During the 1990s the producer Philip Segal had worked with
Universal Television and
BBC Worldwide at reviving
Doctor Who which had been off the air since 1989, and this time the plan was to make the show with a US broadcaster. Initially there was little interest from networks in picking the show, with all except for
Fox declining it outright. Trevor Walton, VP in charge of TV-movie production agreed to produce a television movie designed to serve as a backdoor pilot and work began on it in 1995. But things would not be easy. Initially there were conflicts regarding the nature of the movie, if it should be a reboot or a continuation of the original series. Segal was first in favor of a complete reboot but was brought on board to the idea of a continuation by Walton and writer Matthew Roberts. However the Roberts' script was later deemed inadquate by other
Fox executives and the movie therefore went through numerous rewrites, with different writers being brought in throughout 1995 and early 1996. Eventually the project was shelved by
Fox despite Walton and Segal's objection and the
Doctor Who revival entered development hell.
Despite Segal's best attempt no progress was made with the show thus he was ready to walk out in '97 and would have if the big break hadn't come. At this point in time the young network
UPN was seeing some major success with sci-fi/fantasy shows like
Star Trek and
The Sentinel and was defining itself as the definitive sci-fi network. As the channel was expanding its broadcasts into additional nights it was looking for new programming and
Doctor Who could be a perfect fit. With a Segal taking a less hands-on role this time a new writer and producer would be needed and after a young up-and-comer in the business signed a deal with
Universal after failing to get his own show picked up, there was a light at the end of the tunnel. J.J. Abrams was brought on as an Executive Producer and showrunner and given the job of writing the pilot.
There was some concern from the
BBC at putting an American with so little familliarity with
Doctor Who in charge, however they were placated by Mark Gatiss and Paul Cornell being brought on the creative team as staff writer and Executive Story Editor respectively. Then came the issue of who would play the Eighth Doctor. Paul McGann had been the favourite when the tv-movie was in development, but was now unavailable after being cast as Qui-Gonn Jinn in
Star Wars: The Phantom Menace. The
BBC made it an ultimatum that the Doctor be played by a British actor, however their first pick Rowan Atkinson was deemed too dour and uncharismatic by American test audiences. Hugh Laurie was also a top pick by the
BBC but he was taken out of the running after joining
The WB's new show
Buffy the Vampire Slayer, so eventually it landed on another British actor looking at making a big break in America to take the role. Anthony Head was cast as the Eighth Doctor, with a premiere set for February 1998. In interviews Head would say that one of his main inspirations for his Doctor was Jon Pertwee's Doctor, and that certainly shone through. The Eighth Doctor had the characteristics of an well mannered (if somewhat sarcastic) gentleman adventurer known for his trademark worn leather jacket and never being above throwing a punch whenever the situation called for it.
Then it came down to the companion and with Head cast as the Doctor
UPN wanted an American actress to play her. After a difficult search Jennifer Garner was cast as Casey Sloane, who takes a front and centre role in the pilot where she plays a medical student who has a run in with a strange new professor, The Doctor in disguise. The first 13-episode season got good reviews and ratings which made it a lock for renewal, despite fan criticism of there being too much focus placed on the new villain called the Covenant, a group of Earth businessmen attempting to get hold of aliens and alien technology. The Covenant would be the main villain for the first four and a half seasons, however after listening to fan criticism of the prominence it had in the first season, the show became more episodic from season 2 and onwards. It took a similar path to The X-Files by being mostly episodic but with a few 'mythology'-episodes per season thrown in to advance the story arc. Also as a bit of fan service, UNIT were brought back in Season 2 with the Scottish UNIT Captain Michael Baker (Kevin McKidd) added to the main cast and the Brigadier making 6 guest appearances.
The Covenant arc came to an end in the season 4 mid-season two-parter with Casey being killed in the final battle as Jennifer Garner was moving on to a film career. The death of Casey was however controversial in the British tabloids as Doctor Who was still very much considered a family show in the UK, and her death from a gunshot wound led to a debate about the nature of the show and if it could still be considered child-friendly. Kevin McKidd left the show at the same time as Garner, so Amy Acker playing Casey's sister Olivia was left as the sole companion until the end of season four when D.B. Woodside joined the cast as Jack Martin, a U.S. Army Captain picked up by the Doctor on the european front in World War II.
In his final season as the Doctor, Anthony Head was left as the last castmember from the first season (Acker appeared as a guest star in one season 1 episode), as Amy Acker had left the show to join Joss Whedon's new science fiction show
Serenity. D.B. Woodside stayed on as Jack Martin and a new character, the tough and opinionated journalist Rebecca Lee portrayed by Janeane Garofalo, was added to the cast. The last season of the Eighth Doctor's run was also the first one with Paul Cornell as the showrunner since J.J. Abrams had left at the end of season 4 to pursue other projects. Season 5 was mostly episodic in nature without any major story arc stretching over the course of the season, but it was significant in that it brought back The Master who had last appeared in the 1998 serial
Survival. Bill Nighy's menacing but soft spoken Master turned out to be a fan favourite and after the season finale where he left the Doctor bleeding out, on the brink of regeneration, fans were already clamoring for his return.
So Anthony Head's reign as the Doctor came to an end when the character regenerated at the end of season 5, with Eddie Izzard getting the difficult job of carrying the role forward.