Gentleman Biaggi
Banned
1960 Republican Nomination
Before the 1960 Republican Primaries began, it was generally expected that the race was going to be between Harold Stassen and Vice President Walter Judd. In the polls for that potential race, Stassen was predicted to get crushed. Stassen had burned most of his goodwill in the Republican Party by being a massive maverick and fighting president Everett Dirksen on almost everything. While this gave him large amounts of popularity in Liberal Pennsylvania, as the state was necessarily full of Dirksen supporters, it hurt him with Republicans outside the Liberal Northeast. Meanwhile, he had seemingly burnt out his old support in the Midwest by deserting Minnesota for Pennsylvania before then preaching about “Northeastern values” to support racial integration as governor. He still had moderate Western support, but he had burned too many bridges as governor to win the nomination. That was when former Senate Minority Leader Bill Knowland announced his candidacy. Knowland was to the right of the Republican Party, and had establishment support, as he had been the Republican Senate Leader.
The Primaries were nothing if not surprising after Knowland announced his candidacy. The first primary was the New Hampshire Primary. In it, New Hampshire senator and favorite son candidate Norris Cotton won, but Harold Stassen came in a surprisingly close second with 44.3% of the vote, while Cotton only got 53.6%. Stassen’s performance was largely put on Norris Cotton’s opposition to an extension of Civil Rights, which was not too popular in New Hampshire at the time. Wisconsin, Illinois, New Jersey, D.C, and Nebraska were won by Judd, while Knowland won Indiana, California, and Florida. The real surprise came when Stassen took Oregon and South Dakota. He won South Dakota by a slim plurality with state senator and favorite son candidate David L. Wickens getting into second place with 27% of the vote. He also won Oregon in a shocker, as most people expected the state to go Judd due to the state’s moderate views, but lack of major support for Stassen. Again, he won the state with a small 39% of the vote. Stassen also managed to take Pennsylvania and Massachusetts with larger margins, as he was expected to due to his broad support in the Northeast.
Despite some of the surprising results of the primaries, the nomination looked like it was going to Judd. While Stassen had surprised many with his victories, it was clear he had no chance to get the nomination. He had finished in second place in primaries won, but third in the popular vote. He only won one state with over 50% of the vote, and it was his “home state”, Pennsylvania (which he win with 53%). Not only that, but he had almost no support from Midwestern or Establishment figures. Meanwhile, Knowland and Judd were willing to compromise in order to stop Stassen from further splitting the Republican. Due to Knowland’s endorsement of Judd, Stassen’s nomination chances had ended. After the defeat Stassen announced that he had no plans to run for president again, but would stay active in Pennsylvania politics. In order to pick a less establishment figure than Knowland, Judd decided on moderate Fred Schwengel. However, Schwengel’s support for organized labor would awaken a growing beast in the South and West….
Before the 1960 Republican Primaries began, it was generally expected that the race was going to be between Harold Stassen and Vice President Walter Judd. In the polls for that potential race, Stassen was predicted to get crushed. Stassen had burned most of his goodwill in the Republican Party by being a massive maverick and fighting president Everett Dirksen on almost everything. While this gave him large amounts of popularity in Liberal Pennsylvania, as the state was necessarily full of Dirksen supporters, it hurt him with Republicans outside the Liberal Northeast. Meanwhile, he had seemingly burnt out his old support in the Midwest by deserting Minnesota for Pennsylvania before then preaching about “Northeastern values” to support racial integration as governor. He still had moderate Western support, but he had burned too many bridges as governor to win the nomination. That was when former Senate Minority Leader Bill Knowland announced his candidacy. Knowland was to the right of the Republican Party, and had establishment support, as he had been the Republican Senate Leader.
The Primaries were nothing if not surprising after Knowland announced his candidacy. The first primary was the New Hampshire Primary. In it, New Hampshire senator and favorite son candidate Norris Cotton won, but Harold Stassen came in a surprisingly close second with 44.3% of the vote, while Cotton only got 53.6%. Stassen’s performance was largely put on Norris Cotton’s opposition to an extension of Civil Rights, which was not too popular in New Hampshire at the time. Wisconsin, Illinois, New Jersey, D.C, and Nebraska were won by Judd, while Knowland won Indiana, California, and Florida. The real surprise came when Stassen took Oregon and South Dakota. He won South Dakota by a slim plurality with state senator and favorite son candidate David L. Wickens getting into second place with 27% of the vote. He also won Oregon in a shocker, as most people expected the state to go Judd due to the state’s moderate views, but lack of major support for Stassen. Again, he won the state with a small 39% of the vote. Stassen also managed to take Pennsylvania and Massachusetts with larger margins, as he was expected to due to his broad support in the Northeast.
Despite some of the surprising results of the primaries, the nomination looked like it was going to Judd. While Stassen had surprised many with his victories, it was clear he had no chance to get the nomination. He had finished in second place in primaries won, but third in the popular vote. He only won one state with over 50% of the vote, and it was his “home state”, Pennsylvania (which he win with 53%). Not only that, but he had almost no support from Midwestern or Establishment figures. Meanwhile, Knowland and Judd were willing to compromise in order to stop Stassen from further splitting the Republican. Due to Knowland’s endorsement of Judd, Stassen’s nomination chances had ended. After the defeat Stassen announced that he had no plans to run for president again, but would stay active in Pennsylvania politics. In order to pick a less establishment figure than Knowland, Judd decided on moderate Fred Schwengel. However, Schwengel’s support for organized labor would awaken a growing beast in the South and West….