War aims of a "Nazi" France?

Xgentis

Xgentis

Kome said:
Not really. Thread isnt ASB so it wouldnt really fit there.

Dont be so up tight, its just a fun thought exercise. :D
Click to expand...
But that's impossible France can't do that it could turn fascist but not start a war and conquer most of europe they did not have the ressource to do so.
 

pompejus

Kome said:
Not really. Thread isnt ASB so it wouldnt really fit there.

Dont be so up tight, its just a fun thought exercise. :D
Click to expand...
That would just open the door to discussing operation sealion, the landings in Frisia or Philip II moving towards the Americas.
 
Marc Pasquin

Marc Pasquin

Maponus said:
What you'd need in order to make this a ideology capable of taking power is to unite the various right-wing factions in France together, possibly involving the Rexists as well if we think that's realistic, into a single French Integralist Party with Action Française playing the role of the Deutschvölkische Freiheitspartei and the Croix-de-Feu playing the role of the Deutschnationale Volkspartei. You have the Cercle Proudhon types as the equalivent of the Strasser-Rohem faction.
Click to expand...

I wonder if they would adopt the symbol used by the cercle proudhon in their publication. Distinctive enough though it doesn't scream "french" to many. Then again, nothing particularly distinctly german about the swastika from an historical point of view either.

cercle-proudhon.png
 

Tocomocho

*googles images of Croix de Feu*

croix-de-feu-front-national.jpg


Wow. These Croix de Feu guys had little qualms telling the world that they were evil, weren't they?
 

Wolfpaw

Banned
Exaltation of death is a common trope among fascist organizations. You had the SS love of the Totenkopf, Mussolini's Blackshirts and Falangists alike cried, "Viva la morte/muerte!", the list goes on.
 

pompejus

The Vulture said:
Do you actually know what ASB means?
Click to expand...
There are two definitions of ASB. One that says that only everything that includes magic, aliens, gods, etc is ASB. The other one is that everything that is extremely unlikely is ASB, like succesful sealion, the Frisian landings or probably a relatively succesful expansion Nazi-like France with a POD after the first world war (or after a lost first world war).

Although I think only the first definition is valid (but many use the second definition), I do think that scenario's that fit the second definition are not worth discussing here seriously. As I said it opens the door to a lot of discussion we (well I at least) do not want here, like discussing sealion or the Frisian landings.

PS sorry Xgentis for metioning the Frisian landings again
 
Xgentis

Xgentis

pompejus said:
There are two definitions of ASB. One that says that only everything that includes magic, aliens, gods, etc is ASB. The other one is that everything that is extremely unlikely is ASB, like succesful sealion, the Frisian landings or probably a relatively succesful expansion Nazi-like France with a POD after the first world war (or after a lost first world war).

Although I think only the first definition is valid (but many use the second definition), I do think that scenario's that fit the second definition are not worth discussing here seriously. As I said it opens the door to a lot of discussion we (well I at least) do not want here, like discussing sealion or the Frisian landings.

PS sorry Xgentis for metioning the Frisian landings again
Click to expand...
Did you know that the guy tryed to sell his timeline on another site with similar result lol. Look at this.
https://www.alternatehistory.com/discussion/showthread.php?t=213211
http://www.armchairgeneral.com/forums/showthread.php?p=2059154
The guy was obstinate lol
No more talking about this.:eek:
 
Maponus

Maponus

Tocomocho said:
*googles images of Croix de Feu*

*evil skull of death*

Wow. These Croix de Feu guys had little qualms telling the world that they were evil, weren't they?
Click to expand...

Funny thing is they turned out as a completely respectable right-of-center party, by the standards of the time.

I wonder if they would adopt the symbol used by the cercle proudhon in their publication. Distinctive enough though it doesn't scream "french" to many. Then again, nothing particularly distinctly german about the swastika from an historical point of view either.
Click to expand...

That was cercle proudhon's symbol? So that's where it came from!

Damn Russians, can't they use anything original?
 
varyar

varyar

Xgentis said:
Yeah I know but post WWI France who is able to goble Europe is what I call ASB.
Click to expand...

It might be a little late to point out that asking what a Nazi France would want is not the same as saying that's what a Nazi France could achieve, but the former, not the latter, is what I had in mind. Ultranationalists with wild fantasies of conquest is, alas, not ASB.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top
Top