What was the best possible partition of the Ottoman Empire?

As we all know today, the Middle East is simply a clusterfuck, mainly due to the random division of the Ottoman Empire, and resulting in many of the conflicts in the ME today, like Iraq and Syria, along with everyone-hates-Israel.

But my question here is: what was the best possible division of the Ottoman Empire that was feasible? And how could it happen?
 
The%20Project%20for%20the%20New%20Middle%20East.jpg
 
As we all know today, the Middle East is simply a clusterfuck, mainly due to the random division of the Ottoman Empire, and resulting in many of the conflicts in the ME today, like Iraq and Syria, along with everyone-hates-Israel.

But my question here is: what was the best possible division of the Ottoman Empire that was feasible? And how could it happen?

Free Kurdistan and an independent Arab state from Sinai to Persia under the Hashemites
 

Not this crap again!

Honest answer: no partition - at the very least, a state that covered at least Turkey, the Levant, and Iraq would have been viable and could well have worked as a multiethnic state.

Failing that, don't expand Lebanon beyond the original borders of the existing Mt. Lebanon enclave (plus Beirut) and have an independent Kurdistan.

The problem with these analyses are that "borders" are, contrary to what most people think, NOT the primary problem in the Middle East, and any post-Ottoman settlement is going to by nature have "imperfect" borders because the populations were all heavily heterogenous and mixed.

Also contrary to most modern analyses, the borders of Iraq and Syria were not set by Europeans but largely by Arabs. Turkey's borders were determined by Ataturk and his armies. The most "artificial" state in the region is arguably Jordan, which is nevertheless by far the most stable in the region right now.
 
Last edited:
Top