennings Bryan(D)
1901: Robert E. Lee Jr./William Jennings Bryan(D)
1905: William Jennings Byran/ Eugene V. Debs (Populist)
1909: Theodore Roosevelt/Walter M Chandler (Bull Moose Party)
1913: Theodore Roosevelt/James G. Woodward (Bull Moose)
1917: Theodore Roosevelt/James G. Woodward (Bull Moose)
1921: Upton Sinclair/Eugene V. Debs (Populist)
1922: Eugene V. Debs/Robert M. LaFollette, Sr. (Socialist, after Sinclair's assassination)
1925: Calvin Coolidge/Henry Cabot Lodge (Republican/Bull Moose)
1929: Calvin Coolidge/Nicholas Longworth (Republican/ Bull Moose but the Bull Moose party hardly existed at this time.)
1933: Al Smith/Franklin Roosevelt (Populist/Democrats)
1937: Al Smith/Gerardo Machado (Populist)
1941: Fiorello La Guardia/Wendell Willkie (Republican)
1945: Fiorello La Guardia/Wendell Willkie (Republican)
1949: George S. Patton/Omar Bradley (American)
1953: Frank P. Zeidler/Henry A. Wallace (Socialist)
1957: George S. Patton/Omar Bradley (American)
1961: John F Kennedy/Richard Nixon (R)
1965: John F Kennedy/Richard Nixon (R)
1969: Ferdinand Marcos/John Tower (R)
1973: Ferdinand Marcos/ John Connally (R)
1977: John Connally/Strom Thurmond (R)
1981: Ronald Reagan/ Robert F. Kennedy (R)
1985: Ronald Reagan/ Robert F. Kennedy (R)
1989: John Glenn/Charles Wilson (Democrat)
1993: John Glenn/Charles Wilson (Democrat)
1997: Charles Manson/Bill Clinton (D)
2000: Bill Clinton/ Hilary Clinton (D) (Charles Manson dies in office)
2001: Martin Luther King III / Al Gore (I)
2005: Martin Luther King III / Al Gore (I)
2009: Maria Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo/David Rockefeller Jr (Libertarian)
 
Bill made Hilary the VP against everyone's advice, note they were not really elected due to Manson's death.

She would still have to be approved by both houses of Congress (see section 2 of the 25th ammendment). Unless of course you butterflied away the 25th ammendment, which you can totally do with the POD that early. Otherwise, I doubt she would be confirmed by Congress if she had no prior political experience. Now if you add something about her being in Congress or something before, then maybe I can see it, but I still don't think a husband-wife pair in the Presidency and Vice Presidency is very likely. I don't mean to nitpick, I just want to help you make your TL as accurate as possible. :)
 
She would still have to be approved by both houses of Congress (see section 2 of the 25th ammendment). Unless of course you butterflied away the 25th ammendment, which you can totally do with the POD that early. Otherwise, I doubt she would be confirmed by Congress if she had no prior political experience. Now if you add something about her being in Congress or something before, then maybe I can see it, but I still don't think a husband-wife pair in the Presidency and Vice Presidency is very likely. I don't mean to nitpick, I just want to help you make your TL as accurate as possible. :)

She was already in Congress, in this timeline the Clintons are a major political family like the Kennedy's, and just as cursed as the Kennedy's were OTL.

And I might throw out a couple of amendments.
 
This list is strongly subject to change depending on who the opposing candidates are.


1869: Ulysses S. Grant/Schuyler Colfax (R)
1873: Ulysses S. Grant/Henry Wilson (R)
1877: Isaac Parker/William A. Wheeler (R)
1881: Winfield Scott Hancock/Thomas Andrews Hendricks (D)
1885: Winfield Scott Hancock/Grover Cleveland (D)

1889: Grover Cleveland/Robert E. Lee Jr. (D)
1893: Grover Cleveland/Robert E. Lee Jr. (D)

1897: Robert E. Lee Jr./William Jennings Bryan(D)
1901: Robert E. Lee Jr./William Jennings Bryan(D)
1905: William Jennings Byran/ Eugene V. Debs (Populist)
1909: Theodore Roosevelt/Walter M Chandler (Bull Moose Party)
1913: Theodore Roosevelt/James G. Woodward (Bull Moose)
1917: Theodore Roosevelt/James G. Woodward (Bull Moose)

1921: Upton Sinclair/Eugene V. Debs (Populist)
1922: Eugene V. Debs/Robert M. LaFollette, Sr. (Socialist, after Sinclair's assassination)
1925: Calvin Coolidge/Henry Cabot Lodge (Republican/Bull Moose)
1929: Calvin Coolidge/Nicholas Longworth (Republican/ Bull Moose but the Bull Moose party hardly existed at this time.)

1933: Al Smith/Franklin Roosevelt (Populist/Democrats)
1937: Al Smith/Gerardo Machado (Populist)
1941: Fiorello La Guardia/Wendell Willkie (Republican)
1945: Fiorello La Guardia/Wendell Willkie (Republican)
1949: George S. Patton/Omar Bradley (American)
1953: Frank P. Zeidler/Henry A. Wallace (Socialist)
1957: George S. Patton/Omar Bradley (American)
1961: John F Kennedy/Richard Nixon (R)
1965: John F Kennedy/Richard Nixon (R)
1969: Ferdinand Marcos/John Tower (R)
1973: Ferdinand Marcos/ John Connally (R)
1977: John Connally/Strom Thurmond (R)
1981: Ronald Reagan/ Robert F. Kennedy (R)
1985: Ronald Reagan/ Robert F. Kennedy (R)

1989: John Glenn/Charles Wilson (Democrat)
1993: John Glenn/Charles Wilson (Democrat)
1997: Charles Manson/Bill Clinton (D)
2000: Bill Clinton/ Hilary Clinton (D) (Charles Manson dies in office)
2001: Martin Luther King III / Al Gore (I)
2005: Martin Luther King III / Al Gore (I)
2009: Maria Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo/David Rockefeller Jr (Libertarian)
 
Top