My Contribution
History of Hockey in TL 191
The Stanley Cup Era
In 1893, Canada's Governor General Stanley, who's sons were both avid ice hockey players, bought a trophy that would be dedicated to the top team in Canada, appropriately enough named the Stanley Cup. In the early years, both professional and amateur teams played for the cup. Although no team east of Manitoba had ever won it, the rising power of the Pacific Coast Hockey Association, with teams on both sides of what was then an international border, meant that it looked likely that Vancouver or Victoria, or even Seattle or Portland, may challenge for the cup some day.
However, the PCHA obviously could not survive the outbreak of the First Great War, and the Canadian leagues ceased to play during the war. At the end of the war, when English speaking Canada was occupied by the United States, the Stanley Cup was shipped back to the United States as a museum piece (with President Roosevelt making sure to get a photograph of him holding it high above his head) and hockey games, as well as most spectator sports, were banned in the first years of the occupation.
Interwar Period
When Upton Sinclair was elected President in 1920, he eased some of the restrictions in the occupied territories, including on professional sports; the joke that "without hockey, Canadian women will get drunk and beat their husbands" is sometimes credited to him. Hockey leagues started in Ontario, the Prairies and the Maritimes, while the four team PCHA was resurrected, with teams in Victoria, Vancouver, Seattle and Portland. PCHA games however, frequently turned into scenes of violence between spectators, and after the uprising of 1924, hockey games were once again banned in occupied Canada.
In the United States, hockey was a fringe sport, with two dominant professional leagues: the Eastern Hockey League, with teams in Philadelphia, Boston, Buffalo, Baltimore, Pittsburgh and two teams in New York, and the Central Hockey League, with teams in Detroit, Pontiac, Chicago, Minnesota and Milwaukee. After the Depression though, only five teams: the New York Sentinels, Philadelphia Quakers, Boston Whales, Detroit Cougars and Chicago Towers were able to survive, and the two leagues merged into the American Hockey League in 1932.
But in terms of fan interest and quality of play, the Lique du Hockey Republique in Quebec was clearly the greatest in the continent and the world. Quebec was intensely proud of it's new league, even having the Premier's Cup pictured on their five cent piece, and sending their teams to play exhibition games throughout Europe. The 1920's and 30's are remembered as the Belle Epocque of the LHR.
The Second Great War and it's Aftermath:
The AHL managed to stay afloat in the outbreak of war in 1941, although it struggled: many of it's best players were either drafted, or tried to get on Quebec teams in order to avoid going to war. The quality of professional play dipped below college and university teams.
Meanwhile, the LHR's most celebrated team, the Montreal Habitants, started a run of dominance in 1942 that saw them win the Premier's Cup six years in a row.
After the 1946-47 season, the AHL teams approached the Habitant's owner, Joseph Drapeau with a proposition to come play in their league. The AHL wanted to drum up business by attracting fans to the best team in the world: Drapeau, who knew that he could count on a bigger share of the gate, and larger gates in bigger American cities, agreed. The LHR immediately took the Habitants to court, and the session dragged out so that the entire 1947-48 season meant that the Habitants didn't play a game in either league. However, Quebec's courts, despite public opinion, ruled that the LHR had no legal grounds, and the Habitants became the sixth franchise in the AHL.
If they were dominant in the LHR however, the Habitants proved completely unstoppable in the AHL. Quebecois fans watched with a mixture of pride in watching their team mop the floor with the Americans, and distress as to what this meant for their league, particularily when AHL teams began offering LHR players big money contracts in the hopes of shoring up their lineups. In response, the LRH installed new contract laws that effectively bound every player to their first franchise for a decade after they turned professional. Many Montrealers on the other hand, were faced with the decision to either cheer for Les Deseurters, as the Habitants became commonly called, or cheer for the crosstown Maroons, typically the team of Quebec's Anglophone population.
After a brief bump in attendance the first year, the AHL's numbers went down the second year, as the Habitants continued their mind-numbing dominance of the league. The AHL had to change some rules to try and level the playing field: for instance, ending a powerplay immediately after the team with a man advantage scored, instead of the LHR which would maintain the old rules. The AHL also turned to expansion in order to increase revenue, adding the Buffalo Bisons and Baltimore Unionists in 1949. Both teams had loyal fanbases and were successful financially, which could not be said for the next two franchises to join in 1951: the Saint Louis Choir and the Pontiac Firebirds. In 1954, the AHL reached out to the west coast with the Los Angeles Monarchs and Seattle Cosmos. Los Angeles was another questionable decision, but Seattle's new owners had a somewhat surprising strategy of recruiting players. Seattle had been the main target of Russian emigres to the United States since the Russian Civil War, including the man who would become the new team's coach and general manager, Anatoli Tarosov. Tarosov maintained some contacts in Russia, which had been the nation which had been most taken with hockey since the LHR's European tours.
No one knew what to expect when a team full of Russian players, but when the Cosmos took the ice they silenced all critics: they didn't give up a goal in their first three games, and they humiliated the Habitants 8-3 in Montreal the first time they played. Seattle posted the best record in the regular season, and while Montreal did get some revenge in the championship (winning Game 7 in overtime), the Cosmos took the cup their second year and the AHL's greatest rivalry was born.
A Third League Emerges
In 1950, Joseph Drapeau attempted to buy the Stanley Cup and donate it to the AHL: this was met with protests across the northern territories, and a New Brunswick man attempted to assassinate him (Drapeau would survive, but would be confined to a wheelchair for the rest of his life). The former Canada would seem to be fertile ground for expansion or recruitment by the AHL, were it not for the formation of the Northern Hockey Association in 1952.
The NHA's six teams: (Vancouver Gassers, Calgary Snipers, Edmonton Drillers, Winnipeg Firestarters, Ottawa Legion and Toronto Tecumsehs) played with aggression unseen in either the AHL or LHR: indeed, it seemed like Canadians were sublimating their frustrations at American dominance into hockey. Many NHA franchises are owned and staffed by veterans of the Canadian nationalist movement, and have been suspected of being tied into organized crime. Indeed, many promising players in Canada who get approached by talent scouts from either AHL or LHR teams are visited in the night by suspicious men who want to remind them where their loyalty belongs.
Spectator violence has been a major problem in NHA games, and has been a huge stumbling block to get exhibition games against teams of either professional league.