The R-QBAM main thread

At this point I genuinely think you could compile all of this and look at submitting it to an academic journal.

Just add some conclusions at the end about the validity/usefulness of certain sources and use the 'I got an erroneous article deleted from Wikipedia' bit as a hook.
 
At this point I genuinely think you could compile all of this and look at submitting it to an academic journal.

Just add some conclusions at the end about the validity/usefulness of certain sources and use the 'I got an erroneous article deleted from Wikipedia' bit as a hook.
I just wish all of this research didn't get lost on a few pixels, this could very easily be a big and detailed map or maybe even a GIS source.
 
I just wish all of this research didn't get lost on a few pixels, this could very easily be a big and detailed map or maybe even a GIS source.
Seriously. He's uncovered stuff that I bet even the Indian government doesn't know about/ remember!
 
Last edited:
1684116884435.png

So hey, an small update on the rivers progress, as you can see a lot of WIP yet but Northern India and Nepal already have the primary rivers built, as I mentioned last time the Ghaggar-Hakra River still confuses me (idk if what I use as source is correct?) and both the coast of the Western Ghats and the Bhramputra River look like nightmares... But with patience I'll get there on them.

Also @Tanystropheus42 , about the GADM data I posted earlier, while I was drawning the Nepal rivers I notice that it didn't update their sources for the new Nepalese provinces subdivisions of 2015 and it has the previous subdivisions there, I hope that not the case in other countries but just warning to not make you confused.
 
I will, but Darfur's borders correspond with modern borders, and until those are added, I'm not touching it. This is a work in process anyways, so I there's plenty more to be added, even now. Especially theRTSchultz's patches for German colonial reservations
I think you might like this, its from 1928 but shows the native autorities of Tanganyika (former German East Africa), Leauge of Nations map collection and archives are a treasure throve, i wonder who said that Leauge of Nations were useless :)


 
1684618839180.png

Hey! Another small update on the river progress, not much to say beyond that of course still heavy WIP yet...

But an bad news about that GADM data I found before ( pinging @Tanystropheus42 to warn about it), remember last time I said the Nepal divisions didn't have updated to the current provinces borders? Oh guest what I have found: while I was doing the Godovari river I notice that the GADM data it was indicating that the border of Telangana extended further east over a small piece of Andhra Pradesh (something that happens on several maps on the internet), at the time I found this strange and went to research if there had been any exchange of territories recently or if the dataset was dated... And to my sadness and paranoia, it is dated;
Summing up, when the Telangana state was created in early 2014 the district of Khammam had the northeast of its territory ceded back to Andhra Pradesh in a vote if I'm not mistaken around July, so it was a very short time that the border of these two states became like that way; the territory was mostly transferred to the East Godavari district... However, there was a district reform in Andhra Pradesh in January 2022 that basically redesigned the 2nd level administrative divisions there (which even Google Maps is not updated to that change yet).
In conclusion: although the last GADM update was in July 2022, at least they haven't been updating India since 2014 (especially the districts) , which yiekes, a big red flag on the entire dataset now... Well, it still has its uses and you can use a reference for make modern borders, but it can cause confusion and not as reliable as I hoped it was...

Anyways, I will continue doing the river layer, so see ya guys!
 
Top