what if Arab during Palestinain Arab revolt in 1937 until 1939 were united.

Jason222

Banned
If Palestinian Arab during 1937 until 1939 had one leader united them during Arab revolt real slaughter would happen. UK bend crushing them and Zionist were welling provide aid to crush Arab revolt 1937 until 1939. There lot fewer Arabs in Palestine once dust settle like Jews state came existed.
 
Why do so many of your PODs want Palestinians slaughtered? In any event the Israelis had done a good job already of ensuring no unified Palestinian economic or cultural basis could exist, if one did it's arguable that the Israeli state would never come to exist, while the UK would be in a deep bind as they will go to a White Paper faster, possibly touching off a 1944-8 style terrorist campaign from the ZIONISTS earlier and resulting in a British crackdown on Haganah and Irgun.....
 

Jason222

Banned
Why do so many of your PODs want Palestinians slaughtered? In any event the Israelis had done a good job already of ensuring no unified Palestinian economic or cultural basis could exist, if one did it's arguable that the Israeli state would never come to exist, while the UK would be in a deep bind as they will go to a White Paper faster, possibly touching off a 1944-8 style terrorist campaign from the ZIONISTS earlier and resulting in a British crackdown on Haganah and Irgun.....

You can not blame Zionist for Palestinian no real from nationalism. The Ottoman Empire did what in power undermine any from Nationalism might change rule. Only reason Zionist successful was because force reckon with. They had lot power cards things Palestinians would have until at least after Israel war of independent, Many them been way behind Palestinian Arab reach hand section leader best able lead the movement. They had state art ambassador and back major power some them by the way Ottoman Empire even look and even allies also bribery and blackmail. Earliest a real Palestine Arab nationalist movement get start basic early possible could. Palestinian Arabs need free Ottoman Empire happen in 1919. First major anti Jews riots basic could call start Palestinian Arab nationalistic movement happen 1920 until 1929. Only reason happen fast as it did was because religion leadership. If religion conflict not happens between Jews and muslin in Jerusalem been national movement until 1947 or 1949.

However it is possible better religion leader did try get rids enemy instead turn enemy into allies He could Palestinian Arab population under his control. UK first crush revolt even thinking turn white papers other wise. With something 99% all Arab men taking part fighting something rather 10% Arab male population either exile, died or in jail. The UK recapture Palestine take may few more months rather 10% male population died likely been 40% male population killed. Number killed likely lead UK allows open door policy only men vote at first democracy. Lead Jews majority open door police Jews refugees that flee Nazi Germany.
 
You can not blame Zionist for Palestinian no real from nationalism. The Ottoman Empire did what in power undermine any from Nationalism might change rule. Only reason Zionist successful was because force reckon with. They had lot power cards things Palestinians would have until at least after Israel war of independent, Many them been way behind Palestinian Arab reach hand section leader best able lead the movement. They had state art ambassador and back major power some them by the way Ottoman Empire even look and even allies also bribery and blackmail. Earliest a real Palestine Arab nationalist movement get start basic early possible could. Palestinian Arabs need free Ottoman Empire happen in 1919. First major anti Jews riots basic could call start Palestinian Arab nationalistic movement happen 1920 until 1929. Only reason happen fast as it did was because religion leadership. If religion conflict not happens between Jews and muslin in Jerusalem been national movement until 1947 or 1949.

However it is possible better religion leader did try get rids enemy instead turn enemy into allies He could Palestinian Arab population under his control. UK first crush revolt even thinking turn white papers other wise. With something 99% all Arab men taking part fighting something rather 10% Arab male population either exile, died or in jail. The UK recapture Palestine take may few more months rather 10% male population died likely been 40% male population killed. Number killed likely lead UK allows open door policy only men vote at first democracy. Lead Jews majority open door police Jews refugees that flee Nazi Germany.

No, the only reason Zionism succeeded was from exploiting the British Empire. They did so well, mind, but the Zionists are nothing but Rhodesia for Jews. It would be a lot easier to bother with your threads if you bothered to make your posts legible and intelligible, FWIW.
 

Jason222

Banned
No, the only reason Zionism succeeded was from exploiting the British Empire. They did so well, mind, but the Zionists are nothing but Rhodesia for Jews. It would be a lot easier to bother with your threads if you bothered to make your posts legible and intelligible, FWIW.
Must of these jews ansters had live Palestine before Roman conquest. Palestinain Arabs on other hand good number Egyptians. Beside Zionist in many ways did Ottoman Empire to thier advange.
 
Must of these jews ansters had live Palestine before Roman conquest. Palestinain Arabs on other hand good number Egyptians. Beside Zionist in many ways did Ottoman Empire to thier advange.

By this logic Native Americans have every right to reclaim states the US government claimed from them by bad faith and genocide, as after all there was a white population of all of 0 there in 1491. The thing is that the Palestinians were the natives of Palestine, and an overwhelmin majority of the founders of Israel were European, not Middle Eastern, and to put it bluntly discriminated against the real Jews of the region to favor themselves, foreign Jews, over the real Jews of the Middle East and the Arabs. No dice.
 
Nassirisimo, logic and reason on the board?:(


Strange this thread as I recall that Palestinian leadership during this period fell into two categories: the Mufti of Jerusalem and dead rivals.
 
Nassirisimo, logic and reason on the board?:(


Strange this thread as I recall that Palestinian leadership during this period fell into two categories: the Mufti of Jerusalem and dead rivals.

A crude but accurate description. :( Palestinians have had the worst string of so-called leaders any people could be saddled with. :(
 

Jason222

Banned
A crude but accurate description. :( Palestinians have had the worst string of so-called leaders any people could be saddled with. :(

I agree last 100 years the Palestinians have not had effect leader. Also odds Palestinian leader able unit different Palestinian leaders extremely unlikely the Mufti of Jerusalem for start would made hard even out him extremely difficult Mufti of Jerusalem could hardly only when blame Palestinian Arab failures . However not made it impossible at least theory it could have happen. Again if they did have united leadership Palestinian Arab during the Arab revolt in 1936 until likely 1940 UK massive Jews immigrant into Palestinian. Very possible Arab revolt had been united turn Palestine Jews majority sooner.
 

Jason222

Banned
Jason222, to be honest, I haven't a clue what you just posted.
That in practice Palestinian Arab needed order to be unit during 1936 Arab revolt the best leader all history.
If Palestinian Arab somehow get they had longer revolt might well spill into World War II. Palestinian Arab real collaborating with Nazi Germany in all likelihood in this timeline.
 
I think he means he can't understand the way you write. Neither can I to be honest. I'm guessing English isn't your first language?
 
Top