What IF the Combined Fleet Went to Oahu ?

It appears that Mote has developed his own "lets invade Hawaii" plan which I hope he will soon post on his own thread for further debate?

Hardly, I merely referred to the plan you posted on TankNet.

Much like the Combined Fleet fuel use figures that he claimed to have developed but never posted.

As I mentioned, the numbers became irrelevant because you keep changing the ORBAT and it's a five second google to find out on your own.
 
Thanks for the support but unfortunately it seems to be only Bill Cameron and (a still very unhappy) Mote who are responding regularly.


Robdab2,

That's hardly fair, is it? ;)

If you care to notice, like so many others I've actually quit responding to your ideas. What we would all like to see now is how you're going to use those ideas. That's why I and, I suspect, many others keep reading.

The discussion about whether your ideas are "good" or "plausible" is now moot. We tried talking about plausible PODs at first, but you're having none of it, so that part of the thread is over. All we want to see now is what your timeline is going to do.

The POD is very flawed - but also very intriguing. That means the timeline should be interesting too - whether it is actually "good" AH or not.

So, enough with defending the POD. Get on with the rest of the show! ;)


Bill
 
Last edited:
Finally!

I've kept tuning into this thread only to see long and pointless point-by-point attacks, rebuttals, and rejoinders about details and presumptions, and no exploration of what could be an interesting ATL.
 

robdab2

Banned
Gents,

I understand that you'd all like some good (IMLTHO), free entertainment but I just have to ask, other than typing practise, what do I get out of an AH TL exercise ?

I invest lots of time and energy in exchange for ... ?

At least in a debate situation I occassionally get a little bit of constructive criticism from which to further expand my ideas.

If I were to write an Oahu novel or an Invasion Hawaii wargame I might at least attain some permanent recognition for my efforts.

Why should I write a TL here ?
 
Top