So I got distracted with a different idea and made a bit of a time skip. I'll work on the Red Rebellions (Scipio and the Colletons need to make an appearance sooner or later) and Mexico (Jeff Pinkard)...sooner or later.
V. For a Minute There, I Lost Myself
Charleston, South Carolina
November 2, 1921
“Freedom! Freedom! Freedom! Freedom!”
“Fea-ther-ston! Fea-ther-ston! Fea-ther-ston!”
“Down with the Yankees! Down with the Yankees!”
Roger Kimball shouted the slogans alongside the rest of his white-and-butternut-wearing brothers in arms as they marched along Calhoun. They’d started at White Point and headed due north along Meeting before turning left onto Calhoun. Now, as the leader of the procession, Kimball nudged Ernie the signaller, who raised his arms to indicate a right wheel up Ashley.
Close on nine hundred men – and more than a few women, which wasn't unheard of – moved with a coordination that told of where the vast majority of them had been employed five years ago.
The couple dozen cops who’d had the presence of mind to follow the column of Freedom Partiers were outclassed, brushed aside and forced to tag along after the procession like lost puppies. One of them, braver or stupider than his fellows, trotted along just above the marching pace of the column to address Kimball directly.
“What the hell do you gennelmen intend to do?” asked the grey figure with furrowed brow, sizing up the billy clubs and bayonets and pistols of the marchers as he nervously fiddled with his own six-shooter. Roger levelled his gaze at him, scarcely breaking from his chant to calmly address the officer.
“Why, to have a talk with those folks up yonder,” he replied. “In the spirit of democracy,” he added with a smirk, eyes glinting with malicious intent in the streetlights. The cop had little to say to that, and returned to the knot of his colleagues in grey for safety.
Roger’s grin was predatory as he saw the searchlights beaming into the air ahead. The Rad Libs had been damn quick to cotton on to the idea of illuminating their rallies after Anne Colleton got the Freedom Party to advertise its presence by doing the same. That just made it all the easier for the Freedom marchers to draw in on them.
The half-light was more than enough for Kimball and his comrades to observe the crowd (which, Roger begrudgingly admitted to himself, was a little over half the size of the Freedom Party’s rally last month) gathered in front of the stage where the nigger-loving, Yankee-kissing, Red-baiting traitor sang his high-pitched schoolboy song. As he spoke, the Freedom Party men gathered with military discipline in ranks. The plan had been hammered into everyone before they left Party HQ: nobody to say a damn word before Roger gave the go-ahead. In the meantime, Layne’s warbling bullshit served to get their dander up just fine.
“…out of hand the violence and hatred of Featherston. I put it to you, Charleston, cradle of our proud and great land, that there is an illness in our country. An illness of which the Freedom Party is but the most severe symptom so far, an illness which turns brother against brother and threatens to tear us apart in an orgy of bloodletting at a time when what we need is…”
“Peace!” came the shout from the crowd. “Reconciliation!”
“Yes! Peace and reconciliation! The road ahead is a hard one, but we must and shall cure this illness…”
Roger snorted and rolled his eyes, turning to the men arranged behind him.
“Seems the Yankee-lover feels poorly,” he said with a raised voice which turned a few heads in the crowd near them. “How’s about we give him a dose of our medicine, boys?”
“Freedom!” came the roar from forty score mouths, interrupting Layne’s amplified voice with a piercing spear of sound. “Freedom!” they bellowed again as they stormed forwards, charging into the crowd.
The melee erupted predictably, with the discipline of the Freedom marchers – Stalwarts, Roger’d heard them called, even if he thought it was a weak name – showing as they came up against the bully boys the Rattlers [2] had picketed around their little picnic just how outmatched and, Kimball thought, outclassed they were.
“For God’s sake!” cried Layne as the panic spread through the crowd. “Let us have peace!”
If the Radical Liberals wanted peace, they did a supremely poor job of showing it..
Say what you like for the Red bastards, he thought as he swung his club and connected with flesh and bone,
they go down harder than Whigs. As the Rad Lib he’d hit fell to the ground with a shout, he laughed and swung a boot into the man while he was down. Something cracked, and Roger trod on him as he moved on.
Break plenty easy, though.
The rank of Rad Libs was enough to ward off the first rank of Freedomites, and if it had only been, say, two hundred instead of nine, they might have been able to blunt the offensive. As it happened, the surge Roger led was more than able to break them entirely, and set about making for the stage. Straight out of the manual they’d been playing from all fall, really.
And everything went pretty textbook – enemy defends, Party attacks, enemy is crushed, Party advances – until Roger, turning to break a Rad Lib’s arm and smash his nose in by headbutting him with his tin hat, heard three shots ring out behind him. The screams grew even louder, and as Roger glanced at the stage and noticed that Layne had finally shut up, a horrifying thought dawned upon him. As his eyes regained focus and saw the candidate falling clumsily backwards, arms spinning out every which way, it was confirmed and amplified.
“What the fuck did you just do?” roared Kimball, spinning on his heel to face the man behind him as chaos broke out completely. The man – Kimball thought it might be one of the veterans, a younger fellow named Baines – clutched his pistol in whitening knuckles, grin slipping from his face as Roger’s own face contorted in sheer fury.
“You said we was here to teach the nigger-lovers a less-”
“You Goddamn shit-brained mule-fucker! Do you have any idea what you just did?”
The shooter – fuck, was he an assassin now? – scrambled to find his words as one of Roger’s lieutenants, a Navy man named Osmond Ingram, grabbed his shoulder.
“Skipper, we gotta go,” he said with blood running from a gash on his forehead and a split lip. “The police are already shootin’ and somebody been hollerin’ ‘bout the millies [1] bein’ called up.”
Roger nodded and made to snarl at Baines, but he’d already started moving off through the crowd. Shots were ringing out left and right now, screams punctuating the still, cool night.
“Fuck it, let’s get outta here,” Kimball said, shaking his head. The Party had overstepped its bounds in the battle here today. Hopefully, it wouldn’t lose them the war.
From Perrin, R., The Rise and Fall of the Freedom Party.
Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2003.
The Assassination of Ainsworth Layne
Ainsworth Layne, 1877-1921 [3]
“Man’s a martyr to his own Goddamned principles.”
- Burton Mitchel III
Vice-President of the CSA, 1921-19██ [4]
One fact needs to be made abundantly clear before engaging in any kind of serious discussion on the ill-fated leader of the Radical Liberals: Ainsworth Layne was never going to win the Presidency, despite the fair showing the Rad Libs had made in 1915. For it is often overlooked that prior to his assassination, the party was coming a very distant third to both the Whigs and Freedom, with his message of “Peace and Reconciliation” falling flat in a country which was suffering under heretofore unknown privations at the hands of their Northern adversaries in what the Harvard-educated candidate euphemistically referred to as “the late unpleasantness.”
It would be unfair, however, to claim that Layne was only ever of any significance as a martyr. A lawyer from Arkansas, he brought to the Radical Liberals an exemplar of the upwardly-mobile self-made man the Party presented itself as the vanguard of…
…organised violence was nothing new in the campaign; several had already been brutally injured or outright killed, especially in clashes between Radical Liberal and Freedom, but with the Whigs (as the governing party and thus party of defeat) drawing plenty of ire themselves. Before Charleston, the bloodiest fight had come early in the campaign in an August rally in Dallas, where the woefully underprepared Whigs, having a scant few dozen men armed with clubs, were charged by a Redemption League squad which found itself barely bloodily repulsed by a gathering galvanised by the presence of the Vice-Presidential candidate Burton Mitchel, who had allegedly shouted callous (and, according to primary sources, extremely vulgar) defiance at Willy Knight’s followers whilst brandishing his pistol and exhorting the Whigs to “make ‘em bleed for it.” While this had the effect of making Mitchel something of a folk hero for the Whigs, it didn’t suffice to overcome the damage fifty years of single-party dominance had done to the Whigs’ ability to campaign effectively. Constantly on the back foot as President Semmes remained impotent in the face of an economy hitting rock bottom, the Whigs ceded more and more ground to the Freedom Party-Redemption League alliance as summer turned into fall, to the point that a Featherston victory looked inevitable.
And then, less than a week from the election, the Charleston branch of the Freedom Party got greedy. Marching against the last major opposition rally in the state before the election, the clash spun wildly out of control, with a disgruntled Freedom Party member, William Baines, firing three shots at Ainsworth Layne as he stood on the stage and implored the audience to calm down. The event constituted the first successful assassination of a Presidential candidate in either the Union or Confederacy. [5]
The after-effects were predictable. In the immediate term, Charleston briefly descended into anarchy, with the police chief (like many other older civil servants, a staunch Whig) ordering the entire Police Department out on the streets to suppress anticipated rioting and the Mayor calling in the local State Militia contingent to reinforce them. But it was the Citadel, Charleston’s prestigious military school and alma mater of many a Whig military scion, which stole the spotlight as Superintendent Colonel Bond ordered more than two hundred of his cadets – many armed with blank ammunition in real rifles – across the two hundred yards between the Citadel and Hampton Park to quickly cordon off the area and detain those suspected of causing trouble...organiser and war hero Roger Kimball [6] found himself briefly detained in that initial rush, but was later released without charge when Baines’s body was retrieved by Citadel cadets and Kimball, among others, testified to his role in the assassination…
…Stalwarts melted away into the night, with sporadic violence continuing until before dawn, by which time the news was spreading across the Confederacy. From Guaymas to Norfolk, the word was out: The Freedom Party had killed one of the candidates. Who, many asked, could vote for such people?
As it transpired, a surprisingly large number; approximately thirty-nine percent of the population to the Whigs’ forty-three and the Radical Liberals’ seventeen. In the manifold retellings and analyses of the election which have followed, it has been debated whether Ainsworth Layne did in fact prevent Featherston from winning in 1921. And while it may be argued that the swing away from the Freedom Party in the last six days of campaigning was insufficient to warrant the credit many have given the assassination for the survival of the Whigs in that election, it is hard to deny that their narrowly-won victory enabled them to prove themselves, at least in the interim, the only party which could offer the ‘return to normality’ Hampton campaigned on, an image which would be crucial to their prospects for the rest of the decade and beyond.
It would also, however, be a watershed for the Radical Liberals. Peace and Reconciliation, it was argued, had demonstrably failed, no matter how nobly. If Featherston was to be brought down, suggested voices within the party, it would have to be by using his own tactics against him…
The Election of 1921
203 EVs: 102 needed to win
Wade Hampton V (W-SC)/Burton Mitchel (W-AR): 108 EV
Jacob Featherston (F-VA)/Ferdinand Koenig (F-NC): 67 EV
Plutarco Elias Calles (RL-SO) [7] /position vacant [8]: 28 EV
[1] Colloquialism for ‘militia’; State Militias are TTL’s Confederate version of the National Guard. The US has a National Guard, but it is more comparable to the ARNG in terms of its federal oversight – the states of the Union have far less autonomy ITTL, for obvious reasons.
[2] Known as such for the rattlesnake on the Gadsden Flag, which has been appropriated by the Rad Libs – a party of small farmers and the urban poor/middle class – as a symbol. They’re actually quite proud of the name, even if Layne resents being called a damnyankee snake in the grass by Featherston.
[3] Why yes, that is Peter Finch. A histrionic figure convinced of the righteousness of his ultimately unpopular cause – how could I
not draw a comparison with Howard Beale?
[4] With thanks to Tiro for inspiration on the character of Burton Mitchel, about whom we'll be hearing a bit later.
[5] Okay, so Joseph Smith was very technically a candidate in 1844, but even IOTL it’s debatable and ITTL the Confederates will take credit for any achievement they can.
[6] He’s a bastard, alright, but a bastard who earned the Order of the
Virginia, TTL’s CS Navy equivalent of the Medal of Honor.
[7] The Radical Liberal name on the ballot wasn’t changed in time for the election, naturally, but Radical Liberal electoral votes were cast for Calles after the erstwhile Vice-Presidential nominee was given the nod by the Party (which was understandably preoccupied). It’s been speculated ITTL that his Catholicism cost the Rad Libs Louisiana, but that’s generally accepted to be a thinly-veiled slur against his race – the Freedom convention in New Orleans, the large number of unemployed veterans, and the intense violence in the state as a three-way battleground had substantially more to do with it.
[8] With Calles kicked upstairs and less than a week left to the election, there wasn’t time to nominate a new Vice-Presidential candidate, with the Rad Libs throwing their lot in behind Burton Mitchel as VP pick. Strange bedfellows, and all that; it also gave him the strongest Electoral College vote for a candidate for either of the top two offices since the 1891 election.