What if albanians in Greece convert in judaism what the history then!!!!

It is a posibilite that arvanites origins was from caucasus area and why not become judaizers like tudela think about vlachs population of greece there are turkish christianity so as

No possibility. Caucasian Albanians probably didn't even speak an Indo-European language, and were not referred to as Albanians by their neighbours (Armenians and Persians), and were assimilated by the modern peoples who inhabit their land (mostly Azeri). They have as much relation to Euro-Albanians as Georgians have to residents of Georgia in the United States. Euro-Albanians are Shqiptars, Caucasian Albanians are something.

But why would you pick a third option when such a third option is automatically destructive? The Khazars got away with it--for a while. I don't buy Albanians, or some segment of them, being Jews to avoid that. Number one, what mass conversions to Judaism were there? Some Arab tribes pre-Islam were Jews, some Berber tribes were reported as being Jews (but other reports show many of them as Christians--maybe a veneer of Christianity, I think it shows they weren't quite converted to any religion or another), some sub-Saharan African groups were Jews, most notably the Beta Israel of Ethiopia. But the conditions that made those people Jews (being on the fringe of the Mediterrean world in that era) does not exist in the time and place of the Arvanites.

Judaism gains nothing, besides a host of antisemitic conspiracy theories at best and at worst, no allies to defend you from whoever wants to invade you.
 
It is a posibilite that arvanites origins was from caucasus area and why not become judaizers like tudela think about vlachs population of greece there are turkish christianity so as

Counterweight those populations could choose judaism or a form of that time!! like vlachs the arvanites they didnt hellinized before 19 century so as an alternative to turkish rulers nd albanian muslim population and greek clegry sould judaizer.

Might I suggest you refine your grammar a little more? I'm having a hard time following what you're saying, and the lack of punctuation makes me think its not just a language barrier.
 
they would probably be immediately invaded and cursaded or genocided because medieval christianity wasnt big on judaism though islam was so maybe the turks come and treat them as people of the book and then invade italy and the jewbanians fund colonies to the new world so then america becomes jewbanian!!!!!!!!!
 
they would probably be immediately invaded and cursaded or genocided because medieval christianity wasnt big on judaism though islam was so maybe the turks come and treat them as people of the book and then invade italy and the jewbanians fund colonies to the new world so then america becomes jewbanian!!!!!!!!!

Strictly speaking, medieval Christianity was absolutely fine with Judaism. Its just that most medieval Christians weren't (the Church often had to step in and tell people to knock it off with the whole 'lets kill the Jews cuz there's no Muslims handy' idea).
 

CalBear

Moderator
Donor
Monthly Donor
they would probably be immediately invaded and cursaded or genocided because medieval christianity wasnt big on judaism though islam was so maybe the turks come and treat them as people of the book and then invade italy and the jewbanians fund colonies to the new world so then america becomes jewbanian!!!!!!!!!
Is there a reason you went out of your way to mock this?
 
I think that benjamin of tudela see judaizers vlach population so why not the albanian arvanites can do the same! and remove the clergy ordodox christianity that greeks want for them and not choose a religion that it was the archetype! something like the subbotniki jews of russia it was a nice possibility.
 
Last edited:
Top