Status
Not open for further replies.

Monitor

Donor
Ok, a not totally antisemitic Hitler... Although I generally consider him more or less unimportant if Germany is not going into that shit show that was the years between the first WW and Machtergreifung... (Hyperinflation and then, when they finally manage to get it under control the USA decides to bring down the world's economy? Oh, come on, that was really not necessary...)
 
Give Me Liberty, Or Give Me Death
Give Me Liberty, Or Give Me Death

As mainland Europe fought a bloody war, things were quiet in Ireland. While both the Unionists and Republican factions were ready to tear each other apart in 1914, Britain's entry into the war forced them to put those thoughts towards the wayside. Now that 2 years have passed since then, things were about to happen. Over the past 2 years, the IRB had been receiving arms shipments from Germany. By 1916, their stockpile had grown to such a number they could theoretically launch a rebellion.

In late April 1916, the SS Libau had arrived with its shipment of 10,000 Russian rifles, a million rounds of ammo, 10 machine guns, and some explosives. Once the shipment was offloaded and distributed, the plan was set for a general uprising across the whole island. On the day before the planned date, all the volunteers reported in with 13,000 men in all 4 of the provinces.

On Sunday, 23 April 1916, the Irish Republicans’ plan went into action. In Dublin, the rebels secured several hotspots across the city such as the Four Courts, the City Hall, the General Post Office, and Dublin Castle. More importantly, they secured the telegraph line connecting the Post Office to the outside world, helping them spread the word of their actions to places such as the US.

Osteraufstand_-_Dublin_-_Barrikade.jpg

A street barricade erected by the rebel in Dublin

In areas outside of Dublin, several brigades were formed and headed west towards the River Shannon as quickly as possible. Other units took control of other cities such as Galway, Cork, and Limerick. Back in Dublin, the rebel leaders read out a document proclaiming an Irish republic. Despite its uplifting messages, it was received by an uninterested crowd who saw them as a bunch of radical nutjobs.

With the scale of the uprising becoming clear to London, the government was forced to redirect some divisions from France to help put down the rebellion. Not to mention, the Ulster unionists, who are hell-bent on preventing Home Rule or independence, also took up arms against what they saw as 'Fenian bastards'. Any Irish volunteer unlucky enough to be caught by any unionist was bound to be either beaten to a pulp or shot.

Soon enough, government forces struck back by calling up the Territorial divisions stationed around Ireland. Across the island, the various rebel groups were being pounded while the ones in Dublin were in a vicious street battle with civilians caught in the middle. When progress was slow, a gunboat was brought in and flattened the center of Dublin to help clear the path for the troops. The Territorials stormed Dublin Castle after punding it into rubble. One by one, the British army took back key areas of the city until the rebels were confined to only holding the Post Office. The very same building where they had read out the proclamation.

Osteraufstand_-_Dublin_-_britisches_Milit%C3%A4r.jpg

British soldiers in position behind a stack of barrels in Dublin

As the British brought in artillery guns and fired on the building, the Irish rebels surrendered. The leadership was imprisoned in a nearby jail, where most would end up in front of a firing squad. One of those who managed to avoid this fate was Michael Collins.

When news of the executions broke out, people were surprisingly shocked as they thought the firing squad was too cruel of a punishment for the rebels. This unpredictably swayed public opinion towards the republican cause.

Out in the countryside, the various brigades were forced to resort to guerilla warfare. It was futile though, as the last of the brigades would surrender in the summer of 1916.

Even though the uprising was eventually crushed, the damage had already been done. There was worldwide condemnation for the way the British handled the situation. In the US, violent protests broke out among Irish-Americans in support of the rebels. President Hughes, under intense political pressure, was forced to formally condemn Britain's actions and called on the government to lift the blockade on Germany so neutral ships could go on with their business.

For the IRB, later known as the IRA, the rebellion was a failure but it helped endear the population to their cause. The lessons they learned from this would be used in future operations after the war.
 
Last edited:

Monitor

Donor
Oh boy, hopefully they manage to avoid the troubles, but I am not so optimistic about that. If America breaks the Blockade, Germany suddenly solves a lot of its issues, which are already there, if not apparent right now (especially food!)
 
How is execution by firing squad deemed "too much" for proven rebel leadership? This is the early 20th century after all.
Not sure about in the story but IOTL the condemnation came from the trials themselves. They were were military courts-martial, not civilian trials, and were conducted in secret. If that wasn't bad enough, the defendants were refused any defense (later legal reviews deemed the proceedings to have been illegal under British Law). Finally, there was serious question in the Irish public about the level of guilt of some of those executed. A large portion of the Irish population did not support the Easter Rising but became very sympathetic to the cause of self-rule as a result of the heavy-handed reaction in the aftermath. In short, it was less the method of execution and more the lack of due-process that was the problem.
 
Last edited:
(later legal reviews deemed the proceedings to have been illegal under British Law).
I believe this is merely one opinion in a much later work. There was nothing in the Army Act which mandated that courts martial should be held in public. Without wishing to apply modern rules of civilised behaviour, what other penalty would be appropriate for armed insurrection in time of war when martial law was in force?
 
I believe this is merely one opinion in a much later work. There was nothing in the Army Act which mandated that courts martial should be held in public. Without wishing to apply modern rules of civilised behaviour, what other penalty would be appropriate for armed insurrection in time of war when martial law was in force?
The primary problem with the proceedings was not the secrecy (though that certainly did not help appearances). It was the complete lack of a defense which meant that there was no mechanism to question any of the evidence (I've found one anecdote of a defendant actually receiving permission to have his "superior officer" testify in his defense only for the superior to be executed the morning of the trial before being able to testify.). Under those circumstances, it would have been very unusual for the proceedings to be anything more than a formality with a pre-determined "Guilty" verdict (after all, if there was enough evidence to arrest them then they were clearly guilty....). Considering that of 187 trials, 90 were sentenced to death (with 75 of the sentences being rejected on review) it certainly seems that the courts were heavily inclined to favor execution over any other sentence (I was sadly unable to find numbers on any other sentences or acquittals being handed out so a more complete analysis is not possible at this time).

Under the civilized rules of the time, execution hardly seemed justified for people like Willie Pearse (the brother of one of the leaders) who by multiple accounts was merely an "attache" for his brother and didn't participate in the fighting at all. He should have received prison time, sure, but not execution. As another example, Thomas Kent didn't take part in the Rising at all (admittedly he would have if he hadn't received a "stand-down" order before it started). He was executed for killing a police officer when he was arrested in the post-Rising crackdown. He definitely should have been put on trial (and possibly executed, depending on the evidence) for killing the policeman but it should have been a separate civilian trial unconnected with the Rising instead of getting lumped in with the courts martials established for the Rising.

I'm relating this as an outside observer with no skin in the game. This is how it was viewed by the outside world when the word started to get out (there's a reason why only 14 executions were carried out before London intervened and ordered a halt). In the eyes of the period, there was also the (admittedly racist) horror that White Europeans were being treated like Colonial Insurrectionists (what that says about the casual acceptance in brutally putting down colonial insurrections does not speak well of said observers).
 
Hmm The British Empire is showing its cracks already Joriz a Quick question how is India these days in your tl?
Adolf is on his way to be a better Person than Otl and actually frontline fighting that will have an impact on him. (I actually enjoy seeing things in his perspective)
And the USA is now quite preocupied in mexico so no chance to get involved in Europe. Then there is the fact that mexico will be a shitshow full of pissed of Guirilla fighters behind the American line that will reap a bloody toll on them.
How will the situation in Irland evolve now after the first try got beaten? I can see the Irish learning and trying again later with a little central power help maybe?
 
Last edited:
how is India these days in your tl?
India is still sending men to fight on behalf of the empire. In the Raj, there's a growing demand among educated Indians for Home Rule in case of a victory as a reward for their sacrifices.

How will the situation in Irland evolve now after the first try got beaten? I can see the Irish learning and trying again later with a little central power help maybe?
The IRB, having an ungodly amount of weaponry, lick their wounds for now and wait for their next opportunity. They've learned a lot from the Rising and decided from now on to wage a low- level insurgency, since conducting another uprising would certainly destroy them. The Germans, seeing the nearly successful Rising getting crushed, find that there is some future potential in the Irishmen. This would later be important after the war as it helps the IRB keep afloat.
 
India is still sending men to fight on behalf of the empire. In the Raj, there's a growing demand among educated Indians for Home Rule in case of a victory as a reward for their sacrifices.
I spy with my little eye a point of even more rebellion after the war for the Brittish as they say "The more the merrier" Brittish view of how the World should work will absolutely get a kick in its nethers in your ttl even more so after loosing on the continent. I mean Irland and later the Raj wanting "to get out" from there clutches of there "Betters". Should make an Interesting interwar Period for them.
 
The Rage of Men
The Rage of Men

At the beginning of 1917, the situation in Germany was getting worse. While the Battle of Jutland had put a dent in the Royal Navy’s Grand Fleet, it didn’t have an impact on the British blockade that was slowly strangling the country. Through a combination of poor harvests, shortage of farming fertilizers, horses requisitioned for war, and deteriorating maintenance of agricultural machinery, the German people suffer food shortages.

The people were suffering from starvation throughout the winter, as potatoes were replaced with turnips due to a potato famine in 1916. Unfortunately, the turnip was one of the least appealing vegetables known to man. It was hardly edible and just made things worse. As a result, thousands died of starvation and hunger.

Meanwhile, the Government and OHL debated whether to bring back unrestricted submarine warfare. While the High Command was in favor as this would help starve the British, Chancellor Bethmann-Hollweg was adamantly against it. He cited that such a tactic would surely bring the US into the war in Europe while having to fight another one in Mexico. In one instance, the Chancellor yelled “Nein!” 9 times. Nonetheless, it was up to the Kaiser to make the final decision. After thinking long and hard, Wilhelm decided against restarting ‘Unrestricted submarine warfare’. Also, he ordered that their espionage network in the US shift from sabotage to propaganda, prompting a great deal of anti-British sentiment among German and Irish-Americans.

Austria was severely battered after the Brusilov Offensive and was plagued by nationalist sentiment in its territories. The Ottomans were getting hammered by the British, including an Arab tribal revolt led by T.E Lawrence. Things weren’t looking good for the Central Powers. But circumstances were about to change.

Revolution
On March 8, a mass protest in Petrograd spirals snowballs into a revolution against the Tsar and the war. When Russian troops were sent in to crush the protests, the men promptly mutinied and join the growing revolution. 7 days later, the Tsar abdicates under pressure from everyone in government. The 300-year-old rule of the Romanov Dynasty ends with the Provisional Government taking its place. In the immediate aftermath, the Entente recognizes the new government in hopes of the country staying in the war and maintaining its presence on the Eastern Front. With this legitimacy, Alexander Kerensky soon announced that Russia would continue the war. In one stroke, the Russian people were again pissed.

An Orderly Withdrawal
On March 15, the Germans along the center portion of the Western Front withdraw towards the Siegfried Line, where a line of fortifications prevents an Allied breakthrough from occurring. The front shortens by 25 miles, eliminating an unneeded bulge. While pulling back, they burn everything of value in a scorched-earth policy.

When the British learned of this, they attacked at Arras and the Canadians at Vimy Ridge. After gaining huge ground on the first day, they were stopped in their tracks by ferocious German resistance.

End of the Line
In March, Swedish forces launched an offensive that saw them successfully reach Helsinki. After taking the city, Russian resistance collapsed as troops simply stopped fighting due to the revolution in Petrograd. Throughout the night they partied, danced, and drank like there’s no tomorrow. For the rest of the year, the Swedes would advance in small areas until October as most Russian forces were nearly pushed out of Finland.

For the people back home, a sense of pride and superiority overwhelmed them. The image of the underdog Swedes beating the giant, Russia, became a cornerstone of Swedish identity. Newspapers blared the idea of Sweden's war as 'Revenge for 1809'. In the decades to come, WW1 would be seen in a positive light.

gG9mWU0.png

Eastern Front. December 1917

Cannon Fodder
To follow up with the British at Arras, General Nivelle launches his offensive. An offensive that ended in complete disaster. The French general had planned this attack with intense detail using the latest tactics for an offense. All of that was blunted, however, with the Germans having lots of intel on when and where the French were going to attack. On the first day, things never went according to plan.

Waves and waves of Frenchman were getting cut down like flies from German machine guns. The troops had barely even advanced as their comrades were getting butchered left and right. The carnage becomes too much for the average soldier. They had been enthusiastic beforehand but were now bitterly disappointed.

After a few days, the men disobey their orders to attack. None of them went up the ladder and stick their heads out. This defiance soon spreads across the French lines. It became clear to French high command that this was a mutiny. Fearing a supposed revolution from the ranks, the French authorities crack down hard. Suspected ringleaders were court-martialed and shot. Soldiers who refused to follow orders were sentenced to hard labor. All the while, no concessions were made to the troops. While the mutiny was harshly dealt with, it would later come back to bite them in the ass.


A Master Plan
On April 16, an exiled Russian returned home to the motherland. He arrives at Petrograd Station, having traveled through a few countries to reach his destination. Once there, a huge crowd waving red flags and banners greeted him. With the situation in Russia unclear, it was now time to make some moves. Here was the man who was going to change Russia forever. His name is Vladimir Lenin.

vladimir-lenin-medium.jpg

Vladimir Lenin
1870 - 1924

Lenin had every reason to be a revolutionary. His elder brother had been part of a group that assassinated Alexander III. For his crime, he was hanged along with the others. Vladimir since then, has never forgotten what they did to his brother and vowed on taking revenge against the government. When news of the revolution reached Berlin, the government debated on how to act on this opportunity. One of them, a Social Democrat, suggested they transport Lenin, who was in Switzerland, back to Russia for him to sow chaos.

While the rest were hesitant about sending a Bolshevik revolutionary for their advantage, they saw the advantage the man had in sowing upheaval. The Kaiser wasn’t thrilled with this idea, saying “If the German military plight were not so serious, I would forbid any action of this kind!”. He feared that sending Lenin would create a monster out of an enemy. But still, the important goal was to get Russia out of the war. If the Bolsheviks were the only group who would sue for peace, then now was the time to swallow his fears and give the green light.

In May, despite the desperate situation the country was in, the Provisional Government announced it would continue the war. This made them lose most of the support it had previously experienced. For Lenin, this was an opportunity handed to him on a silver platter.

This later became a further boon when the Kerensky Offensive was launched. The attack failed as soon as it started. The Germans had been lying in wait after having been leaked of the plans while the Russians themselves had jumbled in their coordination and where seriously disunited in the ranks. Sensing they might break the enemy; the Germans launched a counteroffensive that broke the Russians’ spirit. Many Russians simply fled the battlefield and deserted in droves.

In September, the Germans advanced on the Baltics. They captured the city of Riga, eventually reaching up to Estonia. Along the way, they faced little resistance.


Mamma Mia!
With the knowledge of Russia becoming a sinking ship, the Central Powers turn their attention elsewhere. To help their Austrian ally, the Germans plan an offensive towards the Italians. They hoped this would be a knockout blow that would help make things easier. Whilst planning this offensive, the Germans and Austrians practiced coordinating their armies after the experience they gained on the Eastern front.

For most of the war, the Austrians and Italians had been locked in a stalemate over the Alps with very little territory changing hands. Even when new grounds were captured, it came with heavy casualties having to fight through rough mountains and valleys. Luigi Cadorna had always told his men to attack even in the face of impossible odds to the point that he would have ‘deserters’ and ‘cowards’ be shot. When anyone tried to object to his ways, he simply sacked them for “Lack of offensive spirit”. By 1917, Cadorna ruled through fear. Unsurprisingly, the men hated him with a passion.

On October 24, the Austrians attacked. While they expected resistance as usual, what they found was a complete collapse of the front line. Whole Italian units were retreating as fast they could, with the Austrians and Germans advancing as fast they could. All the Italians fled back across the Piave river, trying to set up a defensive line. This bought them time as the Austrians were halted and needed to resupply.

The humiliating retreat at Caporetto sparked outrage towards the government. It caused the Prime Minister to resign and made everyone feel humiliated. Fearing that Italy was about to quit the war, the Allies shored up frontline with a few divisions and some artillery.

Caporetto1.jpg

Italian POWs after the battle

Red October
On November 6, the people of Petrograd went to sleep under a Provisional Government and woke up the next day with the entire city in chaos. The Bolsheviks had staged a coup. Kerensky, the most hated man in Russia, barely fled before they could catch him. Lenin announced a new ‘Soviet’ government where private property and private enterprise were declared illegal. Lenin also announces the end of Russia’s involvement in the war.

Thus, begins the Russians Civil War as the newly – formed ‘Red Army’ begins executing government officials and generals that were anti-socialists and could pose a threat.

Feeling left with no hope, Romania seeks an armistice. Russia soon follows in December. The Eastern front had seemingly come to an end.

A Spoiled Christmas
On December 25, a civilian freighter carrying clothes, food, toys, and gifts from the US was en route to Germany. Unfortunately, a British U-boat spotted it and had mistaken it for a German ship. With full confidence, the crew fired torpedoes and the ship was hit. When they realize what the ship was carrying, everyone knew they had just made the biggest mistake ever made.

When news of the sinking reached American shores, there was total disgust. Many Americans were outraged at the British that some protested at the gates of the British embassy in DC. The outrage was also fueled by propaganda campaign by German spies that paid off. Some of the protesters had called on the US government to cancel all loans to the Entente as revenge. President Hughes, having no choice but to make a decision, demanded the British lift the blockade or face huge sanctions. The British, having depended on American loans to finance their war, had no choice but to accept. By next year, neutral ships would be allowed to go wherever they want as long as they weren't carrying war materials.

For the Germans, what had become a tragedy had turned into a godsend. They had experienced a year of unprecedented struggling, with starvation rationing taking a toll on them. But all was not gloom, as the Kaiser had promised political reforms that would turn the country into a constitutional monarchy and vowed to abolish the Prussian three-class franchise with universal suffrage as its replacement.

His message to the people was simple: Good times were going to come, it's just a matter of holding on to the end. Stay strong.
 
Last edited:

Monitor

Donor
The British have a problem. The German Juggernaut lost only because of lack of resources, and the British were nice enough to solve that problem for them. :) (or at least in this timeline that is true. Still scary how close germany actually got at managing it in our timeline, considering how stacked the deck was.)
 
Mhh so the USA is in Mexico and at least true Neutral now (maybe even German friendly).
The Italians are losing may we see a Austrian Venice or is that to much? ;)
The Ottomans are holding on so the question is can they hold on long enough for the Positive effects of a Central power win to come or will they collapse beforehand?
Russia is out so we should see Brest Litovisk coming around shortly and Millions of Soldiers for the Western front.
The greatest question how much will the french British loose in terms of land at the end of that war in the final treaty Maas or Mosselle Border for the French?
Edit: what is with Belgium and Luxenburg?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top