Which Early American Timeline

Which Early American Timeline Should I Write

  • Hero of Saratoga

    Votes: 14 28.0%
  • The world Turned Right Side Up

    Votes: 16 32.0%
  • Title Not Yet Chosen

    Votes: 20 40.0%

  • Total voters
    50
Early American History is my specialty (1770's-1860's). I'm thinking of making another timeline involving early American History. Which one sounds most interesting to you.

The Hero of Sratoga: Horatio Gates is shot and killed at the Battle of Saratoga and Benedict Arnold receives credit for the victory. He doesn't betray the United States and eventually become President.

The World Turned Right Side Up: The United States loses the war of 1812, and eventually fights a 3rd Anglo-American War.

Title not yet chosen: Title not yet chosen isn't the title, this is just an idea without a name yet. Basically the Americans lose the revolution, but a second revolution happens in the early 1800's but with almost all of British North America revolting.
 
The Untitled one sounds really interesting.

But maybe instead of having the U.S. lose the American Revolution, it could be butterflied away entirely? Like the American Revolution with a whole different set of characters. :D
 
Either the first or third one. Both sound really interesting, especially if you could make Benedict Arnold as President.

Still, finish your current one, Long and Flowing Whig.
 
Arnold not turning his coat would be interesting, but I'm not sure even if he is seen as a hero he'd be president.

Still, that's my vote.

Would be interesting to see how the truth is bent into pretzels to make him sound like a good guy.

Arnold was...not exactly the noblest, or even nicest, of men.

Even if he does get the credit he deserved, he'd still be an unlikable, dysfunctional person at times - more than a few times, from what I can tell.
 
I would definitely say the third. As far as I can tell, its unique, something hard to find on this site, especially with new people. *Runs away to avoid rotten tomatoes thrown over my hypocrisy*
 
The third one sounds the best. It sounds similar to General Finley's Federal Republic of America only with everybody coming along the second time around instead of just the South.
 
Top