The South Wins The Civil War: Alternate Presidents List

Here's a list of presidents I made in an alternate TL where the South won the Civil War. I pretty much went full genocide on butterflies and only followed these rules:
1. The electoral votes from the 11 Confederate States are not counted
2. A candidate cannot have come from said states

1861-1885: OTL
1884: Blaine over Cleveland
1885-1893: James G Blaine(22)
1888: Blaine over Cleveland
1892: Cleveland over Harrison
1893-1897: Cleveland(23)
1896: McKinley over Cleveland
1897-1901: McKinley(24)
1900: OTL
1901-1909: Roosevelt(25)
1904: OTL
1908: OTL
1909-1913: Taft(26)
1912: Harmon over Taft over Roosevelt
1913-1917: Judson Harmon(27)
1916: Hughes over Harmon
1917-1925: Charles Evan Hughes(28)
1920: Hughes over Cox
1924: OTL
1925-1933: Coolidge(29)
1928: Coolidge over Al Smith
1932: OTL
1933-1945: FDR(30)
1936: OTL
1940: OTL
1944: OTL
1945-1953: Truman(31)
1948: OTL
1952: Taft over Stevenson
1953-1961: Robert A Taft(33)
1956: Taft over Stevenson
1960: OTL
1961-1963: Kennedy(34)
1963-1968: Humphrey(35)
1964: Humphrey over Goldwater
1968: Nixon over Eugene McCarthy
1969-1974: Nixon(36)
1972: OTL
1974-1981: Ford(37)
1976: Ford over Mo Udall
1980: Reagan over Ted Kennedy
1981-1989: Reagan(38)
1984: OTL
1988: Baker over Dukakis
1989-1993: Howard Baker(39)
1992: Brown over Baker
1993-2001: Jerry Brown(40)
1996: Brown over Dole
2000: Kerrey over McCain
2001-2009: Bob Kerrey(41)
2004: Kerrey over Keyes
2008: Obama over Romney
2009-2017: Obama(42)
2012: Obama over Huntsman
2016: Sanders over Trump
2017-: Sanders(43)
 
Last edited:
How do you figure no Eisenhower? True, he was born in Denison, TX, but his family moved there from KS shortly before he was born and moved back shortly thereafter. Eisenhower always thought of himself as a Kansan.
 
Interesting concept. I'd like to see somebody do a TL of this on the ASB forum.

How do you figure no Eisenhower? True, he was born in Denison, TX, but his family moved there from KS shortly before he was born and moved back shortly thereafter. Eisenhower always thought of himself as a Kansan.

Unless his family (for some reason) immigrates to the CSA and settle in Texas in this TL.
 
Here's a list of presidents I made in an alternate TL where the South won the Civil War. I pretty much went full genocide on butterflies and only followed these rules:
1. The electoral votes from the 11 Confederate States are not counted
2. A candidate cannot have come from said states

1861-1885: OTL
1884: Blaine over Cleveland
1885-1893: James G Blaine(22)
1888: Blaine over Cleveland
1892: Cleveland over Harrison
1893-1897: Cleveland(23)
1896: McKinley over Cleveland
1897-1901: McKinley(24)
1900: OTL
1901-1909: Roosevelt(25)
1904: OTL
1908: OTL
1909-1913: Taft(26)
1912: Harmon over Taft over Roosevelt
1913-1917: Judson Harmon(27)
1916: Hughes over Harmon
1917-1925: Charles Evan Hughes(28)
1920: Hughes over Cox
1924: OTL
1925-1933: Coolidge(29)
1928: Coolidge over Al Smith
1932: OTL
1933-1945: FDR(30)
1936: OTL
1940: OTL
1944: OTL
1945-1953: Truman(31)
1948: OTL
1952: Taft over Stevenson
1953-1961: Robert A Taft(33)
1956: Taft over Stevenson
1960: OTL
1961-1963: Kennedy(34)
1963-1968: Humphrey(35)
1964: Humphrey over Goldwater
1968: Nixon over Eugene McCarthy
1969-1974: Nixon(36)
1972: OTL
1974-1981: Ford(37)
1976: Ford over Mo Udall
1980: Reagan over Ted Kennedy
1981-1989: Reagan(38)
1984: OTL
1988: Baker over Dukakis
1989-1993: Howard Baker(39)
1992: Brown over Baker
1993-2001: Jerry Brown(40)
1996: Brown over Dole
2000: Kerrey over McCain
2001-2009: Bob Kerrey(41)
2004: Kerrey over Keyes
2008: Obama over Romney
2009-2017: Obama(42)
2012: Obama over Huntsman
2016: Sanders over Trump
2017-: Sanders(43)

Even besides about your rules I am surprised you don't have both Bush' on there. IU mean, 'W' may have been from Texas, but his father HW was born in Massachusetts, and the Bush family is mostly from New Jersey, Connecticut and Mass.
 
Top