I'm glad this TL is surging in activity at this particular moment--It's good timing for me to
finally get this post up after two weeks of nothing.
And these variations would form independently of each other..
Funny you should mention that, this post involves the birth of another central tenet of societal organization in
1984. It should get pretty obvious by the end.
April 10, 1940
Henry Wallace put down his glass. "Look, Fiorello, I sympathize. You know I do. But what can we do? What can
any of us do?" he asked, indicating the whole group. "You and I are the only ones who have cabinet posts; you three aren't even in the cabinet". The three Socialists across the table nodded in acknowledgement. "And our departments are hardly the most important ones. How do you expect Thomas to listen to the Secretary of Commerce and the Secretary of Agriculture when everyone else in his cabinet is telling him what he wants to hear?"
"Earl, Bill and I may not be cabinet members," James P. Cannon interjected, "but we have the President's ear. He's always concerned about maintaining support from all ends of our party, and I can tell you with confidence that our faction is firmly in support of the war." Earl Browder and William Z. Foster winced imperceptibly at Cannon's mention of "our faction". Not noticing, Cannon took a brief reprieve to swallow in a mouthful of ale, then continued. "One of the President's main reservations about entering the war is that the Party might not renominate him for a second term. If we can convince our Party of the need for war, there won't be much standing in the way of a declaration."
"Your party's big," LaGuardia pointed out, "and it's getting bigger. What is it, a thousand new members a day? How do you figure to convince that many people to change their minds?"
Bill Foster spoke up. "That's our prime concern. With so many differing points of view entering our Party it becomes near-impossible to lead it effectively, or establish a coherent program. But if we gain a firm, central control over the Party ideology, it'll become much easier to convince the rank-and-file to support the war." Now it was Cannon's turn to wince. A single central authority deciding the platform of a party that housed everyone from social democrats to militant Marxists? That wasn't the Socialist Party he'd joined when he was eighteen. Still, there had to be some way to turn Socialist sympathies toward war.
"Even if you do manage to get a handle on the Party," opined the skeptical Wallace, "it will take years to shift the views of the electorate in such a disparate direction. By then, I hope, the war will be over and the issue will be moot." Earl Browder rested his gin and tonic on the rickety wooden table as he pondered an answer. "If we increased our power within the cabinet, we would have a more direct influence on the President's decisions. As you said, there's not much chance of swaying him when everyone in his cabinet is an isolationist; but if more of his advisors have a more sensible point of view, he'll be more likely to listen to them."
LaGuardia leaned forward. "And how do you suppose we'll increase our power in the cabinet? We don't control the appointments, and we can hardly create new cabinet positions." Browder wanted to glance at Foster, but the latter was too busy responding. "We'll convince the President to sack his secretaries and install some more sensible men to take their place". LaGuardia's lips were blocked by a glass of Belgian stout, but his eyes asked the question as clearly as they could:
And how in the hell do we do that?
Foster words left a hole in the air as they dissipated, and for several seconds it seemed that the near-deserted bar had become a vacuum--no one spoke, no one moved, and, it seemed, no one thought. Finally a sentence threaded through the empty the space from James Cannon's mouth: "The important thing for now is that we stay united. We don't have a hope of shifting the balance in the cabinet unless we work as one man. And we all agree that we need to work together to get this country to war, don't we?" The silence that followed was nothing like the previous one: this one, though it only lasted a few seconds, hung dense and heavy like a humid cloud, churning in silent thunder.
"Yes, we do." The three words from Wallace were a bolt of lightning, slicing the silent cloud apart and bringing an instant's light to the deep suspicions in the heart of each man.
Then, suddenly, the cloud disappeared. Browder opened his mouth. "I'm glad we're in agreement," he announced as he stood up from his seat. "I should be getting home. My wife's in New York and I've got to get the boys to bed". It was an unconvincing lie, but it hardly mattered. No one was particularly interested in allowing this discussion to drone on. Foster, Browder and Cannon made for the door while Wallace and LaGuardia drained their glasses. As the three piled into Browder's dark-green Dodge they watched as the two moderates were carried off in a White House limousine--even the lesser cabinet members were entitled to a few official amenities.
As the sedan rolled cautiously down the road, the bar disappeared behind the corner of a brick edifice. Cannon spoke up to his comrades in the front: "I hope we all agree that we can't allow those two reactionaries or anyone like them to continue to influence the President." Foster and Browder gave subdued nods. "For all their posturing about labor empowerment they've got nothing but contempt for the working man. If Thomas ever finds his balls and decides to
really go after the hogs on Wall Street, those two will be the first to try and goad him back to defending capitalism. They're capitalists to the core, and once the people wise up to the tyranny of the banks and the marketeers and start rising up in arms, that pair of con men will sidle right up with their cronies and stand in the way of the progress of history."
Foster replied: "We can't get rid of them just yet. They're the only cabinet members who favor the war--"
"For bourgeois reasons," Cannon butted in.
"Reasons aside, without them we have no chance of getting close to the rest of the cabinet. We'll probably have to leave them for last." Cannon grumbled in disappointment. "Well, I suppose I don't care who we start with, so long as we get 'em all--Norris, Wheeler, Lewis, La Follette, and those two stooges, of course. Come to think of it, who exactly are we going to have replacing the cronies we dispose of?"
"Well, Socialists, obviously," said Browder behind the wheel.
"Ones who want war?"
"Naturally."
"What about us?" asked Cannon.
A pause. "I'm sure a few opportunities will present themselves as we shift the balance of the executive. Seeing as we represent such prominent facti--such a prominent faction of the Party, I'd say it's only natural we have some official representation in the executive branch."
"Unquestionably," answered the well satisfied James Cannon, just before the car slowed to a halt in front of a familiar domicile.
"Thanks, Earl," Cannon said as he yanked the door latch and climbed out of the car. As he retreated inside his abode, the green Dodge rolled on.
"I suppose we'll have to wait a while before we kick him from the Party," opined a disappointed Browder once they had cleared a suitable distance.
"What LaGuardia said in the bar was correct, pains me though it does to say it," replied Foster. "Even after we gain control of the Party, it'll take time to subdue all of the counterrevolutionary factions. They'll kick us out of the leadership if we don't give at least the outward appearance of tolerating pluralist viewpoints."
"And for that," Browder admitted, "we've got to keep sods like Cannon at least thinking they're in charge of policy."
"It certainly doesn't mean we'd have to give them any real say in deciding the Party platform," reassured Foster.
"I should hope not. If it were up to him and his ilk," complained Browder, "they'd have us shipping guns and cash to wild gangs of fanatical mountain men in the Congo twice a month in blind hopes we'd gain a bankrupt ally on the other side of the planet--all the while standing by as the revolution at home is highjacked by bourgeois opportunists, with no arm of people's enforcement to safeguard it." The surprise of nearly colliding with an oncoming Buick snapped Browder straight out of the spell he was falling into; as he jerked the wheel to the right he scolded himself for getting lost in another web of frustrated dogmatism.
"Not to mention his preposterous fear of bureaucracy," Browder mocked in a near-gossipy tone after he had righted the car. "I really would like to see him try and act out his fantasies of administering a socialist state without using the state."
"That could be useful for us, though," opined Foster. "If he's so afraid of letting the state outgrow its boots, we might manage to persuade him not take up a portfolio in Thomas's cabinet. We might even find a way discourage him from getting too involved in the Party's organizational structure--that'll make it a lot easier to slam the doors on him and his friends when the time comes."
"If we can get close enough to the President before the convention in June, that time might come sooner than we expected. Perhaps," Browder hoped optimistically, a few poorly-timed speeches by a few poorly-placed individuals could go a long way toward fostering long-term unity, cohesion and accord within the Socialist Party--and it could be the beginning of the end for counterrevolutionary factionalism within the Party of popular revolution."
Foster had little interest in entertaining such notions. "Don't kid yourself, Earl, that's wishful thinking. You heard what LaGuardia said--the Party's being flooded with uneducated simpletons who don't have the slightest grasp of Marxist theory, nor a hint of foresight of revolutionary struggle. A factional war within our Party is the only way to save the Revolution from devolving into a disordered, degenerated disaster--and if it came tonight, we'd be ripped to shreds. Cannon, Lovestone and their Menshevites would mobilize the unwashed hordes against us, tell them we're undemocratic or counterrevolutionary. They wouldn't have a clue what it meant, of course, but it wouldn't matter--we'd be wiped out in an instant, and Cannon would be free to ravage the Party platform with his bullshit ideas of permanent revolution."
Browder's brow wrinkled. Was Bill saying that there was no hope, that Cannon and his ignorant rabble were forever doomed to win out in the end? Surely he couldn't be saying that. Could he?
Browder had to make sure. He kept his eyes on the road, but the convergent brow, the downturned lips--the expression of imminent despair was clear from any angle. He turned his head ever so slightly to glance at his passenger, the tendons in his neck tightening with creeping unsureness. Finally he asked the question. "How do we win?"
Foster leaned in kind, and in a scarce voice he answered. "We need an
inner circle." He emphasized those last two words as though they defined his entire viewpoint. "We build a clique of Party members who will be absolutely loyal to the revolution. They will allow themselves no sympathy whatsoever for the leeching bourgeoisie. They will support us without question." He enunciated every word, knowing that this message was far too important for his ally not to comprehend. "We build this inner circle, and we put its members in every high-ranking position we can. When every Secretary is one of ours, when the National Committee, the Youth League, the Newspapers and the Membership Office are all under our control, the control of our inner circle,
then we go to war against the outer fringes of the Party. And when every leadership office in the Party is ours, it doesn't matter how many ignorant sheep Cannon finds to follow him--we can't lose." Browder nodded slowly. The idea was bold--a decisive, central executive dominant over a disorganized fringe.
"Tomorrow," Browder proposed, "we begin."
At that moment, a conspiracy was born.
Note: OTL, James P. Cannon was a prominent Trotskyist, and Earl Browder and William Z. Foster were well-known Stalinists in the Communist Party, but ATL, with the Socialist Party far, far more successful than it ever was OTL, the Communist Party USA has essentially merged with the Socialists, making the Socialist Party's radical wing all the stronger.