What happens at Chancellorsville if Jacksonville lives?

Edward IX

Banned
I am wondering if I could get opinions about what happens in specific at Chancellorsville if Jackson lives? I am not asking SO Jackson had been at Gettysburg, that has been done. Had the battle reached its climax or could the army have been crushed against the Potomac river or in the United States Ford? What is the likely outcome do you think? I think Stuart handled the Jackson's Corps competently enough but did not use it as aggressively (well like Jackson would have).

I will also be asking in the next few days about what opinions are if that cannon ball had taken out Hooker. I am planning a TL and trying to determine my POD.
 
Jackson, shortly before his wounding, had been hoping to get between the Army of the Potomac and the fords of the Rapphannock, specifically United States Ford, and had instructed his senior division commander AP Hill to prepare a night attack to accomplish that end. Jackson was not specifically instructed to attempt this, but it was very much in line with Lee and Jackson's hopes of achieving the destruction of the Army of the Potomac in the field. But such hopes were shot down with Jackson, for AP Hill too was struck down by friendly fire in the woods near the Orange Turnpike, though non-fatally, and this fundamentally changed the plan. Hill was the only one who had any idea what Jackson was planning, as Jackson was notoriously secretive with his subordinates.

If Jackson had not been shot, A.P. Hill’s ‘Light’ Division would attempted to seize the U.S. Ford through a night attack. A night attack, in addition to the inherent difficulties of such, would have brought Jackson up against fresh Union troops and would have been highly unlikely to achieve his hopes for it. The III Corps still occupied Hazel Grove with 34 guns posted, and the divisions of Berry (III Corps), Alpheus Williams (XII Corps), a supporting brigade from the II Corps and a mix of willing men from XI Corps were already in position to face any attack from A.P. Hill. In addition, 37 guns had been posted at Fairview under Captain Best.

By then, Jackson’s flank attack had already sputtered out. The 30,000 man Corps had been completely disorganized due to Jackson’s faulty deployment of the line and the fighting with the XI Corps. Only A.P. Hill’s division was in any state to continue the attack to U.S. Ford. If May 3rd is anything to go by, A.P. Hill’s attack would be repelled and the Confederates would be in an even worse position than OTL and rely on Mr F.J. Hooker to bail themselves out as historical.
 
Last edited:
To be honest from what I have read Jackson did all he could reasonably given the time the attack started and the circumstances at the time.
 
Top