Union and Liberty: An American TL

Part Twenty: Coming Together and Growing Apart
And now another update.

Part Twenty: Coming Together and Growing Apart

A Continental Idea:
With increasing amounts of people traveling west, many entrepreneurs and politicians saw a need for an eventual link between the Atlantic and Pacific Coasts in the United States. During the Douglas administration, many proposals were brought to Congress for rail lines connecting the two coasts. Some suggested routes started from Saint Louis or Chicago, which had already been connected back to the major east coast cities, while others proposed paths going up to Minneapolis and then west.

The western end of the proposed transcontinental railway was often more varied. Some proposals desired to keep the railroad in the United States and ended the railway at one of the small but fast-growing costal towns in Oregon Territory. Others saw a more southerly route that passed through the California Republic to end in Monterrey, Yerba Buena, or San Diego. Despite the great interest taken by the government in completing a rail line between the two coasts, sectionalism between north and south stopped any major progress until the 1870s when private companies expanded west.

Popular Sovereignty:
With many Americans moving west into the Great Plains, Stephen Douglas passed a bill in 1854 with support from former Vice President Lewis Cass that would open up Kearny Territory to further settlement. With the bill he advocated the position of popular sovereignty and letting the people of a territory decide whether it would allow slavery when it was admitted to the Union. This led to increasing problems as ardent abolitionists and Southern slaveholders moved into the territory to promote their respective positions.

In the months after the bill was passed, both slaveholders and freesoilers poured into the territory. Slaveholders from Missouri and Arkansaw soon clashed with freesoilers from Chicago and New England. These settlers came at odds with each other as the frontier towns swelled with people, and in spring of 1855 violence broke out that would soon engulf the entire territory. The violence began with what is now known as the Haarlem Riots. The town of Haarlem lies on the Sparne River[1] near where it joins the Arakansaw, and grew during the opening of Kearny Territory because of its proximity to Arkansaw and Missouri. In the decade after the city's founding, it had grown to over two thousand people. With such growth, slavery became a great issue in the town. In April of 1855, the murder of a freesoiler by one of the slaveholders in the town spiraled out of control into general violence. The riot lasted almost the entire day before law was restored in the town and in all, seven people were killed.

This sparked more riots in the rest of the territory as a proslavery legislature came into power. In July, noted abolitionist John Brown attempted to bar the legislature from entering the territorial capital at Council Grove. While John Brown was killed in the resulting skirmish, he was remembered and soon became a martyr for the freesoilers in Kearny Territory. After further threats against the legislators, the territorial capital of Kearny was relocated southward to Fort Gibson. In response, the freesoilers set up their own territorial legislature in Council Grove. While the violence gradually decreased in 1856, the competing legislatures lasted long after Douglas's administration and the events of 1855 and 1856 greatly hurt Douglas in the eyes of the American people.

[1] The Canadian River
 
And...the accompanying image for this section, which also has an interesting little tidbit of info.

TCRR_Lee_Proposed.png
 
Another great update Wilcox. John Brown always dies in these TLs. I've yet to see him die of old age. :p

People always seem to forget Lee was an engineer first before he became lord of the battlefield.
 
Another great update Wilcox. John Brown always dies in these TLs. I've yet to see him die of old age. :p
Hehe. John Brown is too radical to die of old age. :D

People always seem to forget Lee was an engineer first before he became lord of the battlefield.
Yeah, I saw that about him and figured that without the Mexican-American War to bring him to the front, Lee would just stay in the Corps of Engineers and eventually become the chief.
 
Wilcoxchar
I have few questions regarding The Rio Grande Republic and the Republic of California:
Is the border between The Rio Grande Republic and the US the Rio Grande or the Nueces River? The capital of Rio should be Laredo which is on the US side of the Rio Grande in OTL. Like Texas they also claimed the Nueces Strip as theirs when they declared independence. In fact the Nueces strip was part of the provinces of Tamaulipas and Coahuila. If it is part of the US then I guess Rio doesn't like this very much and has to think of a new capital, Monterey or Victoria would seem most logical.
Secondly because the Republic of California was mostly empty, I am guessing much of the emigration from Mexico is landing here. Once again this would be giving California a very Hispanic flavor particularly in the south. And I guess the North remains white but it is soon to be the minority. Also aiding the growth of California would be immigrants from Asia. What is the relationship between all these groups? Does the white north still want annexation to the US? Its been a few years and there has been time to develop a California identity. How will the Hispanic south react to this?
Once again awesome TL looking forward for some updates
 
Bump!

So in any case, what are your plans for Russian Alaska and Canada?
Yeah, sorry about not updating this week. Was pretty busy/lazy. :D I'll try to get the next update in tonight or tomorrow though.

Not sure what I'm going to do with Alaska yet, but I have plans for Canada. Probably splitting it into two countries eventually.

Wilcoxchar
I have few questions regarding The Rio Grande Republic and the Republic of California:
Is the border between The Rio Grande Republic and the US the Rio Grande or the Nueces River? The capital of Rio should be Laredo which is on the US side of the Rio Grande in OTL. Like Texas they also claimed the Nueces Strip as theirs when they declared independence. In fact the Nueces strip was part of the provinces of Tamaulipas and Coahuila. If it is part of the US then I guess Rio doesn't like this very much and has to think of a new capital, Monterey or Victoria would seem most logical.
Secondly because the Republic of California was mostly empty, I am guessing much of the emigration from Mexico is landing here. Once again this would be giving California a very Hispanic flavor particularly in the south. And I guess the North remains white but it is soon to be the minority. Also aiding the growth of California would be immigrants from Asia. What is the relationship between all these groups? Does the white north still want annexation to the US? Its been a few years and there has been time to develop a California identity. How will the Hispanic south react to this?
Once again awesome TL looking forward for some updates
The border between the Rio Bravo Republic and the US is the Rio Grande. I didn't know that they claimed up to the Nueces as well, but I suppose with the US helping Texas outright and assisting them, the Rio Bravo Republic ITTL would have given up that claim in exchange for assistance. The capital will probably be Monterrey. I probably won't mention the Rio Bravo Republic for a bit but they will certainly come up in the 1870s.

As for California, I wouldn't think there would be many Anglos in the northern area besides the Mormons yet. But that will change in the next update or two. ;) For now, California is still sparsely populated besides the coast, but towns are appearing in OTL Arizona and western New Mexico as people migrate north.
 
Yeah, sorry about not updating this week. Was pretty busy/lazy. :D I'll try to get the next update in tonight or tomorrow though.

No need to apologize dude. I'm just trying to raise awareness for an awesome TL.

Not sure what I'm going to do with Alaska yet, but I have plans for Canada. Probably splitting it into two countries eventually.

Well, I'l be the first to admit that Canada has great potential in your timeline. Already, the remains of OTL Canada would have at least two Countries if the Acadian Union isn't absorbed, and I can even see the lands of Canada being divided into 4-5 Countries if the cards are played right. So how about this little Scenario?

Now we all know that after the Oregon War, Britian would be more supportive of TTL's version of the Confederacy. So WI after TTL's version of the ACW, the U.S. decides to dismantle Britian's Sphere of Influence in the Canadas? I would say the best method of doing this woud be secretly funding Republican Movements in Quebec since this region would naturally appear to have the least amount of love for the crown.

Now, lets have America do this for Thirty Years or so until they finally manage to start a large scale revolution in Quebec. Next, we can have the United States declare War on Canada and Great Britain for two reasons. (Despite if they were sound or not)

#1. Both the Canadian and British Governments have denied the people of Quebec their natural right to form a democratic republic.

#2. Both the Canadian and British Governments have denied Americans access to the American territories of Alaska and Greenland

(Which would be purchased from Russia and Denmark respectively. Plus, The Greenland part isn't ASB since the U.S. tried to do this in the OTL.)

Logically, this would be a very intense war and would replace the Spanish-American War as the war that helps to heal North and South Relations. As for the results, we could see this in an American victory.

#1. A Republic of Quebec- Puppet of U.S. originally, but could grow into a loyal Ally of both the U.S. and France.(A little Geo-Political Love Triangle.;))

#2. A Republic of Ontario- Extremely Anti-American U.S. Puppet that could one day restore the Monarchy

#3. The Holy Republic of Manitoba- As we all know, most timelines will produce the Deseret Cliche, but why not at least do it in Manitoba? Your Timeline already had mormons in Manitoba, plus if the U.S. does decide to banish the Californian mormons, Manitoba could prove to be a useful dumping ground. As for actual territory, it would probably have most of Manitoba and part of Saskactchewan.

#4. American gains- I could see Congress justifying OTL Alberta, Upper B.C., the Northwest territory, Nunavut, and non-mormon Manitoba/Saskachewan as needed for "proper access" to both Alaska and Greenland. Personally, this version of Ameriwank is at ;east different then the generic "Annex all Canada."

Now this just leaves us with Newfoundland and the Acadian Union. I woud think that these two nations would remain in Britian's Sphere and be even more Pro-British/Anti-American then Ontario. Newfoundland may even join the A.U. Still, Quebec might get Labrador.

In any case, if you did the above, the Liberty part of your TL would certainly be more interesting. How would the U.S. deal with Freedom of Religion Issues and Womens' Rights in Mormon Manitoba. Would the U.S. continue to Nuture Quebec democracy? How would the U.S. react if the people of Ontario decided to re-establish the Monarchy?

Still, this is your TL, and you can certaintly do whatever you want. But, it would be awesome if you did any of the above and I would be glad to discuss more with you through PMs or whatever about Canada since I'm currently studying about the country for citizenship reasons.

Oh, I'm sorry for this extremely long post but I would like to ask you two more questions.

#1. When does Sam Houston become President?

#2. If the U.S. does annex the Rio Bravo, will it be a single state called Rio Bravo, or be divided into the three States that make up the republic?

Thanks Again, and congrats on such an awesome timeline!:D
 
Last edited:
No need to apologize dude. I'm just trying to raise awareness for an awesome TL.
Well, I'm apologizing because I always say I'll post an update at a certain time and I rarely ever meet the deadline. :D



Well, I'l be the first to admit that Canada has great potential in your timeline. Already, the remains of OTL Canada would have at least two Countries if the Acadian Union isn't absorbed, and I can even see the lands of Canada being divided into 4-5 Countries if the cards are played right. So how about this little Scenario?

Now we all know that after the Oregon War, Britian would be more supportive of TTL's version of the Confederacy. So WI after TTL's version of the ACW, the U.S. decides to dismantle Britian's Sphere of Influence in the Canadas? I would say the best method of doing this woud be secretly funding Republican Movements in Quebec since this region would naturally appear to have the least amount of love for the crown.

Now, lets have America do this for Thirty Years or so until they finally manage to start a large scale revolution in Quebec. Next, we can have the United States declare War on Canada and Great Britain for two reasons. (Despite if they were sound or not)

#1. Both the Canadian and British Governments have denied the people of Quebec their natural right to form a democratic republic.

#2. Both the Canadian and British Governments have denied Americans access to the American territories of Alaska and Greenland

(Which would be purchased from Russia and Denmark respectively. Plus, The Greenland part isn't ASB since the U.S. tried to do this in the OTL.)

Logically, this would be a very intense war and would replace the Spanish-American War as the war that helps to heal North and South Relations. As for the results, we could see this in an American victory.

#1. A Republic of Quebec- Puppet of U.S. originally, but could grow into a loyal Ally of both the U.S. and France.(A little Geo-Political Love Triangle.;))

#2. A Republic of Ontario- Extremely Anti-American U.S. Puppet that could one day restore the Monarchy

#3. The Holy Republic of Manitoba- As we all know, most timelines will produce the Deseret Cliche, but why not at least do it in Manitoba? Your Timeline already had mormons in Manitoba, plus if the U.S. does decide to banish the Californian mormons, Manitoba could prove to be a useful dumping ground. As for actual territory, it would probably have most of Manitoba and part of Saskactchewan.

#4. American gains- I could see Congress justifying OTL Alberta, Upper B.C., the Northwest territory, Nunavut, and non-mormon Manitoba/Saskachewan as needed for "proper access" to both Alaska and Greenland. Personally, this version of Ameriwank is at ;east different then the generic "Annex all Canada."

Now this just leaves us with Newfoundland and the Acadian Union. I woud think that these two nations would remain in Britian's Sphere and be even more Pro-British/Anti-American then Ontario. Newfoundland may even join the A.U. Still, Quebec might get Labrador.

In any case, if you did the above, the Liberty part of your TL would certainly be more interesting. How would the U.S. deal with Freedom of Religion Issues and Womens' Rights in Mormon Manitoba. Would the U.S. continue to Nuture Quebec democracy? How would the U.S. react if the people of Ontario decided to re-establish the Monarchy?

Still, this is your TL, and you can certaintly do whatever you want. But, it would be awesome if you did any of the above and I would be glad to discuss more with you through PMs or whatever about Canada since I'm currently studying about the country for citizenship reasons.
Wow, thanks for the ideas! You've included at least one thing that I plan on having happen with Canada but I'll definitely consider those ideas when deciding what to do with it later.

Oh, I'm sorry for this extremely long post but I would like to ask you two more questions.

#1. When does Sam Houston become President?

#2. If the U.S. does annex the Rio Bravo, will it be a single state called Rio Bravo, or be divided into the three States that make up the republic?

Thanks Again, and congrats on such an awesome timeline!:D
Houston will become President soon, and if the US does annex Rio Bravo, it will become one state (the current name for the possible state is Coahuila, might change it though).
 
Part Twenty-One: The Adventures of William Walker
Finally got another update finished. It will only include one bit, because I had no idea that this section would be as long as it turned out. Also, I don't know how plausible some of the parts of this are, most of this just sounded cool or interesting to me.

Part Twenty-One: The Adventures of William Walker

Adventures of William Walker:
In the 1850s, there were many in the southern United States who desired to extend slavery throughout the Caribbean and Central America. Scoieties such as the Knights of the Golden Circle advocated the idea, and helped encourage adventurous Americans to expand the reach of slavery themselves. The most successful and well known of these adventurers or 'filibusters' as they became known was William Walker.

In 1853, Walker went on a recruiting campaign in the southern states for expanding slavery in the Caribbean and possibly bringing the areas they conquered into the United States as slave states. Gathering only 70 men on the continent, Walker went to Cuba to gather more men. There he met with Narciso López, who joined him and helped to recruit over 200 more men into Walker's band. The next summer, Walker and López set off from Cuba to Haiti, where they landed on Tortuga. The men went to Port Paix on the mainland and set the town up as their base of operations, with Walker proclaiming he and López as President and Vice President of the Republic of Hispañola. After a few months, Walker and his men found they were running out of supplies, and after a skirmish with Haiti's emperor Faustin I, Walker and his accomplices returned to the United States, disgraced.

However, walker did not give up. Three years later, in late 1857, Walker decided to take advantage of the unrest in Nicaragua. Getting financing from Cornelius Vanderbilt after he promised Vanderbilt shipping rights along the Rio San Juan as well as the rights to build a canal across Nicaragua, Walker gather almost one thousand followers and settled in the Mosquito Coast on the eastern shore of Nicaragua. Proclaiming he was there to help the Liberal Party of Nicaragua win favor by annexing the Mosquito Coast. After driving out what little British soldiers there were at San Juan del Norte (now San Juan del Este) Walker continued up the coast until he reached Bluefields, and in early 1858 signed a treaty with the local Miskito recognizing Walker's sovereignty over the land.

Shortly after, Walker proclaimed the Mosquito Republic and claimed that the country was sovereign over all the coastline between Costa Rica and Honduras as well as some way inland, although it was never determined how far. With Nicaragua still in turmoil, Walker went with a group of men up the Rio San Juan to capture as much of the river as he could, as it was the planned route for the canal. With the two parties still fighting in the west, Walker easily reached the communities of El Castillo and Boca de Sábalos. However, the forest and disease had taken a toll on the men accompanying him.

Another concern was that the neighboring government of Costa Rica had become worried that Walker's exploits might spread into their country, and was also looking to gain land and resolve border disputes with its troubled neighbor that had arisen with the dissolution of the United Provinces of Central America. Costa Rica sent an army north and met Walker's force outside of San Carlos on Cocibolca[1]. Walker's camp was defeated, but Walker and his men were not executed since they agreed to fight with Costa Rica and cede his Mosquito Republic to the Costa Rican government. Fighting for Costa Rica, they soon defeated Nicaragua and reached Granada[2]. In the peace settlement, Costa Rica gained Rivas department and Rio San Juan department up to the Rio Camastro. Walker was made governor of the new Costa Rican Rio San Juan province and remained in Costa Rica for the rest of his life.

[1] Lake Nicaragua
 
Last edited:
Will William Walker's nation be annexed by the US? If so, this
A) Gives slaveholders another advantage if the Civil War does happen and
B) Might extend the concept of Manifest Destiny to include Latin America
 
Will William Walker's nation be annexed by the US? If so, this
A) Gives slaveholders another advantage if the Civil War does happen and
B) Might extend the concept of Manifest Destiny to include Latin America
The Mosquito Republic doesn't exist anymore. It became part of Costa Rica, and Walker is now in Costa Rica.
 
Ahh, another excellent update, and nothing about your post seemed to be too ASBish.

In any case, you have once more raised many possibilities for this TL. From what you posted inthe Map Thread, we would assume that Costa Rica would essentially remain the same, but perhaps with a Canal and be even richer then IOTL.

Still, what else could happen? Certainly, Nicaragua might want to reclaim its old territory in TTL's version of the World Wars. Or what about Panama? Maybe you could have the U.S. help Costa Rica annex the Panama region to prevent any other nation from building a Panama Canal. Still, this last part might be a little might be a little bit too ASBish.:D
 
Excellent update Wilcoxchar.
I see that slavery is beginning to take the center stage in the TL. I am really looking forward to see what you intend with the Civil War.
 
Top