The Second Mexican-American War

Hnau

Banned
The Second Mexican-American War

The origins of the Second Mexican-American War are rooted in the 1910 Mexican Revolution, when a rebel faction led by Francisco I. Madero attempted to overthrow Mexico’s dictator of more than thirty years, President Profirio Diaz. By June of 1911, the revolution had succeeded, and Madero was elected president. Madero’s victory, however, was short-lived. On February 19, 1913, Gen. Victorio Huerta arrested Madero and forced him to resign. On February 22, Madero was assassinated on orders from Huerta. A civil war erupted a few days later between Huerta’s forces (Federalists) and supporters of Madero (Constitutionalists), who were led by Governor Venustiano Carranza. Also involved was Emiliano Zapata in the south, who’s revolutionary Zapatistas opposed Huerta for disbanding radical organizations and suppressed resistance to land reforms. Meanwhile, with a several thousand men, Pancho Villa formed a military band, known as the Division of the North, and operated in the mountains of northern Mexico.

In the United States a new American Presidenet, Woodrow Wilson, took office in 1912. Wilson now faced the task of choosing a side in the ongoing Mexican Revolution. Wilson’s administration refused to recognize Huerta because of the corrupt manner in which he had seized power, and instituted an arms embargo on both sides of the civil war. When Huerta’s forces appeared to be winning the civil war in early 1914, Wilson lifted the arms embargo by offering to help Carranza. This action had volatile consequences. U.S. Navy warships had been stationed at the ports of Tampico and Vera Cruz to protect American and other foreign interests associated with the rich oil fields of the area.

This brings us to the Tampico Affair, the spark in the powder-keg that began the Second Mexican-American War. On April 9th, a group of sailors detached from the USS Dolphin went ashore at Tampico to retrieve supplies. Huerta’s troops arrested and detained seven of them. A short time later, the sailors were released, and President Huerta apologized to the United States for the incident. However, Admiral Mayo demanded a twenty-one-gun salute to the U.S. flag in addition to the apology. Huerta agreed only if the Americans would return the honor. When learning of the incident, an angry President Wilson refused Huerta’s request. Instead, he ordered the U.S. Navy’s Atlantic Fleet to Mexico’s Gulf Coast to strengthen American forces and occupy Tampico.

[In OTL, an American consul’s office in Vera Cruz reported that a German ship delivering arms (U.S.-made, incidentally) for Huerta was expected on April 21st, 1914. The consul never notices this. Thus, Wilson waits for Congress to approve the occupation of Tampico.]

April 21st, 1914 – Mexican Federalist forces in Vera Cruz receive the arms shipment from Germany safely. The U.S. consul’s office receives the news, only it’s too late. Word is sent to the United States to warn Wilson.
April 23rd – Wilson receives the news of the weapons shipment in Vera Cruz, and immediately Congress complies to vote on the occupation of Vera Cruz instead, to seize what guns they can from the local customhouse. This does cause some confusion, and some frenzied drawing up of plans for an invasion of Vera Cruz, while the plans for the occupation of Tampico have already been drawn up…

The Battle of Vera Cruz
41 ships of the U.S. Atlantic Fleet under the command of Rear Admiral Frank Fletcher begin a bombardment of Vera Cruz. By noon, 757 American Marines begin landing operations. Unfortunately, the Mexican Federalist soldiers have been forewarned, and have distributed all of the weapons in the latest shipment. General Gustavo Mass has made preparations, expecting the invasion.

By 4:00 PM, the Americans had taken 25 dead and 117 wounded, and it was obvious that things were not turning out as expected. An additional 1574 reinforcements stumbled in from the ships by 5:00 PM. Hit-and-run guerilla tactics and rooftop sniper fire nevertheless took their toll on the ground-pounders. By the end of the 24th, another 16 troopers had died and 68 wounded. Fletcher called in even more reinforcements to ground operations during the night, 1024 of them, all the rest he was willing to risk.

April 24th - The soldiers fought throughout the night, finally reaching the central town square by noon the next day (25th) with 30 more deaths and 82 wounded. This led to a total of 338 casualties by that time, and the Battle of Vera Cruz was not over! By 9:00 PM the Naval Academy, the main center of resistance, had fallen after prolonged naval bombardment. However, General Mass was still conducting guerilla warfare while he attempted to pull weapons and equipment out of the port to be used elsewhere. Urban warfare would continue for four days longer, encouraged by Commodore Azueta and his cadets.

April 26th – President Wilson sends sixteen thousand troops to Texas for “war games” and training, much as Taft had done three years before him.

April 28th – The Battle of Vera Cruz ends, as serious resistance tapers off and American control of Vera Cruz is cemented and consolidated. The U.S. forces have suffered 151 dead and some 450 wounded. The American press has called it a bloodbath despite the best attempts of the Wilson administration to say otherwise. On the other side, the Mexicans held their own, though suffered comparatively more deaths, with 222 killed and 268 wounded. The fact that the U.S. suffered a fifth more casualties causes the presses back home to call it a bloodbath, either as an honorable price to pay, or a fiasco. The Battle of Vera Cruz leaves a wake throughout U.S. politics.
 

Hnau

Banned
May 1st – Reinforcements arrive for the Mexican Federalists in Tampico, fresh from Vera Cruz. One of them is particularly angered by American hostilities against Gen. Huerta, and kills sixteen American citizens in the Hotel del Sol Massacre. This immediately causes widespread anti-Mexican and anti-American hostilities throughout the port city.

May 3rd – President Woodrow Wilson issues an order to divide the Atlantic Fleet, sending 23 ships under Rear Admiral Henry Mayo to Tampico to protect American citizens and interests. He asks Congress permission to occupy Tampico in much the same manner as Vera Cruz. Because the plans are already on the table, he suggests to begin the invasion as soon as possible. Wilson also begins to formulate a declaration of war against Mexico.

May 4th – Venustiano Carranzo is in his office when three gunmen burst in and riddle his body with bullets. The Federalists behind the assassination are executed; however, the Constitutionalists are without a leader. General Alvaro Obregon Salido begins to consolidate power, but it will take some time and weaken the army’s position.

The Battle of Tampico
Admiral Mayo begins a naval bombardment at eight in the morning, away from the American sectors of the port. Mexican Federalist forces scramble to organize a response. There are violent clashes between Mexican and American citizenry throughout the town. By 9:30 American troopers make landfall and begin their campaign to capture the city. Customs, post and telegraph offices are captured, while a vicious urban battle commences. The battle will last for three days.

May 5th – During celebrations of Cinco de Mayo in Vera Cruz, resistance members lead a revolt against the American occupation, killing four Americans and wounding many more. A fire breaks out in the American quarter of the port, and the perceived revenge killings causes retribution against the Mexican populace, leading to another twenty to thirty dead. In the aftermath, U.S. soldiers storm houses to locate the perpetrators, while the local Mexican populace seethes with nationalistic fury.

May 6th – General Frederick Funston, still in Vera Cruz, writes back to Washington to suggest the expansion of the United States Army to 50,000 soldiers, instead of the current 27,000.

May 7th – The Battle of Tampico formally ends as American soldiers set up shop. The battle is considered quite the victory, with only 42 U.S. Marines killed, 133 wounded. Total Mexican casualties include 172 dead, 232 wounded. The press seizes the victory very quickly, eager to make up for the tragedy of Vera Cruz. Wilson makes an illustrious declaration that the Mexicans will have democracy and peace, through valiant American efforts. In the aftermath of Tampico, General Victoriano Huerta has been cut off from all weapons shipments with the capture of his two most important ports. The fact that Vera Cruz was such a success proved that the Mexican Federalist army can win, even against Americans, Constitutionalists, Villistas, and Zapatistas, all at the same time. If only he can remove the American blockade and gain the assistance of the Germans. Thus, it comes time to ratify a declaration of war against the United States of America. Huerta sends feelers for peace to defend against the American intruders.

May 11th – President Wilson asks Congress to declare war on Mexico.

May 17th – Congress narrowly complies with Wilson’s request, formally ratifying a declaration of war against Mexico, beginning the Second Mexican-American War. This is the result of a bloc of Wilsonian Democrats siding with the President, Republicans loyal to the Roosevelt Corollary and business interests, and the southwestern states who have a vested interest in keeping Mexico peaceful and their borders secure.

---

General progression of events follows:
- The US Invasion of Vera Cruz is a bloodbath, because they arrive two days late, giving Huerta's army plenty of time to distribute German arms that in OTL were seized.
- The US has a chip on their shoulder, as does Huerta over Vera Cruz. More anti-Americanism and anti-Mexicanism throughout respective countries. A massacre in Tampico provokes Wilson to try and correct his mistake by ordering an invasion.
- U.S. success at capturing Tampico (parallel of OTL Vera Cruz) is much more patriotic, galvanizes the country after a horrible defeat. Mexicans have now been attacked twice and anti-Americanism is rampant. Huerta has won once before against the Americans, and he can again, so he declares war, hoping to bring Germany into the fight and end the civil war.
- U.S. still wants to avenge Vera Cruz and other massacres, feels threatened by a formal declaration of war, fears for American citizens lives in Mexico, and so answers the drums of war with a declaration of their own.

Pancho Villa plots in the north while Pershing's men in Texas are ready to storm the border. General Funston's in Vera Cruz and is planning a March on Mexico City. Carranza is dead, Huerta is in a strong position, and the Zapatistas are a wild card. We all know who will win, but by how much?

To be continued...

SMAW1914.PNG
 
It is a good start and depending on how you end up Mexico could become a wealthy stable state or turn into a cesspool that needs constant intervention.
 

Hnau

Banned
One item of interest is that Germany is going to demand the ability to trade weapons with Mexico, as a neutral power under the Hague Convention of 1907, they should be allowed to facilitate guns to Huerta's army. When this leads to Mexican successes... the USN could decide to do away with rules and begin a naval engagement against the German merchant marine.

Now how will the U.S. look when World War One starts, and they want to ship materials freely as a neutral power? Germany will call them on it, certainly. :cool:
 
Very interesting! The US with a bloody, but victorious nose could have a very different outlook on becoming an up-and-coming great power. And of course, there are all sorts of potential WWI butterflies. I wonder what TR thinks of all this...

I do have one question, how do all the various Mexican factions receive word of US intentions at Vera Cruz and Tampico? Because of actions of the US press? Because they can see the ships? I ask because the Mexican defense seems awfully coordinated for a country in the midst of a civil war.
 
Germany

Germany can demand all that it want to, but it's a little hard to trade with another nation when the ports are occupied.
 
Ports

One item of interest is that Germany is going to demand the ability to trade weapons with Mexico, as a neutral power under the Hague Convention of 1907, they should be allowed to facilitate guns to Huerta's army. When this leads to Mexican successes... the USN could decide to do away with rules and begin a naval engagement against the German merchant marine.

Of course, since Mexico only has two ports

I know that Mexico has more that 2 ports on the Gulf side, but that was the implication in the post. Besides, if the US does declare war on Mexico what's to stop a blockade from occurring? I would be very surprised if that was not a part of the USN plans. If a blockade does occur I'm pretty sure that guns would be forbidden and not be permitted to be delivered to Mexico under international law.
 
I know that Mexico has more that 2 ports on the Gulf side, but that was the implication in the post. Besides, if the US does declare war on Mexico what's to stop a blockade from occurring? I would be very surprised if that was not a part of the USN plans. If a blockade does occur I'm pretty sure that guns would be forbidden and not be permitted to be delivered to Mexico under international law.

As far as I know, neutral counties are allowed to trade weapons to any nation they choose under international law. Of course the Americans could try to stop them. If the Americans prevent Germany sending weapons to Mexico how could they justify sending weapons to France? And what would they do? Sink german ships :rolleyes:.
 

Hnau

Banned
As far as I know, neutral counties are allowed to trade weapons to any nation they choose under international law. Of course the Americans could try to stop them. If the Americans prevent Germany sending weapons to Mexico how could they justify sending weapons to France? And what would they do? Sink german ships :rolleyes:.

Exactly! There-in lies the rub. While I do want to explore the implications of another conflict with Mexico, I don't believe actions there will be as world-changing as the effects on World War I. It could very well lead to an earlier entry of the US, either under Wilson or another president. Wilson's career will likely be remembered ITTL for the events of this Second Mexican-American War.
 
all i can say is a good start im curious as to how this would affect mexican-american relations in the 21st century would there still be a NAFTA or only a canadian-american free trade agreement
 

Hnau

Banned
A map of the fronts at the beginning of the Second Mexican-American War. The dark teal is U.S.-occupied territory. The red is held by General Victoriano Huerta and his Federalist faction. The green is held by Carranza's (now Obregon's) Constitutionalists, as well as Pancho Villa's Villistas. Violet is held by Zapata's Zapatistas. The gray areas are either divided on the issue of political rule or have devolved into a form local rule while the civil war plays itself out.

Mexico Blank Map.PNG
 

Hnau

Banned
May 6th – General Frederick Funston, still in Vera Cruz, writes back to Washington to suggest the expansion of the United States Army by “twice as much or more, including or excluding the National Guard.” The United States Army by this time has 98,000 soldiers, 45,000 of which were overseas. The National Guard consisted of 27,000.

May 7th – The Battle of Tampico formally ends as American soldiers set up shop. The battle is considered quite the victory, with only 42 U.S. Marines killed, 133 wounded. Total Mexican casualties include 172 dead, 232 wounded. The press seizes the victory very quickly, eager to make up for the tragedy of Vera Cruz. Wilson makes an illustrious declaration that the Mexicans will have democracy and peace, through valiant American efforts.

In the aftermath of Tampico, General Victoriano Huerta has been cut off from a huge amount of revenue and trade with the capture of his two most important ports. The fact that Vera Cruz was such a success proved that the Mexican Federalist army can win, even against Americans, Constitutionalists, Villistas, and Zapatistas, all at the same time. If only he can remove the American blockade and gain the assistance of the Germans. Thus, it comes time to ratify a declaration of war against the United States of America. Huerta feels that the other Mexican factions will stand together to remove the American menace from their country, and so sends envoys to each for an alliance against them.

May 11th – President Wilson, with the report of Huerta’s declaration of war, asks Congress to declare war on Mexico.

May 17th – Congress narrowly complies with Wilson’s request, formally ratifying a declaration of war against Mexico, beginning the Second Mexican-American War. This is the result of a bloc of Wilsonian Democrats siding with the President, Republicans loyal to the Roosevelt Corollary and business interests, and the southwestern states who have a vested interest in keeping Mexico peaceful and their borders secure.

There are few immediate actions. Loans, exports and other investments from the United States to Constitutionalist forces in northern Mexico doubled nearly overnight, though this is not very significant as such economic activity with Mexico was trivial during the Mexican Revolution. The military begins concentrating on military plans and getting their war machine fired up.

May 19th – Wilson orders Major General John “Black Jack” Pershing, with authority over all U.S. border troops, to organize the Northern Maneuver Division with twenty-five thousand soldiers readied in Texas to begin land operations. Another thirty thousand are to be sent to Vera Cruz as both an occupying force and to be organized as the American Expeditionary Force under General Frederick Funston.

May 24th – Secretary of State Bryan makes the New York Declaration, that neutral merchants in the Gulf of Mexico will be subjected to searches by the United States Navy.

May 27th – 21,000 soldiers of the American Expeditionary Force under General Funston, detaches from the Vera Cruz occupied territory following the railroad to Mexico City. Unfortunately, General Huerta has sabotaged the rail lines and cars for miles and miles. Funston has made up for this by organizing ‘truck-trains’ consisting of a huge supply line of trucks that will carry soldiers, fuel, ammunition and supplies to Cordoba, which they will take before heading across more rough terrain on their way to Puebla, then Mexico City. There are logistics issues with the fuel, ammunition and other various supplies, but the trucks themselves are well-manufactured and travel efficiently across the Mexican coastal terrain. Funston follows practically the same route used by Winfield Scott nearly seventy years before.

This becomes the famed Cordoba March of Funston’s Force. The Federalists fight a guerilla war, with lone machine gunners in favorable terrain picking off the forward American Doughboys one by one. Being a scout is practically suicide. American hard-handedness becomes infamous during the Cordoba March, with every village succumbing to a battle from paranoid Americans. There are enough Federalist forces in each village along the way that the Doughboys are justified in taking each one cautiously, but it does not leave a favorable attitude amongst the populace.

Also infamous among Funston’s Force are the ‘Remounting Stations’ that are set up at each camp. These military-funded brothels, built for morale purposes, actually sap the army’s energy and enthusiasm for the activities of each day. Alcohol is brought in large amounts from Vera Cruz, and many soldiers engage in wild parties during the night. General Funston turns a blind eye to the whole ordeal, and allows the men to march at a slower pace if needs be.

May 30th – The Obregonistas, Villistas, and Zapatistas have all heard the call for an alliance against the American incursion. Obregon has taken the mantle of the head of the Constitutionalist Army, and it is recognized that he should become the interim president once Huerta is deposed. He has not built a relationship with the United States, so he is wary, but not willing to fight back. Pancho Villa is firmly pro-American, using American-made equipment and American mercenaries, even. However, what he does not like is that the Americans are marching on Mexico City, and may pre-empt his possibilities for leadership. Zapata is hostile, arguing that no foreign invader can set up a president for the country that would be beneficial to the poor. However, Zapatista opposition to Huerta remains.

June 1st – The National Security League is founded by attorney Solomon Menken and General Leonard Wood. This quasi-fascist militaristic organization begins to argue for national conscription to increase the size of the U.S. Army and for the annexation of part or all of Mexico after the war.

June 2nd – The Siege of Cordoba begins. Huerta and his generals have massed a huge majority of their army to defend Cordoba and access across the mountains in order to gain a victory against the Americans that might inspire the other Mexican factions to join his side. In a surprise attack, thousands of the forward divisions are captured as they prepare to enter Cordoba. The siege will last nine days.

June 3rd – The bloodiest day of the Siege of Cordoba. Huerta had used his best men and artillery to fend off the American incursion, and now the worst sectors of his army are being thrown at the invaders. Nevertheless, Funston faces a large angry, enthusiastic, if somewhat malnourished legion. The US suffers over two thousand casualties in a single day, as Funston underestimated Huerta’s forces and plunged too far into the city, and then was forced to order a retreat after some very bloody urban warfare. Already, Funston is pushing to surround the Federalist army in order to push into the city.

June 3rd - The Ponga Incident. The Ponga is an armed German merchant ship that is searched by American ships off the shore of Cuba. When attempting to approach the ship for inspection, the Americans were fired upon. The Americans returned fire and were able to force the German ship to surrender. The sailors are imprisoned, while the ship is searched, revealing a large load of ammunition due for Mexico. A few days later, the ship is sent back to Germany with its sailors, minus the contraband and all of its armaments. A few sailors were wounded and demand recompense for their cruel treatment both during the scuffle and in the Cuban prison they were sent to.

June 8th – The First Ponga Note. Kaiser Wilhelm writes to President Wilson demanding the indisputable right of Germans to sail the high seas, reparations for the confiscation of German goods, reparations for the detention of German sailors, and reiterating “Strict Accountability” and demanding the abandonment of the ‘search and seizure’ routine against neutral ships.

June 11th – The Siege of Cordoba is finished, as Funston forces Huerta’s Federalists to retreat across the mountains. He captures nine thousand Federalist soldiers and begins to facilitate material across the mountains. It is both a victory and a loss: the battle had taken more three thousand casualties and was regarded as a victory on both sides, for different reasons.

June 15th – President Woodrow Wilson makes an executive order that expands the standing United States Army from 98,000 to 126,000.

June 17th – General Frederick Funston begins an overland push across the plateau towards Puebla.

June 18th – President Wilson claims that the Ponga was actually the hostile force during the incident and that it had shot upon American ships for approaching. He justified the imprisonment of Germans and confiscation of weaponry as “just self-defense”. Wilson denies Germany’s claim to unrestricted economic warfare against the United States by paying for Mexicans to kill American soldiers.

June 21st – General Victoriano Huerta bows to the pressure of his surrounding enemies, and resigns from the presidency. He flees along the interior of southern Mexico towards Belize. Francisco Carvajal is the next in line to Huerta, and as his first act he makes an executive order to allow the Americans into the capital to sign a peace treaty.

June 23rd – American soldiers enter Puebla peacefully. The populace does not want a battle, but they openly oppose the presence of the Expeditionary Force.

June 24th – The Puebla Massacre. Tired soldiers have been drinking throughout the last night after arriving in Puebla without a battle. A citizen uses an American flag to sweep the dirty streets in the evening. Inebriated soldiers beat the man in public view, which causes someone to take a shot at them. This causes a small urban battle that kills fifteen American soldiers and nearly one hundred Puebla citizens.

June 25th – General Funston bans alcohol from the troop encampments. Meanwhile, American soldiers are posted at every corner of Puebla, and the settlement is searched for former soldiers. Food shipments directed for the soldiers are distributed to the populace, as many are starving after the Federalist retreat from Cordoba. While Funston is trying to remedy the problems that began the Puebla Massacre, these measures will not hold for long.

June 26th – The American Expeditionary Force moves on to Mexico City. Another fifteen thousand reinforcements are sent in from the coast.

June 27th – The Second Ponga Note denies America’s claim that special circumstances justified the attack, and demanded specific pledges of future safety of German citizens and ships. It warns that future poor treatment of Germans, and either the searching or seizure of their merchant marine, will be regarded as “deliberately unfriendly” toward the German Empire, requiring appropriate response.

June 28th – Pancho Villa marches on Zacatecas, and takes the wealthy city for himself to help his funding. The Federalist Army there surrenders beforehand, and it makes a fine acquisition for Villa.

June 30th – In response to the Ponga Incident, President Wilson orders Admiral Mayo to begin a naval blockade of the Atlantic shore of Mexico consisting of coastline stretching from Tampico to the tip of the Yucatan. The Americans declare the Gulf of Mexico a military area, and that no one can enter the area without their protection. There is somewhat negative approval throughout Europe, except for Britain. Germany would like to cut diplomatic relations completely; however, the recent assassination in Sarajevo has brought such thoughts to a standstill.

July 31st – General Frederick Funston enters Mexico City at the head of tens of thousands of American soldiers, rather peacefully. Interim President Carvajal welcomes them into the city, and a nervous peace holds as Funston orders military authority over the city.
 

Hnau

Banned
Ridiculous. For some reason the forum won't let me edit the last update from its heinous format!
 

Hnau

Banned
I'm sorry about my triple post, guys. :( For some reason the forum won't let me edit or delete my posts, and I'm leaving for a few days, so I won't have a chance to make amends. If a moderator could fix this, that would be great. I'm sorry to leave the timeline in such a state but I don't know what else to do!

Hope you enjoy what I did write, and that's its plausible. Maybe put it into Word to read it better. :)
 
cool time line, it seems that WW1 will take off like OTL, it seems that America will join on allied side like OTL. If America joins quick enough could we see some European forces in the war?
 
Top