"A Hate as True as the Wrath of Jev:" The Yankees-Brown Caps Rivalry
Video footage of an Oswald Era Brawl between the Philadelphia Yankees and the Schicagwa Brown Caps
There are few things that rile up a Yankee more than The Pinnacle Game. Rounders is followed in the Fascist Empire almost as closely as the AFC Church itself, and team loyalties and passions are fervent. Conversely, hatred for one's rivals is so spittle flecked and vitriolic that some even go so far as to accuse their opponents of Infee heritage, albeit mostly in an unserious manner. However, even by the standards of American Rounders there is no rivalry so vicious, no hatred so deeply felt, and no series so closely watched as the rivalry between the Philadelphia Yankees and the Shicagwa Brown Caps. Both teams are in the Liberty League, both teams are world-class Rounders outfits, and both teams represent America's biggest and most important cities. The story of this rivalry is long and strange, filled with tales of violence, corruption, debauchery, betrayal, and drug fueled delusions. It is a quintessential American story, and by gazing into this rivalry, one might hope to understand the strange and twisted soul of the Pinnacle Race.
The first three game series between the Yankees and the Brown Caps was played in 1880 at the Old Yankee Stadium. The Yankees were led by former Camden Gold Caps pitcher Sam Langley, a true titan of the game, who made up for the Yankees' underdeveloped slugger bench with his sheer talent as a pitcher. This was the start of Philadelphia's surprising "Dominant Decade," in which they won the National Championships every year. Predictably in such a good year, they swept the series with the Brown Caps. During the first game Sam Langley had thrown a wild pitch at the star slugger for the Brown Caps, Archibald Hardrada, breaking his arm and forcing him to sit out the rest of the humiliating series, and in fact much of the season. His career never fully recovered from the incident. Although Langley swore up and down that the pitch had been accidental, the Brown Caps increasingly became convinced that he had done it deliberately. In reality, given the fact that Langley paid for Hardrada's medical expenses and later stuck up a friendship with "Archie the Ace," it does indeed seem likely that the pitch was an accident and that Brown Caps players and fans slowly latched onto a conspiracy theory to explain their humiliating 5 year losing streak to Philadelphia, which started in that game. In 1886, the Brown Caps finally broke the "Hardrada Curse," winning their series against the Yankees 2-1. The final deciding game, played on April 11th, became the font of more conspiracy theories as it was believed that the Brown Caps had fixed the game. This is partially true. They attempted to bribe an umpire by the name of Marcus Bowdoin, but he refused their offer of $500 (a princely sum for the time) out of respect for the game. Nonetheless, as the truth came out, Yankees fans were outraged and demanded that NRA officials "Stop the Steal" and award the series to the Yankees as compensation. The NRA refused, as they themselves were fairly corrupt, and no other evidence of corruption emerged. To this day, Yankees fans insist that the 1886 Series should be awarded to their team, and litigation regarding the series would continue to be filed by wealthy fans into the Oswald Administration. This was the birth of a rivalry, the product of conspiracy theories, bribery, and one bad pitch. Before we continue to describe the history of this fascinating rivalry, let's take a moment to examine the cultural factors behind its growth and intensity.
One of the greatest lies told by America's enemies is that the nation is a monolithic empire where all are the same. While America is for sure a totalitarian superstate, and while this stereotype may have had a certain truth in the Steele Administration, the American empire is a vast realm with many regional subcultures. Philadelphia, along with Boston and New York, is the heart of Greater New England, and the region takes great pride in its Colonial heritage. Shicagwa is the cultural and economic capital of the Middle West, a vast region encompassing Ohio, Iowai, Michigania, Chersonesus, Osage, parts of Dakota and Lewisland, and Mississippi. The Middle West is often neglected in studies of American culture, lacking the prestige of New England, the racial history of the South, the frontier spirit of the West, the military history of Canada, and of course the toughness and hyper-Americaness of the Old Mexicans. However, the region is decidedly not bland. Settled by a colorful assortment of Scandinavians, Germans, French Protestants, and Ukrainian Jews, the Middle West is a region defined by a down-home focus on family, a talent for agriculture, faith in God, and a kind of orderliness and work ethic that anyone can admire. Alongside this, they have excellent breweries and a fantastic German music scene that has developed over the years. Nonetheless, the region is constantly derided as boring and even "less Pinnacle" than the rest of the country. These stereotypes began emerging at around the same time as the Custer Administration rose to power, not aided by the fact that the Middle West was the part of the country least enthused by Custer's takeover (excepting his home state of Ohio, which was overjoyed). This all contributed to a massive inferiority complex on the part of Middle Westerners, who responded by loudly proclaiming their Pinnacle Fluidation and looking for opportunities to best the rest of the country. Simultaneously, Shicagwa had rapidly become the industrial capital of the Union, and was among the most important cities in the entirety of the continent straddling juggernaut that was America. Philadelphians looked down upon the "soot covered hickerbillies" of the Middle Western Colossus, while Shicagwans considered Philadelphians "Pinnacle Parasites feasting on the tax dollars of a country conquered by men Better than they." Each city vied for supremacy in every endeavor, and this inevitably bled over into sport. Of course, no one knew just how intense it would become.
Pro-democracy protesters in Lindale, Dakota on the eve of the Velvet Revolution. Lindale, like many Middle Western towns, was settled by Germans and Scandinavians who believed in true democracy for Betters. The town would later go through an ORRA purge of dissidents.
After the "Decade of Dominance" that was the 1880s, both the Yankees and the Brown Caps took something of a backseat to the Toronto Blue Caps and the Boston Patriots, who enjoyed periods of dominance in the 1890's that would help cement those teams as elite franchises as well. However, by the turn of the century, American Rounders was once again the Philly-Shicagwa Show. In 1901 Philadelphia recruited Arnold Jefferson, a Virginian born descendant of enslaved Black Betters, as their star pitcher. Arnold Jefferson would pitch a then-record 135 perfect games over the course of his career, was the first Black man to compete in professional athletics in the Carolinas (in an exhibition game between Philadelphia and Prophetstown as part of Custer's efforts to tie Carolinian culture ever more closely to the Yankees), and to this day is considered one of the best pitchers to ever play the game. Arnold helped cement a pattern that was already emerging in this rivalry: Philadelphia, despite having many star sluggers, was most known for its world-class pitching corps to deny points to their opponents, while Shicagwa focused on having sluggers who could just nail the ball no matte what. Jefferson won 6 National Championships for Philadelphia and received a personal commendation from President Custer. Off the diamond, Jefferson was a notorious party animal, albeit one who closely followed anti-miscegenation laws out of both belief and fear. At the peak of his career in 1907, the "Virginia Viper" consumed over 3500 bottles of champagne, smoked 900 cartons of Firebreathers, and is believed to have impregnated 70 women in that year alone. Despite much of this being either immoral or illegal, Jefferson was given a "Tobias Token" by the AFC Church and ORRA, so-named for the Blind Christian Gentleman, and in 1904 the AFC proclaimed "
In service to furthering the Pinnacle Race and improving the bloodlines of the Black American population, Mr. Arnold Jefferson is allowed and asked to lovingly lay with as many women of his race as possible so that the Seed of the Pinnacle Man might overspread the Earth and hasten the coming of the New JerUSAlem." The media suppressed stories of Jefferson's sexual dalliances, allowing Mrs. Violet Jefferson to continue living in blissful ignorance about her husband's behavior.
Jefferson was absolutely hated among Shicagwans because he not only beat their beloved Brown Caps constantly, but seemed to take relish in humiliating them. He would stick out his buttocks at fans, engage in mocking gestures on the pitchers mound, and openly taunt the team's sluggers. He especially delighted in harassing one Matthew Fernsby for the great crime of being an Anglo-Saxon from Natchez, Florida in the Old South. This behavior came to a head on June 13th, 1910, at the third game of a four game series played in Goodyear Field, Home of the Brown Caps. Fernsby came up to bat with bases loaded in the bottom of the eighth, with the Brown Caps down by 3. Hitting a homer would tie up the game and give the Caps a fighting chance coming into the ninth. Jefferson also knew this. He proceeded to engage in his usual trash talk as he tried to evaluate which kind of pitch to throw to Fernsby. A curveball? A fastball, maybe? Fernsby remained laser focused, not letting Jefferson's infamous psychological warfare get to him. Jefferson realized this and decided to break one of America's great taboos to try and seal the game. He called out "
Hey Matty, lemme ask ya this ol' chum. Did your whore momma like layin' with Black men as much as I heard? Maybe I'll visit her after the game and become your new Daddy!" Fernsby was famously the son of a deceased veteran of the Mexican Immolation and raised by a single mother, who he adored. As the crowd began to boo and hiss, Fernsby calmly walked towards the pitchers mound, bat in hand, as Jefferson ignored him to delight in the crowd's hatred. 30 seconds later, Matthew Fernsby stood on the pitchers mound holding a bat dripping with blood as he stood over Arnold Jefferson's body and caved in skull. Irate Yankees fans surged towards the field to be met by the Brown Caps, who had gathered up their bats and protective gear, and formed a kind of pseudo-testudo formation. They were quickly reinforced by their fellow Shicagwans, who outnumbered the Yankees fans by a 2-1 margin. After 15 minutes of combat, the outnumbered Yankees fans fled the stadium and disappeared into the city. The Battle of Goodyear, as it was known, was the largest Rounders riot up to that point in American history. Matthew Fernsby was pardoned by President Custer, as popular opinion among most Betters was that Jefferson had crossed a line, with even most Black Americans disowning him in the immediate aftermath. It would take a generation for Arnold Jefferson to re-enter the Pantheon of Rounders as memory of the incident faded from view.
The Great Rivalry, as many were now calling the Yankees-Brown Caps feud, was put on hold for the duration of the Great War. Even in the immediate aftermath of the war from 1915-1920, the rivalry was calmer and more subdued as leftover hyper-nationalism meant that sectional differences didn't inflame quite like they used to. However, as wartime unity faded to be replaced by the roaring boom of post-war America, the Great Rivalry came surging back. In 1921, Brown Caps slugger Owen Hughes was a rising star of Rounders, rivaled only by Yankees pitcher Noam Goldman, the most prominent "Man of Zion" to ever play the game as of this time. The Yankees were still extremely sore over the murder of Arnold Jefferson, and desired to somehow humiliate the Yankees in return. Goldman managed to do this quite by accident. It was an open secret that Hughes's wife Amelia absolutely despised him. He beat her, demeaned her, and cheated without consequence as he too had attained a Tobias Token from his good personal friend Billy Sunday. The famously charming Goldman found Amelia Hughes outside of a party hosted by the NRA on April 1st to commemorate March on Philadelphia Day, crying and bruised as a result of another of her husband's beatings. He was taken by her immense beauty. Goldman seduced her then and there, resulting in a torrid affair, during which time Amelia Hughes gave Goldman her husband's famous practice notes, allowing him to obliterate the star slugger whenever they met. Knowledge of the affair broke when the Brown Caps were playing the Yankees at Yankee Stadium in early June, 1922. Hughes was first enraged and then suffered a nervous breakdown, believing that the fact the he was cuckolded by "
That miserable fucking Jew" meant that he was not the Pinnacle Man he believed himself to be. Hughes had always prided himself on his ability to utterly dominate his wife while living like a King of Old Israel, and the knowledge that he couldn't actually do that proved too much for his self image. Owen Hughes hanged himself in his hotel room on June 4th, 1922. In direct violation of his own law, President Steele not only allowed Goldman to live and continue to play, he attended the pitcher's wedding to Amelia Hughes (now Goldman) in July 1922. Steele was an ardent Yankees fan and despite his evil adored his own wife immensely, meaning he was more than happy that America's second-most prominent wife beater had offed himself. Goldman would continue to be the star pitcher for the Yankees until 1928.
Yankees pitcher Noam Goldman, AKA "The Saven Slinger" in 1923
We shall close out this tale by focusing on the last major character and event that took place in this rivalry before Manifest Climax again froze Rounders into stasis and suppressed regional rivalries in favor of the common good. By 1926, a Shicagwa Brown Caps still reeling from the cuckolding and suicide of Owen Hughes was trying to overcome their worst four years in franchise history, with the NRA being dominated by the Toronto Blue Caps and the hated Yankees in the Liberty League, while the Boston Patriots, Camden Minutemen, and Oshkosh Vikings vied for supremacy of the Destiny League. The Brown Caps, meanwhile, stewed in internal dissension and debauchery. They had seemingly recovered in 1923 and beat the Yankees in 2 of their 3 series, but those had been fixed by team owner Jebediah Preston of the Preston Bank of Michigania, and when his deception was uncovered both series were given to the Yankees and he was himself sent to a camp and replaced by his cousin Mark. Despite the raw talent present in the Brown Caps's bench, their lack of cohesion and constant feuding under a new owner and weak management meant that in the 1925 season the Brown Caps suffered their very first losing season, with a .395 win average and a sixth place finish in the Liberty League, just barely above the Haddonfield Brewers and Crawford Wolverines, widely considered joke teams by the big players. The franchise was in crisis. However, in 1926, like Moses, a new slugger appeared to lead the Brown Caps out of the wilderness and into the Promised Land once more.
Adler Durchdenwald was the son of an American father of German heritage and a Swedish immigrant mother, born in Davenport, Michigania in 1907. The eldest of 6, the young Adler had an All-American childhood in Davenport where he did, in fact, attain the rank of All-American. Adler's father David was cold and distant for most of his life, a product of Great War induced PTSD. Although his father earned more than enough to keep the family comfortable, in almost every other way Adler was thrust into the father role. He attended meetings with teachers for his younger siblings, ensured the family got up in time for church, and even disciplined his siblings. Alongside these adult responsibilities and his CYB duties, young Adler discovered he had a talent for Rounders, which his mother encouraged. He became the best youth slugger in the state of Michigania, batting a .340 his freshman year of high school and leading his school to 4 consecutive state championships. Standing 6'2" and weighing in at 220 lbs at the age of 18, the powerfully built hazel-eyed brunette was the very vision of the ideal Pinnacle Man. Not that Adler needed to be told that by strangers (though he was, frequently). Aside from the acclaim of his schoolmates and strangers, the obsessions of the local girls and women (Adler revealed in his 1960 memoir that he lost his virginity at 14 shortly after winning his first state championship to the game's guest of honor, 1921 Miss Michigania Ella Cooper, who was 28 at the time) and the admiration of his teachers and coaches, the key to understanding the rather titanic ego and unhinged personality that was Adler Durchdenwald is in evaluating his relationship with his mother and then his wife. Let's examine his mother first.
His mother Johanna, a gorgeous and tall blonde, was a fervent AFC convert who became despondent after her once lively and vigorous husband came home from the Canadian Front a broken man. While she never strayed (partially thanks to Steele's strict anti-adultery legislation) she did become increasingly dissatisfied with her marriage. She did, however, admire the way her eldest son naturally filled the role of de facto man of the house and seemed to excel at everything he did. As her son matured she became more and more obsessed with him, convinced that she had "
borne the most Pinnacle Man to ever bestride the state of Michigania." Allegations of an inappropriate sexual relationship between the two swirled for years, although no one dared to investigate. At the very least, it can be determined that they had an emotionally incestuous relationship. Much as he de facto became his siblings' father, he de facto became his mother's husband. He arranged for flowers to be sent to her every week, took her out for steaks at Davenport's best restaurant (where he always ate for free as the town's hero), and escorted her to her Women's MDP events. On her end, Johanna treated her son like a spoiled tyrant. He had complete control over his siblings, the family auto, and even what his mother wore, and at the end of each day after his siblings were in for the night he recalled "
Mother used the arts of Swedish massage she had learned as a young woman in Stockholm to soothe my aching muscles. While she did so, she would help mend my weary mind by praising the immense thickness and vigor of my Pinnacle Fluids, and addressed me as "Her Caesar." The only way in which his mother controlled him was in trying to scare off his many, many female admirers and girlfriends. When he was 18, with her encouragement, young Adler declared for the NRA Draft and was picked up by Shicagwa.
Adler Durchdenwald, Shicagwa's "Strong Man Slugger."
In his first season in 1926, many were skeptical that Adler would do much for the ailing Brown Caps. Sure the kid had talent, but that wouldn't matter much if the team could not gather itself together. However, young Adler was a born leader, and he knew how to assert his dominance. During a dispute over cigars between first basemen Richard Korhonen and pitcher Willy Mayer, the 18 year old simply beat both men to a pulp and took the cigars. Following the rules of Social Darwinism, Durchdenwald was made team captain. Now under the iron-fisted leadership of their "Tyrant Tot," as the media disparagingly called him, Adler stunned the nation by batting .335 and leading the Brown Caps to their first National Championship in a decade. All joking about the brash young man ended and even Joe Steele, a diehard Yankees fan, praised the young third basemen and slugging superstar. He would lead the Brown Caps to further Championships in '27, '28, '31, '32, '33, and '35. The once dismissive media dubbed him "
An athletic Aeneas, a bully boy of ball, or simply, the Strong Man Slugger," and he took to fame with relish. He lived lavishly, building a compound in the shape of a Rounders diamond outside of Shicagwa. The "Palace of Slugging" as the press called it, was 5 separate buildings made from white limestone. Home plate was his 7500 sq foot mansion, the pitchers mound a large gymnasium, first base was the 5000 sq ft "guest" house, second base servants' quarters, and third base was a 6000 sq ft home for his mother. Construction was completed in 1928, in time for Adler to move in to his palace with his bride, who we shall now cover before getting to the Great Rounders Riot of 1935.
In 1927, fresh off his second championship, Adler Durchdenwald met Klara Nilsson, a beautiful blonde 22 year old Swedish immigrant who had been a champion fencer and was currently a Rounders fanatic. The two connected instantly, and on a much deeper level than any of Adler's previous conquests. A fervent believer in Fundamentalism and the Strong Man Theory, she, like many American women, was utterly obsessed with the Boy-King of Rounders. After a whirlwind courtship, the two married and moved into his palatial complex outside Shicagwa. There, she introduced Adler to LSD and group sex. Firm believers in Spiritual Marxism, the two would frequently laze about and drop acid together. Adler had increasingly insane hallucinations that depicted him as a Greek God, wielding a rounders bat and smiting his foes with it before laying with multiple Greek Goddesses dressed as Lady Liberty, Aphrodite, and Boudicca. His bisexual wife took this as a sign that Adler and her were clearly meant to work together to spread his Bloodline together. Having received his Tobias Token from the AFC, Adler and Klara founded what was essentially the world's first Rounders-themed sex cult. There were 11 "stars" taken in, all tall, beautiful blondes. His wife was the 12th star, and they centered the 13th or Pinnacle Star, Adler, who based the structure of this cult on the 13 stars of the Blood-Stained Banner of the Revolution. The 11 subsidiary women were required to wear Brown Caps cheerleading uniforms on the property. They served Adler first and then Klara when he wasn't present. All 11 women were even more worshipful towards Adler than his wife and mother. When combined with his legions of fans, his budding personality cult within the Brown Caps organization, and the national acclaim he had achieved, Durchdenwald became ever more unhinged, seeing himself as something of a Pinnacle athletic warrior-god who was going to found his own tribe (given that he had 62 children between his wife and 11 disciples, he arguably did). This would all come to a head after he defeated the Philadelphia Yankees in a close series in 1935.
August 11th, 1935. The final game of the final series of the regular season was between Shicagwa and Philadelphia. The 3 game series was tied 1-1. The winner would win the Liberty League and likely go on to be National Champs. Philadelphia took the lead in the second inning and held on until it was the bottom of the ninth. Yankees lead by 1, with two Brown Caps on the bases. There have already been two outs. Durchdenwald comes up to bat. He hits a record setting 753rd homer. Shicagwa wins the game and the series. Philadelphia fans are outraged, calling the game rigged and demanding that the last inning be replayed due to alleged (read, imagined) irregularities in officiating. Boos ring out. Adler takes up the microphone used by a local singing prodigy to belt out the national anthem. In one final show of disrespect to the Yankees, he launches into an epic tirade known simply as the "Look Upon Me" speech.
"Yes, look upon me, you vanquished lesser Pinnacle Men! Look upon me and weep for you have been beaten! Though I may not be of Colonial stock like you Philadelphians, my Fluids run thick and hearty, like mother's beef stew! I am filled to the brim with the Essence and Vigor of the Pinnaclean Gladiators of yore! For I am the Strong Man Slugger, the Aeneas of Athletics, the Newborn Pinnacle Tyrant of Sport, and my reign shall never end! I AM THE ZEUS OF ROUNDERS, HEAR MY THUNDER!"
His speech so enraged Yankee Stadium that fans began fighting in the stands, while others charged the field. Durchdenwald personally killed 5 Philadelphians in self-defense. The Great Rounders Riot of 1935 had begun, and would rage for the whole day and into the night. Shicagwa fans were hanged by lynch mobs, stabbed leaving the stadium, and dragged out of their autos and shot. Brown Caps fans would in turn fight like cornered animals. Businesses burned, 311 people died, and RUMP was deployed to the heart of Yankeeland to beat, shoot, club, and gas their own people. It was one of the deadliest sports riots in human history. Joe Steele was enraged by the whole affair (including the outcome of the game, which inspired him to shoot his talkiebox) but could not charge Durchdenwald without possibly inciting Shicagwa to revolt. Instead he made an example out of rioters from both sides, hanging them in front of the Capitol Building. This riot was a bloody punctuation mark on a truly insane rivalry.
The logo of the Philadelphia Yankees
RUMP clashes with sports rioters during the Great Rounders Riot of 1935
The talkiebox Joe Steele shot after hearing the end of the Yankees-Caps matchup before the Great Rounders Riot.