alternatehistory.com

Let's say that there is some POD in the 19th century, perhaps we kill Engels, perhaps Proudhon has a disciple who gives his teacher's ideas the sort of "scientific" gloss that helped make Marxism popular and Anarchism becomes the go-to ideology of the hard left while Marxism stays in the fringes. I'd posit that if that's the case eventually a reformist strain of Anarchism would emerge, just like Marxism had Social Democracy split off from it. What would that ideology have looked like?

I'll be drawing more on Proudhon, Kropotkin and Tucker here rather than people like Bakunin. Of course once you make Anarchism reformist enough it stops being Anarchism and becomes something else with Anarchist roots...

Some ideas:
-Perhaps they'd be called Syndicalists (without the "Anarcho" prefix as they wouldn't be any more radical than the Social Democrats overall) would be involved in politics as well as labor union activity. Perhaps a political party would be started by an anarchist-affiliated labor union that got tired of anarchist purism.
-Emphasize on devolving government to the local, federalism and perhaps New England-style town councils.
-Taxes based on the value of land (not the property on it) with a portion of this tax paid out in cash to the citizenry (a bit like Paine's ideas or OTL Social Credit ideas). This would replace support for the welfare state.
-Support for mutual banking and industrial co-ops.
-Hostility towards tariffs, patents and many forms of intellectual property.
-Pro labor union.
-Your standard basket of culturally libertarian ideas.
-Probably the closest OTL equivalent would be the left wing of modern European Liberalism like Det Radikale Venstre (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Danish_Social_Liberal_Party) in Denmark (maybe, my knowledge of Danish politics isn't very deep at all).

Thoughts?
Top