For a total British victory, let's look at the terms Britain demanded in August 1814 at Ghent (as things turned out, they were as unrealistic as the US terms of 1813 but again we are assuming a total British victory here):
The British held out for an Indian buffer state in the Northwest, and also demanded that the Americans not maintain warships on the waters of the Great Lakes or forts upon their shores. The British right of navigation of the Mississippi, agreed on in 1783, would be maintained, but with boundary adjustments to allow the British access to the river from Lake Superior; the northern part of Maine would also have to be ceded in order to provide more direct communication between Quebec and Halifax. The British retreated from these terms not only because of military setbacks in America and Wellington's refusal to go there but also because of the deteriorating situation in Europe--the victorious Allies were quarreling with each other, there were rumors of an impending Bonapartist coup against the French government, etc.
For details on the Indian boundary state:
"Within a week, Lord Castlereagh sent precise instructions which confirmed the worst fears of the Americans. The Indian boundary line was to follow the line of the Treaty of Greenville and beyond it neither nation was to acquire land. The United States was asked, in short, to set apart for the Indians in perpetuity an area which comprised the present States of Michigan, Wisconsin, and Illinois, four-fifths of Indiana, and a third of Ohio. But, remonstrated Gallatin, this area included States and Territories settled by more than a hundred thousand American citizens. What was to be done with them? 'They must look after themselves,' was the blunt answer." http://www.gutenberg.org/files/3004/3004-h/3004-h.htm
See http://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/greenvil.asp for the text of the Treaty of Greenville and http://score.rims.k12.ca.us/score_lessons/treaty_greenville/media/treatygreenvillemap.gif for a map.
To insist on this 1795 line in 1814 seems amazingly unrealistic in retrospect, but remember that in 1814 "Britain and Indians still held Michilimackinac, Prarie du Chien on the upper Mississippi, and most of Michigan and Wisconsin. With Wellington's veterans preparing to embark from French ports and the United States on the verge of bankruptcy, fighting its most unpopular war, Britain and the Indians became optimistic about making territorial adjustments." J. Leitch Wright, Jr., *Britain and the American Frontier 1783-1815* (Athens: University of Georgia Press 1975), p. 167.
The British held out for an Indian buffer state in the Northwest, and also demanded that the Americans not maintain warships on the waters of the Great Lakes or forts upon their shores. The British right of navigation of the Mississippi, agreed on in 1783, would be maintained, but with boundary adjustments to allow the British access to the river from Lake Superior; the northern part of Maine would also have to be ceded in order to provide more direct communication between Quebec and Halifax. The British retreated from these terms not only because of military setbacks in America and Wellington's refusal to go there but also because of the deteriorating situation in Europe--the victorious Allies were quarreling with each other, there were rumors of an impending Bonapartist coup against the French government, etc.
For details on the Indian boundary state:
"Within a week, Lord Castlereagh sent precise instructions which confirmed the worst fears of the Americans. The Indian boundary line was to follow the line of the Treaty of Greenville and beyond it neither nation was to acquire land. The United States was asked, in short, to set apart for the Indians in perpetuity an area which comprised the present States of Michigan, Wisconsin, and Illinois, four-fifths of Indiana, and a third of Ohio. But, remonstrated Gallatin, this area included States and Territories settled by more than a hundred thousand American citizens. What was to be done with them? 'They must look after themselves,' was the blunt answer." http://www.gutenberg.org/files/3004/3004-h/3004-h.htm
See http://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/greenvil.asp for the text of the Treaty of Greenville and http://score.rims.k12.ca.us/score_lessons/treaty_greenville/media/treatygreenvillemap.gif for a map.
To insist on this 1795 line in 1814 seems amazingly unrealistic in retrospect, but remember that in 1814 "Britain and Indians still held Michilimackinac, Prarie du Chien on the upper Mississippi, and most of Michigan and Wisconsin. With Wellington's veterans preparing to embark from French ports and the United States on the verge of bankruptcy, fighting its most unpopular war, Britain and the Indians became optimistic about making territorial adjustments." J. Leitch Wright, Jr., *Britain and the American Frontier 1783-1815* (Athens: University of Georgia Press 1975), p. 167.