The Ultimate Irony: A Fascist Israel Challenge

Which of these are more realistic\make a better story

  • Jewish Defense League seizes power instead of being banned.

    Votes: 10 55.6%
  • Ben-Gurion goes mad with power.

    Votes: 3 16.7%
  • Military coup d'etat by an unknown,young,and charismaticHitler-esque figure

    Votes: 3 16.7%
  • Israeli extremists cull government blame it on the enemy,do a coup d'etat

    Votes: 2 11.1%

  • Total voters
    18
Status
Not open for further replies.
Didn't the Israeli economy pretty much go down the toilet in the 70s and 80s, to the extent that there was a spate of mass nationalisations and they had to switch out the currency for a new one? Turn that up the 11, be it they get hit with a perfect storm of atrocious economic factors or the governments refuse to implement harsh measures needed to combat it due to political fears, with the economy going into absolute meltdown and in times of crisis people could turn to more extreme movements. On the face of it fascist parties could offer what looks like an new alternative to the usual left or right wing policies in the form of a third way.
 
The goal of this is to see if it is PLAUSIBLE to have a fascist Israel post Israeli War of Independence. The objective is to have Israel remain fascist until either
  • end of Cold War(1989 or other date)
  • Some other pivotal event
  • or present day
Adieu
Jabotinski and his rightwing zionist revisionists were regarded as fascists, so if he had not wasted his great chance to lead the overall zionist movement, the state of Israel might have been more of a fascist state, instead of the OTL socialist early Israel.

Would Begin still be his successor as leader of the revisionists, and the first prime minister of Israel?
 
Frankly none of those concepts sound remotely responsible. Also, an easier way to note who your responding too would simply to click the QUOTE button at the bottom right corner of the post's box. That should do it.
 
I don't see anything Ironic about a Fascist Israel, a Nazi Israel with obvious religious and cultural changes that would be ironic. You could have an Iron Guard esqe Fascism with it's emphasis on religion, and stress the need for a strong military to defend against enemies of the Jewish people, while uphold Jewish ideals.

Although this seems like a long shot idea no matter what, unless you have an alternate Israel come about, with it's oppression of it's people not coming from the radical right but radical left. Anti-Semitic communists kill their Jewish populations or force them out for being enemies of the workers. In reaction Jewish nationalists rally around the call of an Israel that will defend the Jewish people and traditions at all costs.
 
I don't see anything Ironic about a Fascist Israel, a Nazi Israel with obvious religious and cultural changes that would be ironic. You could have an Iron Guard esqe Fascism with it's emphasis on religion, and stress the need for a strong military to defend against enemies of the Jewish people, while uphold Jewish ideals.

I know what you meant, but when I saw it , I was like "Anti-Smeitic and Ultra Christian?"
 
As I have said before what I meant by this version of Fascist Israel is a nation that still embodies the idea of a Jewish Homeland,and became fascist AFTER it's OTL War of Independence!
 
If it's after the War of Independence, than a Fascist Israel is something that no one would consider to touch with a 50ft pole. Fascism by then is tainted with it's synonymous association with the Nazi's that it can't happen. You would need an alternate creation for Israel that doesn't involve active genocide and prejudice from the right, as a motivator for it's existence.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top