The consequences need not be as extreme as those described by Ozzymandias. But the survival of Astor, Strauss and Guggenheim could have significant implications. Say the Fed is much weaker than in OTL. Say the first world war is much more abbreviated. What impact might there be on the Russian Revolution? If the war that happens ends in more of a draw, the events that lead to the second world war and the Holocaust do not happen. You have a different century. But you still cultural conflicts with the Ottoman Empire and Islamic states. The American Great Depression was fueled not only by failed investment practices, but by market saturation of railroads and the sudden loss of growth in the steel industry. Now, look at American prohibition. Without antagonism against beer-drinking German-Americans, prohibition might be confined to distilled liquor. If congress outlaws whiskey, there might not be a prohibition amendment. If there is, it might only apply to whiskey and might have never been repealed.
What if the Titanic never sank?
- Thread starter RNG
- Start date
-
- Tags
- alt history titanic ww1
Without Halas, do the Decatur Staleys still become the Chicago Bears? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_Chicago_Bears
Ed Sternaman - who's brother Joey was the team's QB in the '20s - was approached by Staley before the latter met Halas (Sternaman wanted to finish his engineering degree at Illinois). The two ended up as 50/50 partners in Chicago.
The downturn in the economy in 1921 meant the curtailment of the company's sports programme, and Staley suggested to Halas a move to Chicago, with $5k as seed money. Halas and Sternaman agreed, and off they went.
Given the circumstances, I think it likely that a move would have taken place even without Halas. Would the team have called itself the Bears? Richard Whittingham's history doesn't say who thought of the idea, or anything of the dynamics of the relationship with CC Pyle, which would transform the sport. By 1929 the two seem to have fallen out, about coaching matters initially.
Halas was always the public face of the Bears, Sternaman the backroom administrator and coaching organiser. Without Halas, I think Sternaman would have needed another partner, someone more confident - brash - at putting the team forward.
Last edited:
That aside, I think other posters covered it: the ship herself either joins Olympic as one of the "greats" and gets scrapped in the 30s, 40s at the latest or meets her fate another way due to the world wars.
As for the world writ large... the butterflies probably change the world completely considering the people who won't die and the families that won't form as survivors remarry.
As for the world writ large... the butterflies probably change the world completely considering the people who won't die and the families that won't form as survivors remarry.