Great analysis dear @Shevek23 ! Thank you for your fine words and suggestions. You really help me and this ATL a lot.
Its pretty much a combine French and English approach. We are in the same page more or less but for me this fusion will take some time. Honestly i think that this Greek-Gaul fusion is all ready going too fast rather slow. It takes time for Greek chauvinism to convert to a Greek-Gaul fusion. Its 52 years from the start of this ATL and we allready see Gaul temples of Epona builded and Gauls start to be granted citizenship. Tolosa and Massalia have big numbers of Gaul populations and the epicurean sect and Dynatoi company have all ready Gaul members. Sadly my limited English don't allow me to get really deeper on this subjects and thats why i choose this Fact/text -book/wiki approach.
Not entirely. Its also a blend of the social reforms of Ptolemaic Egypt ( Under a "democratic" instead of Tyrant approach) and the way that Romans gave citizenship to Italians during the social wars era. Another major factor that affects all that and helps the Greek- Gaul fusion is the Epicurean sect that supports the equality of people. Newer the less a civil war was really close in 248 BC if the political reforms under Nestor failed to pass( basically happened the opposite from what really happened in Rome OTL prior the social wars)If the League is mainly Hellenizing in the way the Roman conquest of Gaul was Latinizing, then we have to have some serious conflict going on now
They'd have to combine something of both the French and English approaches I'd think. Ruthless attempts to divide and rule might open up space in the form of devastating conquest and enserfment of loser groups, but only with the alliance of rival Native groups who could be expected to gradually, largely on their own terms, assimilate useful or interesting aspects of European civilization, and acquire what the Europeans regarded as cultivation, but also set the general terms of contact to a much greater degree than seen OTL in aggressive settler colonies. The settlers would not be nearly as able to shove the natives aside, and the best surviving colonies would be those who learned to make long-term, lasting alliances with Native peoples who would be drawn into their orbit, but only by letting themselves in turn be drawn into Native orbits.
This is the sort of fusion I've been hoping to find evidence of, and I fear largely looking in vain. I'm still hung up on the whole Bordeaux thing you see, which is much more like what English might do than French in North America. On the lack of Celtic names, on the lack of attribution to useful innovations to Celtic influence, on the lack of mention of strongly Gaulish though loyal districts in the Massilote heartland, etc etc.
So it is a bit heartening to be told, "don't worry, the Gauls are fine." But the only evidence one sees is that the devastating social wars I'd fear would result if the Massaliotes are in fact a one-sided Hellenization project--which the overwhelming number of specific citations of people and events hitherto seems to support--have not in fact taken place yet.
A hybridized Helleno-Gaulic Massaliote region would have some limitations that have not been mentioned yet (such as being somewhat alien and off-putting to "purer" Hellenes, which should have come into play by now) but also some big advantages--the author seems to be attributing these advantages to the League without as it were paying dues for them by acknowledging the likely side effects nor demonstrating the actual presence of Gauls in Massaliote high society--not even as thoroughly Hellenized model products of a French-style (19th century French I mean here) mission civilitrice transformation, let alone showing us Gauls who proudly retain Gaulish cultural traits suitably modified but definitely not Hellenic, nor Greeks who are adopting distinctly Gaulish ways.
Its pretty much a combine French and English approach. We are in the same page more or less but for me this fusion will take some time. Honestly i think that this Greek-Gaul fusion is all ready going too fast rather slow. It takes time for Greek chauvinism to convert to a Greek-Gaul fusion. Its 52 years from the start of this ATL and we allready see Gaul temples of Epona builded and Gauls start to be granted citizenship. Tolosa and Massalia have big numbers of Gaul populations and the epicurean sect and Dynatoi company have all ready Gaul members. Sadly my limited English don't allow me to get really deeper on this subjects and thats why i choose this Fact/text -book/wiki approach.
Last edited: