Introduction
Introduction: Or where I, Rognvald, try to explain the thesis
It has been many years since I have participated actively on alternatehistory.com, and I recognize that the culture of the board may have changed since those long off days of 2015. The rigors of scholarship and accuracy and the hatred of the crime of implausibility may well have increased, and indeed I would hope have increased, since those days. And yet, at this time I prepare to present to you a work of alternate history that may belong more to the fringes of the History channel, rather than this illustrious board.
For what I intend to write about, and discuss in the following pages, is the effect of an Irish discovery of the New World in the 6th-century.
Now, before the pitchforks are distributed and the torches lit, let me explain myself.
In the 6th-century AD, a monk named Brendan (later a Saint) and his band of Irish clerics went on a voyage. They encountered many hardships, both theological and physical. They discovered the island on which Judas Iscariot, on Sundays and feast days, enjoyed temporary respite from the pit of Hell. They discovered a fish as large as an island (a commonly recurring theme in antiquity and early medieval nautical adventures), and they also discovered a new land- the “Island of the Blessed”, where the Saints of God do dwell.
All well and good- but what does the (mostly second hand) account of the voyage of a monk in the Dark Ages have to do with the New World?
Over the years, various individuals have maintained that Saint Brendan and his fellows, in discovering the Island of the Blessed, discovered the Americas. These were and remain fringe theories- there is no proof that the Irish monk even came close to the Atlantic seaboard of North America. In fact, with how much mythology and theology is mixed in with the account, some could argue that the voyage never took place at all or was, more likely, much smaller in scope.
However, and stay with me here-
What if St. Brendan did, in fact, discover the Americas?
The main concern some would have is whether the boat Brendan used could have made the journey from the Emerald Isle to, say, Newfoundland. However, a more modern explorer, Tom Severin, undertook the trip in a similar boat to what Brendan would have used (a currach), and was able to accomplish the voyage. So it is theoretically possible for Brendan to have accomplished this trip.
But this, then, begs the question (at least from myself)-
What impact would St. Brendan’s discovery had had on the history of the world?
I veered between two extremes in my brainstorming of this project. The first (or, as I termed it, the “Vinland” Theory) held that this discovery would have had little impact on world affairs. Maybe Brendan or another monk would revisit the New World, maybe erect a monument of some kind, but due to hostile natives and a general lack of support from the outside, the discovery would have no impact on future developments in the New World or the Old.
The second (or, as I termed it, the “Turtledove” Theory) held that this discovery would have unalterably changed the future of both the Old World and the New. While perhaps more suited to the ASB forum, due to a heavy use of butterfly-pesticide, I envisioned medieval kingdoms propping along the East Coast of the OTL United States and Canada. Anglo-Saxons fleeing Norman oppression! Jews! Lost Byzantine traders! But, unfortunately, this would not be very likely either.
So, my conclusion, the one that I’m basing this project on, is somewhere in the middle. Perhaps St. Brendan’s discovery would not have any major impact initially. But later on, over the years?
It would change the course of human history forever.
So, I hope that you all enjoy my explorations of this idea, as the butterflies, unimpeded, begin to flap their wings, and as a monk, his beard flecked with sea-spray, takes his first steps into a brave new world...
It has been many years since I have participated actively on alternatehistory.com, and I recognize that the culture of the board may have changed since those long off days of 2015. The rigors of scholarship and accuracy and the hatred of the crime of implausibility may well have increased, and indeed I would hope have increased, since those days. And yet, at this time I prepare to present to you a work of alternate history that may belong more to the fringes of the History channel, rather than this illustrious board.
For what I intend to write about, and discuss in the following pages, is the effect of an Irish discovery of the New World in the 6th-century.
Now, before the pitchforks are distributed and the torches lit, let me explain myself.
In the 6th-century AD, a monk named Brendan (later a Saint) and his band of Irish clerics went on a voyage. They encountered many hardships, both theological and physical. They discovered the island on which Judas Iscariot, on Sundays and feast days, enjoyed temporary respite from the pit of Hell. They discovered a fish as large as an island (a commonly recurring theme in antiquity and early medieval nautical adventures), and they also discovered a new land- the “Island of the Blessed”, where the Saints of God do dwell.
All well and good- but what does the (mostly second hand) account of the voyage of a monk in the Dark Ages have to do with the New World?
Over the years, various individuals have maintained that Saint Brendan and his fellows, in discovering the Island of the Blessed, discovered the Americas. These were and remain fringe theories- there is no proof that the Irish monk even came close to the Atlantic seaboard of North America. In fact, with how much mythology and theology is mixed in with the account, some could argue that the voyage never took place at all or was, more likely, much smaller in scope.
However, and stay with me here-
What if St. Brendan did, in fact, discover the Americas?
The main concern some would have is whether the boat Brendan used could have made the journey from the Emerald Isle to, say, Newfoundland. However, a more modern explorer, Tom Severin, undertook the trip in a similar boat to what Brendan would have used (a currach), and was able to accomplish the voyage. So it is theoretically possible for Brendan to have accomplished this trip.
But this, then, begs the question (at least from myself)-
What impact would St. Brendan’s discovery had had on the history of the world?
I veered between two extremes in my brainstorming of this project. The first (or, as I termed it, the “Vinland” Theory) held that this discovery would have had little impact on world affairs. Maybe Brendan or another monk would revisit the New World, maybe erect a monument of some kind, but due to hostile natives and a general lack of support from the outside, the discovery would have no impact on future developments in the New World or the Old.
The second (or, as I termed it, the “Turtledove” Theory) held that this discovery would have unalterably changed the future of both the Old World and the New. While perhaps more suited to the ASB forum, due to a heavy use of butterfly-pesticide, I envisioned medieval kingdoms propping along the East Coast of the OTL United States and Canada. Anglo-Saxons fleeing Norman oppression! Jews! Lost Byzantine traders! But, unfortunately, this would not be very likely either.
So, my conclusion, the one that I’m basing this project on, is somewhere in the middle. Perhaps St. Brendan’s discovery would not have any major impact initially. But later on, over the years?
It would change the course of human history forever.
So, I hope that you all enjoy my explorations of this idea, as the butterflies, unimpeded, begin to flap their wings, and as a monk, his beard flecked with sea-spray, takes his first steps into a brave new world...