TLIAD: The Limpid Stream

rand_by_lordroem-d7dae20.jpg


1971-1982: Alisa Rosenbaum (Free Democratic and Liberal)
The Iron Lady who brought her country in from the cold

In the 18th Century - Russia was a nation dominated by strong female rulers, with the male monarchs providing brief and unhappy interregnums. Anna Ioannovna, Elizaveta Petrovna and Catherine the Great all left far greater legacies for their vast realm than the likes of Ivan, the two short-reigning Peters and the incompetent Paul.

At the same time, the Jewish people had known only two women rulers during their long history. Athalia, daughter of Jezebel, ruled the Levant in the 8th Century BC, whilst Salome Alexandra governed as the last independent Queen of Judea seventy years before the birth of Christ. When Alisa Rosenbaum rose to the leadership of the struggling Liberal Party in the late-sixties, few would have assumed that the former Minister for Education would embody both heritages.

Were it not for her gender and ethnicity, Rosenbaum’s political career would have been considered unremarkable. Born into a middle-class Jewish family in Petrograd in 1905 - the young Miss Rosenbaum excelled at school, where she became firm friends with the future-Premier Nabokov’s younger sister. An instinctive liberal, she was a young admirer of Alexander Kerensky over the Tsar during the Revolution, seeing the latter as a reactionary, anti-Semitic block on future constitutional reform.

Soon after Wrangel had consolidated his hold on power, Rosenbaum entered Moscow University, where she read Law. Although Wrangel’s government was not the best place in the world to be Jewish, the Directorate’s internal security police did - at the very least - put a stop to all but the most serious Pogroms - and with figures such as Trotsky, Pasternak and Kantorovich (the latter of whom would serve as Rosenbaum’s brilliant Minister of Finance) brought into the National Unity government, the Russian Jewish community slowly began to see an end to the institutional prejudice that had persisted since Catherine the Great had established the Pale of Settlement. After a brief period as a lecturer at the Pedagogical University of Perm - she entered the city council, where she gained a reputation as a fierce anti-corruption fighter. Following a three-hour interrogation of the local Mayor at a fractious meeting in October 1934, where the indicted politician finally broke down and confessed to mass embezzlement, she gained the attention of the national press. A storm of media attention followed and she was soon appointed to a senior position at the Interior Ministry, where she became a member of the so-called “Objectivists” - single minded government officials who went from town to town to root out cases of fraud.

By the end of the war, Rosenbaum joined the Progress Movement, and later the Social Liberal Party. In the first post-Wrangel elections, she entered the Duma as one of only six female representatives and was instrumental in throwing the “Moderate” faction of the movement behind Trotsky during the Denikin Coup. Her commitment to democracy was rewarded by a place in the government, and she ably served as a Junior Whip under Stravinsky, eventually rising to the Education Ministry during Nabokov’s final administration in the early 1960s. One of the few Ministers to stand out in the “Pigmy Cabinet” - Rosenbaum became very popular for her determination in improving school standards. In 1961, she promoted the teaching of the Symplified Cyrillic Alphabet, removing almost a dozen archaic letters from the curriculum. When the government fell at the general election two years later, she was one of the only Liberal Duma Members to increase her majority in her central Petrograd seat.

Nevertheless, Rosenbaum was a surprise victor in the post-election leadership ballot, narrowly beating Nikolai Podgorny to become Leader of the Opposition. Facing Solzhenitsyn across the Chamber, she constantly harried the government on a number of issues, although she was unable to prevent the escalation of the Vladivostok Crisis. The Prime Minister’s reference to her Jewish heritage shortly before polling day in 1971 backfired spectacularly, and a late swing towards the Liberal Party allowed Rosenbaum to become Russia’s first female leader since Catherine the Great. Catherine, a Baltic German minor noble who rose to become one of the most powerful monarchs in Europe, was a personal heroine to Rosenbaum and had clearly studied her idol’s diplomatic lessons carefully.

“Our Republic must come in from the cold,” the Prime Minister stated as she walked into the Kremlin for the first time. “To stand outside, waving a sabre at your neighbour, is nothing but chutzpah of the highest order!” - to a cacophony of cheering and jeers. Such a turn of phrase was typical Rosenbaum, arousing ire and laughter in almost equal measure. It would serve as a perfect example of the uncompromising and brisk way that she would conduct her administration throughout her eleven year term in office.

Rosenbaum’s time in office is seen as the time when the so-called “Bear Economy” finally started to come into being. Between them, Wrangel, Stravinsky and Nabokov brought Russia up to a standard of living equitable with that of the likes of Bohemia, Danubia or the North Chinese Federation, but as the seventies began to dawn, many commentators had begun to turn around and ask where their Cosmos Programme and Atomkraft Reactors were. For the new Prime Minister, such technologies could only come through co-operation. Soon after taking office, she established her “Grand Embassy” (the term chosen in deliberate homage to the Petrine effort that took place just before the Great Northern War.) Although Rosenbaum’s age prevented her from taking as involved a role as Peter the Great, over her first term in office, her diplomats, lecturers and business-leaders travelled around the world, flying the flag to show that the Russian Republic was finally open for business. In 1973, she enjoyed a fruitful meeting with President George Kennan to discuss proposals for a joint mission to the moon (Von Braun having already masterminded a Scando-German orbit of the satellite the previous summer.) Although the proposals came to naught, it was nevertheless a firm indication that the new government desired a fresh beginning after the Solzhenitsyn years.

With the “Rosenbaum Thaw” came the popular support necessary for the Prime Minister's long-cherished constitutional reforms. After consultations with her coalition partners – the government won three referenda shortly after being returned to office in 1976. In order to curb the power of executive, a semi-appointed second chamber of the Duma was established as a means of scrutinising legislation and better representing the regions (functioning as a combination of the Reichsrat and the British House of Councillors), whilst other plebiscites created a popular-elected presidency and an independent National Bank. Under Kantorovich’s ‘Cybernetics’ policy, long-term economic planning was increasingly left to engineering students beavering away in the basement of the Ministry of Finance, whilst the increase in the scope of the National Hospital Service contributed to life-expectancy reaching parity with central Europe by the end of the decade.

However, Rosenbaum’s health went into a rapid decline during her third term. Kantorovich’s resignation following a heart attack in 1979 left her increasingly conscious of her own mortality, and although still popular with the electorate-at-large, by 1981, the seventy-seven year-old Prime Minister decided that she was unable to lead her fifth election campaign. The following year, she shocked the country by announcing that she would not contest the party leadership at the annual congress. Her successor, the young Gregori Trebek, was unable to properly tie his own campaign to Rosenbaum. In 1982, the FDLP slumped to a narrow defeat at the polls, where the resurgent Conservatives eked out a narrow majority.​
 
Last edited:
Ayn Rand, you magnificent bastard.

Yeah - it was an obvious choice really!

:D

Thanks to "bottomofthepageitis", I will repeat my previous remark that - typically - work intervened for the past couple of days. I was stuck in the office until nine yesterday, but I am pleased to say that this is now up for being finished by tomorrow afternoon!
 
I am deeply disappointed by the absence of at least one 'a man chooses, a serf obeys' reference. Really, Jack, you're losing your touch.

Unlike Iain, I must admit I had to suppress an eyeroll when I saw it was dear Ayn in charge. She is a bit more 'done' than your other options, no less by EdT himself in The World of FaBR. However, this was a very innovative take on her character and contained a great bit of world-buildi-

...

House of Councillors.

What hath Belisha wrought
 
A very (OTL) artistic bunch of rulers Russia's been having- a composer, and three writers! Also... is Gregori Trebek a reference to OTLs Jeopardy! host?
 
Last edited:

BigDave1967

Banned
Leon Trotsky would be the guy running the revolution and campaigning for a much more aggressive version of communism.
 
This is just excellent, Roem. It's certainly a more optimistic take on Russia than is often seen here (and elsewhere, for that matter).

Stravinsky, by the way, was inspired.
 
I am deeply disappointed by the absence of at least one 'a man chooses, a serf obeys' reference. Really, Jack, you're losing your touch.

Unlike Iain, I must admit I had to suppress an eyeroll when I saw it was dear Ayn in charge. She is a bit more 'done' than your other options, no less by EdT himself in The World of FaBR. However, this was a very innovative take on her character and contained a great bit of world-buildi-

...

House of Councillors.

What hath Belisha wrought

Yes. That's one of the throwaway lines that shows the world is different. Has the UK become a republic or is it still a monarchy that had reformed the Lords further by the 1970s than OTL has today. I'm sure there are many other interesting changes beyond the boundaries of mother Russia.
 
tolstoy_by_lordroem-d7dbahy.jpg


1982-1990 Nikolai Tolstoy (Conservative and Unionist)
The grey conservative who brought Russia into Europe, but annihilated his party

For a man who ran the world’s largest nation for the best part of eight years – Russia seems to have adopted collective amnesia about Nikolai Tolstoy’s government. Widely considered the “Grey Man” of the so-called “Blue Eighties”, his time at Prime Minister was characterised by a deep-set social conservatism that played poorly in the inner cities, but fairly well almost everywhere else.

“There are those who will always say that one cannot stand firm against the river of history,” Tolstoy said in his speech to the 1984 Conservative Party Conference, “but I remain convinced that, regardless of what such social vandals say, that in three centuries, there will still be a Russia of domed Churches, snow-tipped forests and a samovar bubbling away in a lakeside dacha.”

Such a turn of phrase epitomised the quaint - some would say naive - prism through which Tolstoy viewed his politics. The radical Christian Anarchism of his ancestor was diluted to little more than a vague belief in creating a better yesterday, which in practice manifest itself as a desire to hold firm against any further liberalisation of the laws concerning abortion, gay rights or divorce. Under Rosenbaum, Russia had liberalised on the Polish model; official discrimination had ended at the state level, homosexuals were no longer sent to German Elektrokrampftherapie hospitals, and women increasingly enjoyed wage parity with their male counterparts. Under Tolstoy, the pace of even these marginal reforms had slackened off considerably. The population of the “Corrective Labour Camps” on the Arctic Circle began to grow again and - no matter how much the Prime Minister defended them as a humane alternative to western-style prisons - Red Swastika representatives became persistent critics of Tolstoy’s government.

Tolstoy’s public authoritarianism was not born out by his style of Cabinet government - in the Kremlin, he functioned very much as a Chairman, attempting to find an uneasy moderation between the left- and right-wings of his always-irritable party. Despite a tough new broadcasting act that seriously hampered the state-press, independent broadcasters - many of them officially based in Finland - harangued the Conservative government for failures both social and economic (the Persian Civil War breaking-out a matter of weeks after Tolstoy entered office.) and Eduard Khil’s popular current affairs programme “The Hour Has 59 Minutes” - persistently satirised Tolstoy’s grey image from the relative security of Petrograd.

Nevertheless, Tolstoy’s government did enjoy some successes internationally, quite at odds with his domestic reputation. The State Visit of Pope Nicholas VI (the former Archbishop of Prague, František Tomášek) in 1985 was seen as a triumph and did much to improve ties between the Catholic and Orthodox Churches. In his memoirs, Tolstoy even went so far as to voice support for re-uniting the Church, a view that he sensibly decided to keep from himself during his time in office. The following year, he also visited London, meeting with King Alexander IV and the head of the Imperial Family-in-Exile.The decision to restore the pretender's citizenship would prove to be one of the most important of his Premiership.

The decision to join the League of Nations peacekeeping force in Persia added further complexities to Tolstoy’s way of doing things. An unabashed conservative at home, there was little sign of that at the international level and the Prime Minister saw his own popularity slowly ebb away as first dozens, then later hundreds, of coffins began to take the long funeral train home from the battlegrounds of Isfahan and Qom. The tying of Moscow to the Berlin-London-Washington Axis caused consternation in the party, and Tolstoy was only able to survive the exodus of twenty of his Duma Members into the Patriotic Justice Party by forming an electoral pact with the Agrarians.

As the seventieth anniversary of the founding of the Revolution approached in 1987 - Tolstoy made every effort to reaffirmed popular support for constitutional republic. On 6th August, Duma Day, Tolstoy and President Ustinov were both present for the ceremonial “Reaffirmation of Democracy,” - where the Prime Minister gave a surprisingly upbeat assessment of the future of the country. The following day, the Duma voted narrowly in favour of joining the European Council of States. For the first time in many years, Russia could claim that she was unquestionably a European country.

The decision was a controversial one and it seriously damaged Tolstoy’s efforts to remain in office after the inconclusive 1989 General Election. Although the FDLP were riven by in-fighting of their own, a new force, emerging out of a decision made several years ago, had entered Russian politics. When the Prime Minister was forced to call another election barely fourteen months later, the Conservatives were eviscerated, losing all but forty of their seats. Tolstoy himself was defeated in his own constituency of Kaluga East. He retired immediately, leaving the task of rebuilding the centre-right in the hands of his Foreign Minister, one of the few senior figures to survive the landslide. Today, he spends his time between his Black Sea villa and his Oxfordshire Estate, where he writes a monthly column for the International Times.​
 
Last edited:

Thande

Donor
Count Nikolai Tolstoy. Brilliant.

For those who don't know, he was the UKIP candidate who challenged Cameron in Witney at the last election.

House of Councillors.

What hath Belisha wrought

Yeah! I want to find out more about that!

Yes. That's one of the throwaway lines that shows the world is different. Has the UK become a republic or is it still a monarchy that had reformed the Lords further by the 1970s than OTL has today. I'm sure there are many other interesting changes beyond the boundaries of mother Russia.
I should think it replaced the House of Lords, as the text implies. Although there are obvious comparisons to Japan's upper house (which replaced the House of Peers) given the different meaning of 'councillor' in Britain I suspect that it is similar to the German Reichsrat (the text does mention them together) - it's an upper house consisting of representatives sent from, or chosen by, all the local councils. I'm sure we'll get a throwaway reference to alt-Iain being the Speaker or equivalent.
 

Heavy

Banned


“There are those who will always say that one cannot stand firm against the river of history,” Tolstoy said in his speech to the 1984 Conservative Party Conference, “but I remain convinced that, regardless of what such social vandals say, that in three centuries, there will still be a Russia of domed Churches, snow-tipped forests and a samovar bubbling away in a lakeside dacha.”

And also comely maidens dancing at the crossroads, one assumes.
 
The Russia of TTL is very interesting, but I find myself more intrigued by the differences in the rest of the world. A Persian Civil War. King Alexander IV, presumably the monarch of the UK. I wonder why a Scottish regnal name was chosen. The Red Swastika. German hospitals where people from other countries go for shock therapy. Truly the world is all but unrecognisable.

Russia is interesting though, as I said. A powerful Agrarian party able to help keep Tolstoy in power. And Tolstoy seems even greyer than OTL John Major. I wonder who the Foreign Minister of the Conservatives was. And what this new political force in Russia is.
 

Saphroneth

Banned
King Alexander IV, presumably the monarch of the UK. I wonder why a Scottish regnal name was chosen.
Actually, that's interesting. The effective policy currently in the UK is that a monarch of a given name will take the highest regnal number that applies - so a future James would be James VIII. I could see someone opting for Alexander, and hence they count the Scots Alexanders as the earlier ones of that regnal number.
 
romanov_by_lordroem-d7db9qr.jpg


1990-1996: Nicholai Romanov (All-Russia Union - Bloc “Romanov”)
The pretender who rode a populist wave, and fell off
The recession of the late-1980s prompted anti-establishment victories throughout the world. In the United Kingdom, the Liberal-Conservatives slumped to a humiliating third thanks to the rise of Alan Sked’s Radical Party. In the European Commonwealth, the anti-Federalists won power in Paris, Berlin, Rome and Vienna, whilst the United States saw Fred Koch enter the White House as an independent.

Russia was no exception from the so-called “Occupy Politics!” tide. On 8th May 1990, Nicholai Romanov, who under normal circumstances would have been better known to the people as “Nicholas III, Emperor and Autocrat of All the Russias”, swept into office as the head of the populist coalition that he had assembled from dissatisfied conservatives, contrarian liberals, ethno-centric nationalists and antidisestablishmentarians. In the history of the Republic, nothing quite like the “All Russia Union” had been seen before. It had won seats off all four mainstream political parties, made inroads into the liberal strongholds of Petrograd and Minsk, and even enjoyed a narrow majority of the trade union vote. Only in Siberian Turkestan, the Caucasian Autonomous Republic and Sloboda did the regionalist parties manage to hold on.

When the Romanovs had return to Russia in 1986, few people seemed to care. Russia’s republican system was secure and had survived both military dictators and the threat of atomic war. At the same time, Nicholai (the spelling a messy and unexpected outcome from Rosenbaum’s simplification campaign) had never set foot in his nominal homeland before in his life. Raised abroad, and educated at Eton, Trinity College, Cambridge and the Coldstream Guards - the head of the Imperial Family was far closer to the idea of an English gentleman than the heir of Peter, Catherine or Alexander I. Despite this, he was greeted by huge crowds on his return from exile and for the first time in living memory, “God Save the Tsar!” was sung by the ranked masses of the general public. With the popularity of elected politicians at an all-time low, some commentators began to wonder if the monarchy was on the verge of being restored by popular demand.

The post-war period had not been kind to the kingdoms of Europe. Although Wilhelm III had narrowly survived a referendum in 1956 after yet another attempt to sack the Chancellor fell horribly flat, it was enough to force his abdication in favour of his cousin, Prince Victor. In Austria, the Archduke had survived, but Bohemia, Spain, Greece and Rumania had all seen their republican movements take control during various times of social unrest from the War of the Iron Pact onwards. The rulers of Livonia, Lithuania and Finland had only survived by breeding out any traces of Teutonic blood over the course of three generations.

Romanov knew this history, and hesitated. Even the Duma’s decision to restore a number of Imperial Estates - nationalised under Wrangel - to the Imperial Family was insufficient to make the titular Emperor call for a restoration. Instead, in his famous “Dostoevsky Park Speech” of September 1986, Romanov announced his intention to serve his re-adopted country by constitutional means.

“I desire to be known by no title other than that of ‘Mister” he said to a crowd of several hundred, “as it is a term that I consider to be perfectly adequate for anyone who shares my aims and intentions for the Motherland. We have become corrupted - if I may be so bold - by our drive for homogeneity and synthesis with the New Europe. Citizens, the new movement that we must form must be entirely Russian in outlook - but I remind you that Great Novgorod survived for centuries under the principles of Republicanism - a legacy that I am more than happy to emulate!”

The announcement was a masterstroke, appealing to conservatives dissatisfied with the lack of reaction from Tolstoy’s government to the liberalisations of the previous decade, whilst nullifying the centrist voters fearing a return to Tsarist oppression. Only in the regions did the message go down poorly, where Romanov’s calls for “A Third Way of Russification” hinted at a return to the days of Alexander III. At the resulting general election, parties calling for regional assemblies performed well in the majority of Russian-minority areas.

Entering office as the most popular politician in years, the sheen went off the Romanov juggernaut very quickly. The “Cultural Promotion Act” - the lead article of legislation aimed at promoting traditional values - served only in creating a number of generic ‘re-imaginings’ of Mussorgsky’s Boris Godunov. Indeed, the act served primarily to galvanise the Russian intelligentsia into a reaction against the staid conservatism of the Republic. In 1994, Eduard Limonov wrote his seminal play “At the Intersection of Novyy Arbat and Novinski Boulevard” - a searing production of the endemic boredom prevalent within the nineties generation. In the final scene, the hero, Sergei Bobovnikovit, wears a crown made out of his own placenta, given to him by a tramp who claims to be “Emperor of All Moscow.” The production received rave reviews, touring Broadway (and receiving a very public visit from President Koch on opening night) and winning numerous international awards.

The Prime Minister was not amused, and attempted to have the opening night cut short by representatives of the security police. The resulting riot was minor, but it cost Romanov a great deal of popularity, from which he never recovered.

As the Long Recession carried on throughout the nineties, splits in the unwieldy governing party became clear. Economic liberals criticised the Prime Minister for not following through on his promised privatisations, social conservatives decried the lack of efforts to row-back the abortion laws, whilst the more right-leaning Duma Members wondered why immigration continued to be permitted. As with so many of his predecessors, Romanov simply could not balance the competing interests of his government.

At the 1996 election, the “All Russia Bloc” simply ceased to be. Romanov resigned immediately afterwards. He now hosts a popular current affairs programme on RT-01, loosely translated as “Propping Up The Tsar.”
 
Last edited:
Top