What if peace talk Israel had with Arabs 1949 were successful

Jason222

Banned
Let say Egypt agree hand over Gaze strip to Israel. Syria agree take 300,000 Palestinian Refugee in Lebanon and Syria in return for half the Lake Tiberias Israel give up. Jordan just decide assimilation it Palestinian population why they did normal timeline. My personal views peace fall part . Because one person name and his Nasser of Egypt. Point he still had issues with Israel one way or other. Syria likely stay neutral since did major Palestinian population and same goes with Lebanon. Jordan and Egypt be war with Israel for simple reason Nasser few Zionist European colonist aim remove Imperial powers Israel on the lists and Jordan because more half population been Palestinian hard time stay out. Israel on other hand number advance that they did not have in the normal timeline for one thing USA no problem selling Israel arms. Israel might real burn midnight oil join NATO mean time. Arab states one thing impossible tells. Many Arab states hate Egypt all hearts might well keep friendly relationship Israel. USSR relations Israel still been bad maybe not as bad.
 
As I recall the Palestinians loved rule by other Arabs so much that the Fatah movement rose to power on the basis of attacking Arabs occupying the Palestinian territories, exploiting those grievances. Then they went from there to attempting to take over first Jordan and then Lebanon. Palestinians have never liked being ruled by anyone else, Israeli or Arab. They are not monoliths following some nebulous Arab view, they're nationalists in their own right according to their own agendas.
 

Jason222

Banned
As I recall the Palestinians loved rule by other Arabs so much that the Fatah movement rose to power on the basis of attacking Arabs occupying the Palestinian territories, exploiting those grievances. Then they went from there to attempting to take over first Jordan and then Lebanon. Palestinians have never liked being ruled by anyone else, Israeli or Arab. They are not monoliths following some nebulous Arab view, they're nationalists in their own right according to their own agendas.
Palestinian no shape range uprising against Syria government. Syria goverment little problem crush rebel like unwanted bug Those 300,000 well under control. Jordan again Palestinian Arab you just another black sept like said Jordan could see go war with Israel. Arab under Israel rule must want be under Israel rule. Only 30% all Arab Israeli want to move Palestine state today in past something like 14%.
 
Palestinian no shape range uprising against Syria government. Syria goverment little problem crush rebel like unwanted bug Those 300,000 well under control. Jordan again Palestinian Arab you just another black sept like said Jordan could see go war with Israel. Arab under Israel rule must want be under Israel rule. Only 30% all Arab Israeli want to move Palestine state today in past something like 14%.

Virgil, can you put that into English even Caesar can understand?
 
Palestinian no shape range uprising against Syria government. Syria goverment little problem crush rebel like unwanted bug Those 300,000 well under control. Jordan again Palestinian Arab you just another black sept like said Jordan could see go war with Israel. Arab under Israel rule must want be under Israel rule. Only 30% all Arab Israeli want to move Palestine state today in past something like 14%.
More verbs necessary.
 
Palestinian no shape range uprising against Syria government. Syria goverment little problem crush rebel like unwanted bug Those 300,000 well under control. Jordan again Palestinian Arab you just another black sept like said Jordan could see go war with Israel. Arab under Israel rule must want be under Israel rule. Only 30% all Arab Israeli want to move Palestine state today in past something like 14%.

um....
 
Give him a bit of a break. He's clearly not a native english speaker, and probably speaks something with a very different grammar. Chinese?

Jason: it IS very difficult to understand your thoughts. Even though google translate is pretty bad, it might still be worth your while to use it.
Edit: and make fewer posts with more care to each.
 
Last edited:
Jason, thank you for using a spelling checker. However, that only means each word is correct. It doesn't mean that your words, together, make up complete thoughts. You seem to be leaving out a lot of words and a lot of suffixes on the words you do have.

Is something like this what you meant?

Palestinians are in no shape to arrange an uprising against the Syrian government. The Syrian goverment will have little problem crushing the rebels like unwanted bugs. Those 300,000 will be well under control. [I can't make sense of the rest of the post.]

Palestinians were very happy under Jordan's rule; most of them did wish to return. So why once in Syria would it be any different; they for the must part would just assimilate in-words.
 
Top