The Hero of Saratoga: The Presidency of Benedict Arnold

This timeline was a spurr of the moment, when research for another timeline gave me the idea for this one.


The Hero of Saratoga:
The Presidency of Benedict Arnold
Lossy-page1-488px-Benedict_Arnold_Copy_of_engraving_by_H_B_Hall_after_John_Trumbull%2C_published_1879_%2C_1931_-_1932_-_NARA_-_532921_tif.jpg

Not gold but only men can make
A people great and strong;
Men who for truth and honor's sake
Stand fast and suffer long.
Brave men who work while others sleep,
Who dare while others fly...
They build a nation's pillars deep
And lift them to the sky.


A Nation's Strength
by Ralph Waldo Emerson
 
Last edited:
He was one of six children born to Benedict and Hannah Arnold in Norwich, Connecticut in January of 1741. He was named after his great-grandfather who had been an early governor of the Colony of Rhode Island, and after his older brother, Benedict IV, who died in infancy. Only Benedict and his sister Hannah would survive to adulthood, his other siblings succumbing to yellow fever. His father was successful businessman, however the death of most of his children lead him to take up drinking. His alcoholism would lead to the ruin of business. He would accept an apprenticeship with his mothers cousins as an apothecary. He ran away from home several times during the French and Indian wars. He dreamed of glory in the military, but was always ashamed of his family, and constantly felt the drive to rise above the circumstances his father drove he and his family into. In 1775 he would get his chance to make a name for himself by leading an attack on Fort Ticonderoga with Ethan Allen, and invading Quebec. However he received no credit for the former, and the latter was a failure.

In 1777 he would have his chance. In Spring of 1777, the British began a new campaign in the north, designed and led by General John Burgoyne. He marches south from Quebec with an army of 8000 men, while a diversionary campaign is being led through the Mohawk River Valley by Colonel Barry St. Leger, and Iroquois leader Joseph Brant. The goal of this campaign was to capture Albany and take control of the Hudson river, cutting New England off from the rest of the colonies. The American camp was becoming uneasy after Arnold’s return from Fort Stanwix. It was not so evident yet, but tension between Benedict Arnold and Horatio Gates would eventually boil over. On September 18, Burgoyne’s vanguard was just north of Saratoga, and about 4 miles away from the American lines.

Skirmishes occurred between the British vanguard and the American scouting parties. On the 19th, Arnold begs Gates for the chance to attack the British, and after enough pestering, Gates allows him to take the left wing and nothing else. Arnold takes his troops and goes to where the skirmishes are occurring. As the battle continues, Arnold detects a gap in the British line and orders several charges in order to break through. According to one officer Arnold seems to have been “inspired by the furry of a demon”. At a critical moment, Arnold believes he can take the field and defeat the red coats if he only had more troops. He rides back to camp and implores gates for reinforcements. Gates gives in and allows him to take 1 regiment. As Arnold heads back toward the battlefield, Gates orders him back and strips him of field command and ordered him to stay at camp. The Troops marching out under Gates are not inspired and do not want to follow him. The Americans loose momentum, and the fighting ends. The British eventually take the field when they send as many of their reserves as they can afford to send to attack the Right Wing of the army. The Americans retreated, giving the British a Technical victory. Burgoyne had 600 men killed or wounded, and the Americans had only 300 killed or wounded.

The tensions that had been boiling between Horatio Gates and Benedict Arnold finally spill over after the battle. Gates refuses to acknowledge Arnolds contributions in the battle, and Arnold confronts him about it. After a strong shouting match and a threat by Gates to have Arnold removed and replaced, Arnold requests a pass to go join Washington’s army in Pennsylvania. Gates is only too willing to get rid of him. Word spreads among the troops of Arnold’s departure. The officers sign a petition to get Arnold to stay. Seeing this loyalty among his men, Arnold reconsiders and decides to stay with the Army. This, however does not bode well with Gates. Arnold was not allowed to leave camp, and when battle would come this meant that he couldn’t lead his men.

After the battle on September 19th, Burgoyne pushes his men forward closer to the American lines in order to consolidate their position. He receives a message Henry Clinton dated September 12th, saying that he was taking a fort just south of West Point, and would be there in 10 days. This meant that Clinton would not be close enough to Saratoga by the end of September in order to assist. With their supplies running low, Burgoyne decided to hold on and not push forward. With their supplies dwindling, and Burgoyne refusing to consider retreat, on October 4th, they agreed to launch an attack on the American Left Wing on the 7th. They engaged the Americans once again outside of Saratoga, this time at a place known as Bemis Heights.

After Gates had stripped Arnold of field command he would take command of the American left himself and give control of the right to Benjamin Lincoln. In the chaos of battle, a stray bullet hit General Horatio gates in the heart, knocking him from his horse, mortally wounding him. News of Gate’s death quickly reached the camp. When Arnold heard word of this he mounted his horse and dashed quickly to the battlefield. When he arrived the left wing of the army was collapsing, but when the men saw their commander arrive their spirits were rejuvenated and they turned back to face the British. Arnold would lead his men from the front, bullets whizzing past him. At one moment he was almost shot out from under his horse, but he managed to stay mounted the whole time. By the end of the day the field was in American hands. Days later Burgoyne’s army surrendered to Arnold and the Northern Army.

Arnold became more famous throughout the colonies. There were those who wanted to replace George Washington with Benedict Arnold, but Arnold refused. In December of 1777 Arnold would be given official command of the northern army, with Benjamin Lincoln as his right hand. Throughout the war Arnold would repel several invasion attempts by the British out of Canada, and attempt at least one invasion himself, but would be stopped by the winter cold. He led an attack on New York city in the Spring of 1781. He would lose the battle, but like the many battles of the American Revolution, the British losses far outnumbered the American losses. Arnold regretted not being present at the Battle of York Town in Virginia, but he would still be one of the most famous Generals throughout the entire revolution.
 
 
800px-Surrender_of_General_Burgoyne.jpg

 
The ideas that you come up with for a TL. Wish i was that creative.

I want to do nothing now but laugh. This is brilliant.


----
Edit: So Washington will most likely remain the first president, so perhaps Arnold as the second, or third?
 
The ideas that you come up with for a TL. Wish i was that creative.

I want to do nothing now but laugh. This is brilliant.


----
Edit: So Washington will most likely remain the first president, so perhaps Arnold as the second, or third?

I plan for him to be second, but I came up with this timeline on a spurr of a moment, so who knows.
 
After the war many members of the revolution returned to their lives. George Washington returned his command of the continental army to the congress, wishing to live out the rest of his days in peace at Mt. Vernon. John Adams would return from Europe to spend a year at home before being called back into service as the United States Minister to Great Britain. Benjamin Franklin would return to Philadelphia after his long stint as Minister to France. Benedict Arnold would return to Connecticut to resume his business as a merchant, attempting to regain much of the wealth he lost during his service in the revolution.

Not all revolutionary leaders had happy endings after the war was over. In particular Thomas Jefferson’s story was the most tragic. In 1782 Thomas’ wife Martha would die. On her death bed she pleaded her husband to not remarry. In loving devotion to his wife, he obeyed. His love for his wife was so strong that her death caused him to go into a deep depression. He spent weeks at his home Monticello not saying a word. However, on Christmas Eve of 1782, he succumb to what everyone around him in those dark days feared. He was found in his study by his daughter Martha, hanging from a noose. The children would be cared for by their neighbors until they were sent to live with relatives of their mother.

In September of 1783 the Treaty of Paris was signed, ending the war between Great Britain and her former colonies, the nations of Europe recognizing the American Confederation. Not all was well in the new nation. British troops still occupied forts in the northwest territory. Tensions between Patriots and loyalists had become so high that part of the Treaty of Paris addressed this, allowing any American wanting to leave the 13 former colonies to return to Britain or go north into Canada were to be allowed to do so. Property stolen from loyalists wasn’t returned. The states were engaged in trade wars, placing tariffs on goods from other states. It was chaos.

In 1787 it was realized that the United States needed a stronger central government, and the Articles of Confederation were insufficient to do this. In May of 1787 the states sent delegates to Philadelphia in order to amend the Articles, but it soon became clear that a whole new document would be necessary. The convention became divided along lines of those who favored a new constitution, and those who favored to retain the Articles of Confederation. Those who favored adoption of a new constitution were the Federalists, while those who opposed the adoption became known as the Anti-Federalists. Leading Federalists were Alexander Hamilton, James Madison, and George Washington. Leading anti-Federalists were Patrick Henry, Samuel Adams, and Richard Henry Lee. Ultimately the Federalists would win and the Constitution would be adopted.

In December of 1788 the first election under the newly written constitution was held. George Washington was called on to run, and so he did, returning once more to assist the nation he helped founded. He would win every vote in the electoral college for President. Coming in second would be John Adams. Washington would be sworn into office on April 30th, 1789. He would set many of the precedents that would be followed by succeeding presidents. One of the most important precedents he would set was the selecting of cabinet members. For the position of Secretary of State he would select John Jay, who had served as Minister to Spain and France. For Secretary of the Treasury he would select Alexander Hamilton. For Attorney General he selected Edmund Randolph. Last but not least, he would select General Benedict Arnold to be the Secretary of War.

George-Washingtons-inaugu-006.jpg
 
So, Jefferson dead. Without him the anti-Federalists have practically lost their rudder, so to speak. There is really no unifying figure. Unless of course Madison just happens to switch sides again, even though i think that Jefferson really tethered him to make that choice.

And Benedict Arnold as Secretary of War? That's his place alright.

So....
President: George Washington
Vice President: John Adams
Secretary of State: John Jay
Secretary of Treasury: Alexander Hamilton
Secretary of War: Benedict Arnold
Attorney General:Edmund Randolph
Postmaster General:?
Secretary of Foreign Affairs:?

What of the last two positions. Washington supposedly had those.
Also, Henry Knox? What are you going to do with him.
 
Interesting butterfly there. No Jefferson makes me think Arnold fills his place later on.

And that practically kills the anti-Federalist camp, or at least puts them on parity.
 
There will be, this timeline was just a spurr of the moment. I was doing research for The Commonwealth of North America when this idea popped into my head.

I'm always looking for a way to rehabilitate Benny! Thanks for your start.
Now please continue! :D
 
I've got a question to ask the readers: What was the state of the French Navy in the 1790's? This may or may not play into this timeline, depending on how big or small it is.
 
The Early Days of Washington’s Presidency would set the pattern for all future presidents to follow. After having established his executive cabinet, he and congress would establish the judicial branch. He would do this through the Judiciary Act of 1789. The Act would establish a Supreme Court with a Chief Justice and 5 associate justices. Below the supreme court the act created lower district and circuit courts.

One thing the young nation was missing was a national capital. Cities up and down the 13 states were proposed. Secretary of the Treasury was insistent on the capital being located in the north, in particular New York City. Washington however was in favor of having the capital being located somewhere in Virginia. However Hamilton was persuasive, and convinced Washington that New York City should be the location of the national capital. The Residence Act of 1790 selected New York City as the national capital. It also created the Federal territory of Manhattan. Manhattan Island would be taken from New York and made into a territory under direct governing of the Federal government. It also removed New York City from the control of New York State. This would be quite unpopular with the state of New York. When the vote occurred in Congress, every New York delegate voted against the legislation, but it would still pass. This would remove nearly 50 thousand people from citizenship of New York State, and lose 2 representatives in the House.

Economically the nation was in dire straights. The country faced both foreign and domestic debt. The state governments were also in debt. However the northern states were in more debt then the southern states. Hamilton also recommended to Washington that the federal government should take on the war debt of the states in order to build up a national credit. He also insisted on the creation of a central bank to help finance these loans. The anti-federalists were ardently against this. James Madison tried to build up a coalition in congress to resist these actions, but without a leader to unify the anti-federalists, they would not have the strength to resist. Along with a central bank nationalizing state debt, Hamilton would also push for tariffs to protect American industry.

Hamilton6.jpg
 
Kind of surprised that Madison would dominantly remain in the Federalist camp without Jefferson to reign him in.

Also. Hamilton sure is a persuasive bastard.;):D
 
I would have put the capital in Philly myself if I was going to change things up, considering that it had one of the longest and most repeated stints as a capital. Plus not only is it more populous than New York was at the time, it's further south than it too, which sort of fits as a compromise between New York and Virginia. Plus it's a bit more defensible, considering it's a bit further inland.

Plus Hamilton's stepping on a few too many toes I think.

I've got a question to ask the readers: What was the state of the French Navy in the 1790's? This may or may not play into this timeline, depending on how big or small it is.

The French navy was no slouch then. They weren't decisively defeated until Trafalgar in 1805, which declawed them. I also think it went through its own purge in the 1790's of officers of noble birth thanks to the revolution.
 
Last edited:
Top