Tungusga

I have heard of the comet/astereoid destroying london,st petersberg but how about these places

Mexico-civil war/ u.s intervention

Rome-Austrian/French invasion

constantinople-U.k/Russian/Greek/Bulgarian/Persian invasion of Ottomans

1916 battle of verdun-several million killed western front collapses
 
Sorry, dude... But you posted two completely different threads in less than 20 minutes.

Are you trolling ?
 
I have heard of the comet/astereoid destroying london,st petersberg but how about these places

Mexico-civil war/ u.s intervention

Rome-Austrian/French invasion

constantinople-U.k/Russian/Greek/Bulgarian/Persian invasion of Ottomans

1916 battle of verdun-several million killed western front collapses

Slow down my friend. Perhaps no one has explained to you that posing multiple, buck-shot-like questions like this is generally frowned upon, especially when the questions posed are better suited for the ASB forum then for here.
 
Okay, I am not at all sure why you didn't list any places at all save for Constantinople. If you want a "Tunguska Event" to destroy something, it has to be a specific place or an object, not a bloody event. That isn't a noob mistake, it's a logic mistake. I'm sorry, but it had to be said.

EDIT: At first I misunderstood, but that still stands to logical mistake. For one, Mexico is very large. As in many times larger than a city or a battlefield. Two, you didn't list a specific time for any of these. It matters. I mean, the Pancho Villa expedition and the Occupation of Vera Cruz didn't happen at the same time. Nor did all those invasions or battles take place in one day.
 

Cook

Banned
Most of the world is Ocean so you stand a better chance of a Tunguska type impact in the ocean with the resulting Tsunami wiping out vast stretches of coastline and coastal cities.

Arthur C. Clark’s book “Rendezvous with Rama” starts with such an event, a small asteroid impacts the Adriatic Sea and the resulting wave acts like a shotgun blast at Venice and the cities of Northern Italy and the Po Valley.

Larry Niven and Jerry Pournelle’s book “Lucifer’s Hammer” describes a much larger series of impacts. The imagery will give you sleepless nights.
 
Most of the world is Ocean so you stand a better chance of a Tunguska type impact in the ocean with the resulting Tsunami wiping out vast stretches of coastline and coastal cities.

Arthur C. Clark’s book “Rendezvous with Rama” starts with such an event, a small asteroid impacts the Adriatic Sea and the resulting wave acts like a shotgun blast at Venice and the cities of Northern Italy and the Po Valley.

Larry Niven and Jerry Pournelle’s book “Lucifer’s Hammer” describes a much larger series of impacts. The imagery will give you sleepless nights.

Same with Pournelle and Niven's book "Footfall" although the "Foot" is a prelude to an alien invasion; lands in the Indian Ocean. AC Clarke's "Hammer of God" actually has a chapter dedicated to Tunguska; if it had hit a few minutes earlier it would have wiped out Moscow (what with the earth's rotation and all).

To see what a REALLY bit hit would do, check out "Red Lightning" by John Varley. An object traveling at relativistic velocities skips off the Mid-Atlantic Ocean. Focuses on Florida, but you get glimpses. Death toll close to 1 billion...
 
If I had a nickle... :rolleyes:

I disagree a little that physical PODs belong in ASB. The accidental trip that begins Look to the West is probably just as likely as something slowing/accelerating the Tunguska object just a little bit. We just don't know is the problem with celestial events and when one is dealing with incredible distances and incomprehensible speeds, small changes can probably make massive differences.

We say it is ASB because the difference is put as "Tunguska hits London!!!!" but if it written as,

"Somewhere between Mars and Jupiter, a rock, roughly five miles across, is speeding towards the inner regions of the Solar System. It is on a collision course with the third planet, Earth. Against all odds, it passed relatively unscathed through the gauntlet that is the Asteroid Belt, save for a few scratches. Yet, just as its fate looks clear, its passage safe and determined, the rock smashes into, and through, a clump of dirt, half a mile wide, slowing the rock's velocity by only a few meters per second.

"In the scale of the universe, this change is of no minor consequence. It would still hit the third planet rotating that particular star. It would only hit a few hundred kilometers 'west' of its original impact site, before that clump of dirt got in that rocks path. Instead of that remote forest in the middle of Asia, away from human settlements, it would strike one the most important and largest human settlements of the era, the city of St. Petersburg."

When put like that, it seems more reasonable, at least to me, to say that such a change is plausible and not ASB. However, the Tunguska event question is fairly covered and asked and there are more unique and creative changes that could be done.
 
Top