The Forge of Weyland

28th May 1940
28th May 1940 (Part 1)

Belgium


At 0700 the lead tank elements of 1st Armoured division begin to move eastwards towards Puurs and Willebroek. Their cavalry reconnaissance element started off at dawn, and has stopped south of the N290 highway having encountered 9th Panzer's own screen. General Evan has split the division, keeping 1st Armoured Brigade concentrated in the area of Hamme (north of Dendermonde) in case 9th Panzer manage to push on over the Scheldt at Temse and threaten his flank, while 2nd Armoured Brigade drives on Puurs. His intention is to hit 9th Panzer on the flank, and to roll them up to the east. His Cutlass infantry tank units are behind 2nd Armoured, and if 9th Panzer isn't as far forward as expected, they will take care of any counterattack south. Once 9th Panzer has been dealt with, his orders are to re-establish the defensive line south of Antwerp, and hold it until relieved by the infantry of 5th British Division.

9th Panzer were intending to make a crossing of the Scheldt at Temse before pushing on to surround the French forces north of Antwerp, but the reports of British armoured cars by hisn own screen, and the report from the Luftwaffe late the previous evening of tanks massing in the area of Dendermonde has changed his plans. Now his intention is to block tne obvious armoured thrust from the south, then counterattack and then cross the river either at Temse or opposite Hamme.

The first indication that things are not going to plan was the reports coming in of the first actions with 2nd Armoured Brigade. With no clear identification of exactly who was approaching, General von Hubiki had assumed they were French tanks from a reserve formation; while the movement of 1st Armoured north from the Sedan area had been noted, they hadn't been expected to arrive here this soon, but the heavily motorised British units were far less dependent on the French and Belgian railways system. He had read the reports of the fighting in the Ardennes, and they indicated that the British tanks were capable opponents, which meant he needed to concentrate his medium tanks to stop them.

General von Hubiki was glad that the British hadn't advanced as fast as he would have done. He would have kept on driving, attacking 9th Panzer the previous evening while they were still moving forward, which would have placed him in a much more precarious position. The need by General Blanchard to coordinate the different formations in the areas, belonging to three different countries and all with differing movement speeds had made him be conservative in respect to his more mobile units. So 9th Panzer had been able to set themselves into a defensive posture, with mines laid where possible to help channel an attack, and with heavier guns brought up to supplement the divisions 37mm antitank guns.

The British tanks nevertheless pushed slowly forward despite the well-sited defence. Led by the Sabre tanks, they took a heavy toll of any of the lighter Panzers that were unfortunate enough to come into range, and proved a serious challenge for the Pz III and Pz IV's. Despite some losses in getting this far, 9th Panzer had 40 of these available, and all of them had been concentrated in front of the British advance. By noon, von Hubiki had lost twelve Pz III and three of his Pz IV tanks, but 2nd Armoured Brigade had themselves lost some 40 Sabre tanks, some disabled by mines or broken down, but the heavy antitank guns had been a serious problem.

The initial British plan, to push forward and cut the head of the panzer spearpoint, was now looking far too costly. The Sabres pulled back slightly into defence, while a battalion of the Cutlass Infantry tanks was moved in behind them. This time they would advance to support one of the armoured infantry battalions, while the Sabre tanks made sure no panzers would try and outflank them.

*********

The report from the Admiralty that some of their destroyers had engaged small ships carrying troops apparently to Zeeland had taken a while to work through the system. There was currently no good communication between them and the Army, so by the time it had worked its way through the rather sclerotic channels it had been overtaken by events.

At first light, German airborne units had landed, either by parachute or glider, in the coastal area south of Ternuzen, straddling the canal. The French forces in the area were the rear echelon of the infantry divisions fighting on the west bank of the Scheldt north of Antwerp, and were taken completely by surprise. While the airborne troops were in fact considerably outnumbered by the French, the surprise, and the fact that there were an elite unit and the French were support troops, let to them pushing the French back some five miles south as they expended the airhead. The initial reports of the fighting were very confused, and before the French command had been able to clarify things and work out what was happening, addition mountain troops were landed in Terneusan from smaller ships and craft to reinforce the airborne units.

The Germans added to the confusion in the French units by a series of heavy attacks by the Luftwaffe, which succeeded in their aim of causing more disorganisation in the units currently engaging the thrust west from Antwerp, and delaying an early response to the new invasion.

*******

The situation only started to clarify for the Allied High command by noon. The heavy air presence of the Luftwaffe had made it almost impossible to get any decent aerial reconnaissance of what was going on on the ground, and it was mainly reports from the units who had fallen back from the new assault that made General Blanchard realise his problem.

His initial thoughts were to bring up new troops to hold and then pinch out the combined aerial and seaborne assault. This would relieve the pressure on the forward French units, who for the next day would hold on where they were, British 1st Armoured would carry on their attack on 9th Panzer, to remove the threat of encircling the units around Antwerp and joining up with the airborne troops. He had a French infantry Corps on the way, but the were travelling by train, and would not attive until tomorrow, and would need another day to detrain and to get themselves organised. He had three British divisions and an armoured brigade that were available, and he would use these to form a defensive line and then push out the airborne troops.

British V Corps would advance east of Bruges and make sure the Germans didn't push west. He felt that unless the airborne troops were heavily reinforced, this was not too likely, although he wanted naval and air support to make sure no more troops were ferried over to add to his problem. British 5th division would position itself north of Ghen, to make sure the beachhead stayed where it was until he had organised a proper counterattack. As long as 1st Armoured stopped 9th Panzer, that shouldn't be an issue. While there were Belgian forces around Ghent, many of these were the disorganised elements of units badly handled in the initial invasion of Belgium, or made up of reserves, and he didn't want to have to count on them yet.
 
The call has gone out for naval and air support to make the German landings! Who do we think will do more damage the RAF and AdA or the Royal Navy (humming Hearts of Oak quietly).
 
The call has gone out for naval and air support to make the German landings! Who do we think will do more damage the RAF and AdA or the Royal Navy (humming Hearts of Oak quietly).

I vote for a strong chorus of Hearts of Oak, followed by rendition of the finale of the 1812 Ovature sung by 4.7 to 15 inch guns!
 
And that is the best the Germans can do...

The VI Army had:
- 5 good infantry divisions
- 5 third rate divisions (200 Series)
- 2 panzer divisions that already had casualties in Hannut and Gembloux

The XVIII Army had:
- 2 green SS Divisions (the 1940 SS where not the 1944 Waffen SS)
- 7 third rate divisions
- 1 panzer division

The whole OKH Reserve was comprised by
- 9 first and second rate divisions
- 9 third rate divisions

Any divisions from the Ardennes and Eifel forest would have been marching north on foot and would arrive later than any Allied division that used railroad instead of marching via forest roads.. The OKH divisions would move by train and then foot.

The above divisions are currently facing the excellent French 1st Army, the BEF and the entirety of the Belgian Army that by this point has minimal material losses (62 guns lost, while ~2,000 are fine -included the 47mm antitank guns).
 
And that is the best the Germans can do...

The VI Army had:
- 5 good infantry divisions
- 5 third rate divisions (200 Series)
- 2 panzer divisions that already had casualties in Hannut and Gembloux

The XVIII Army had:
- 2 green SS Divisions (the 1940 SS where not the 1944 Waffen SS)
- 7 third rate divisions
- 1 panzer division

The whole OKH Reserve was comprised by
- 9 first and second rate divisions
- 9 third rate divisions

Any divisions from the Ardennes and Eifel forest would have been marching north on foot and would arrive later than any Allied division that used railroad instead of marching via forest roads.. The OKH divisions would move by train and then foot.

The above divisions are currently facing the excellent French 1st Army, the BEF and the entirety of the Belgian Army that by this point has minimal material losses (62 guns lost, while ~2,000 are fine -included the 47mm antitank guns).
Into the valley of death they........
 
Can someone elaborate on the tactics of the British armoured forces at this time?

Just in terms of armor encountering heavy anti-tank guns, would they not simply withdraw until the Royal Artillery pummeled the positions, before pushing forward again? The reason I ask is based on the very few 88's that would be a danger to the wonderfully butterflied tanks Astrodragon has created, I have to assume the RA wouldn't have to take out many positions to have eliminated the threat? How many 88's would a typical Panzer Division have at this time? And how would the tanks and their supporting recon units usually spot, then call in RA support? Lead time between an order being called in and first rounds landing? This is way outside my lane so just trying to paint a picture in my head as to how such contact would take place. Thanks in advance, M.
 
IIRC a large number of 88s were decimated in earlier actions vs British forces during earlier actions so the 88s may be spread thinner.
 
Can someone elaborate on the tactics of the British armoured forces at this time?

Just in terms of armor encountering heavy anti-tank guns, would they not simply withdraw until the Royal Artillery pummeled the positions, before pushing forward again? The reason I ask is based on the very few 88's that would be a danger to the wonderfully butterflied tanks Astrodragon has created, I have to assume the RA wouldn't have to take out many positions to have eliminated the threat? How many 88's would a typical Panzer Division have at this time? And how would the tanks and their supporting recon units usually spot, then call in RA support? Lead time between an order being called in and first rounds landing? This is way outside my lane so just trying to paint a picture in my head as to how such contact would take place. Thanks in advance, M.
Ideally., yes. The tactic would be to hold position -preferably in cover - and call in the guns. An alternative would be an infantry assault.
However there is also the need to cut through the panzer thrust, so in practice this will cause more losses. Not a huge number, but the Germans are prepared, and the Brigade only has so much artillery. The big advantage of the SP guns is they can move quickly, so counterbattery fire is less effective.

9th Panzer is also using artillery, not just 88's, and they have laid some mines. So the British tanks have to grind through a defensive position. Which is why they've called in the infantry tanks, these are better suited for the task. This was the pre-war doctrine if the position is too tough for the cruiser tanks to take easily.
 
Well, we know that the 88s were distributed as 12 per corps. In "Panzer Divisions- the Blitzkrieg Years" the majority of the attached flak units are described as "leichte", light. There were not that many of them even in May 10th with zero casualties.

The 88s were also distributed as 12 per corps. But at that level, using them in an anti-tank role would mean that the corps was about to be overrun. The 88s at that level had to be used in an AA role to protect important junctions, supply depots, railheads etc.

I am of the opinion that the panzer units are a shadow of their 10th May self. In OTL where they had much fewer casualties, most of which were damaged tanks that were retrieved by the Germans. Yet, even so, in the OTL Case Red on June 5th the panzer divisions were at 50% strength.

In contrast in this timeline, we have one panzer division completely destroyed, six mauled and two suffering moderate casualties. In all the cases with the exception of the Battle of Hannut, the Allies controlled the battlefield after each battle. Every damaged or broken down panzer was left behind, in complete contrast to the OTL.

The great retreat by the 1st, 2nd, 6th and 8th panzer divisions took place against dug in DCRs, DLM and excellent infantry, To pin down so many dug in good formations, the sacrifices must have been horrendous. These were not partially trained Soviet rifle divisions of nominal strength lead by an upjumped major or B Series french divisions with untrained 40 year old reservists. These were Regulars. The panzers can only bring that many men on top of them. The 88s and the rest of the anti tank formation must have been left behind to engage the French until destroyed. The real eschelon formations such as the valuable communication units must have been partially or completely destroyed.

The French of the 7th Army had more infantry than all the panzer divisions combined. Good dug in infantry. To keep the roads open for the tanks against the excellent french 47mm and even 25mm (that would have punched through the sides or rear of a Pz III and Pz IV and the front of a Pz II), infantry must have held up the roads. And infantry would perish against numerically superior equally well trained infantry and tanks.

So, I think the fighting ability of the remaining panzer divisions is limited, very limited. How to function without proper infantry and artillery support? How to achieve the vaunted german tactical mobility with a gutted communication abteilung? To simply attach a battalion of infantry that has never worked before with tanks, would be a solution but a pretty bad one. An infantry or artillery unit does not become experts in combined arms warfare over a singe week.

Overall, this new offensive has the potential to be the death ride of the panzer divisions and it is pretty consisted with the quick victory at all costs doctrine of the Germans. Good luck rebuilding the 10 divisions over the 1940-1941 winter if they are gutted beyond recognition.
 
Last edited:
28th May 1940 Part 2
28th May 1940 (Part 2)

Belgium


That afternoon, the only major Allied attack was that of the Infantry tanks of 1st Armoured. The German landings were causing huge difficulties for the French infantry force around Antwerp, their rear echelon attacked, many of the men either surrendering or dispersing to avoid the much better organised and trained German force, and a renewed push by the German infantry to their east hadn't helped matters at all. For the time being, the sudden loss of their logistical and support train was bearable, but in a day or so they would run low on artillery shells and some of the other supplies. General Lanquetot had already informed General Billotte that unless his supply lie could be re-established, he would either have to withdraw into Antwerp or fight his way out of what was starting to look like an encirclement of his men.

More infantry divisions were coming up, and General Billotte intended to use these to push the airborne troops back. As long as 1st Armoured could break the ongoing panzer thrust, the French Corps (4e, 21e and 60e) would just have to defend against any attempt by the Germans to break in from the west. H also ordered Lord Gort to position his reserve in case it was needed to reinforce the Belgian troops between Antwerp and the BEF. While a break had been made closer to the city thanks to 9th Panzer, he wanted to make sure that the Germans weren't able to roll up the Belgian defences along the Dyle, an obvious continuation of their breakthrough. The Belgians there were under pressure from the German Infantry, but as yet were in well-prepared defences and were holding.

Further south, there had been more action in front of the Genbloux gap, where 1st, 3rd and 4th Panzer divisions had been putting pressure on 1, 2 1nd 3 DLM. The situation there was fluid, and in general was similar to the earlier breakthrough attempt - the French tanks were faring well on their own, but the panzers tactics and mobility were causing them greater losses. However at the moment the DLM's were holding, backed by the now well-dug-in infantry of 1st Army, and he felt confident that the situation here was stable, unless the strength of the German attack increased considerably.

************

Having brought up their infantry tanks, 1st Armoured Brigade recommenced its attack north at 1500. The heavier infantry tanks fared better against the prepared defences - as had ben expected - and started to make significant progress. While well-trained in this type of defence, 9th Panzer only had so many heavy guns and mines available, and only a heavy gun could stop a Cutlass. The mines helped by disabling some, but that didn't stop the remaining tanks, backed by their armoured infantry support.

An attempt to go around the heavy tanks and attack them from the rear failed; a regiment of Sabre tanks had been positioned on either side of the main thrust to counter exactly this type of attack, and with the heavy guns mainly concentrated against the central thrust, the lighter panzers made little progress.

It was by now obvious to General von Hubiki that there was now little hope of deflecting the British armour unless he could find more tanks and heavy guns. While 2nd Panzer was behind him (to the east of Antwerp), the gap that had been made in the Belgian defences wasn't wide enough yet to allow them to easily deploy beside him. He saw no option but to pull back east, his intention being to trail his coat for the British tanks, and pull them onto more gunlines, including those of 2nd Panzer. That should allow the two panzer divisions to break through the weakened British force, and drive forward to meet up with the landings.

While a retreat under fire like this was not the preferred tactic of the german armour, they were pre-war troops, and well-trained in the various manoeuvres they might have to do. While they had to abandon damaged and broken-down tanks, they did manage to extract most of their vehicles east. They had suffered heavy losses, and the fast-responding British artillery had removed the need to pull back a considerable part of their artillery, but they had also blunted 2nd Armoured Brigade, who even with the addition of the Cutlass regiment were down to half strength, although the withdrawal of the panzers did allow them to start recovering some of their broken down tanks. By 1800, the panzers, while still in action while slowly retreating, were felt to be contained, and the Brigade expected to be able to hold here, allowing 1st Armoured Brigade to drive into the landing force at dawn tomorrow.

*****************

Norway

Allied forces consisted of British, French, Norwegian, and Polish troops attack Narvik across the Rombaksfjord. German air support doesn't arrive until nearly five hours after the start of the attack, and was then unable to make any decisive intervention, although they did damage the cruiser HMS Cairo and this caused the Allied fleet to withdraw. However at 1200 French mountain troops capture the port, forcing the German defenders (a mixture Gebirgsjäger alpine light infantry units and men from the crews of the destroyers sunk in the earlier naval actions) into the surrounding hills. Unable to hold any longer, the German troops, withdraw towards the safety of the Swedish border and internment.

The news that Narvik is now in Allied hands means that the plan to form an easily-defended line further south becomes more urgent. With such a line established, the port will only have to be able to fend off air attacks, and as summer arrives the necessary airfields and defenses can be put in place more easily. Fighters will have to come from Britain, and the need for yet more fighters - already badly needed in France as well as for the defence of Britain itself - means that aircraft production in Britain needs to be reassessed.

America

The National Defense Advisory Committee is established in the United States as a group of advisors for US President Roosevelt. Its membership includes business and industry leaders such as William Knudsen, Edward Stettinius, and Sidney Hillman and academics such as economist Leon Henderson. While ostensibly its purpose is to look at improving the defences of the United States, its undeclared remit is to see how aid may be made available to the Allied powers, if necessary finding ways to work around the problems caused by some American legislation.
 
Well things seem to be going somewhat well in Belgium for the Allies though I imagine the Germans are starting the sweat it remains to be seen whether the mad Austrian Corporal will let them withdraw.

Fighters will have to come from Britain, and the need for yet more fighters - already badly needed in France as well as for the defence of Britain itself - means that aircraft production in Britain needs to be reassessed.
I imagine Bomber Command is about to scream like they are being gelded with a butter knife.
 
That afternoon, the only major Allied attack was that of the Infantry tanks of 1st Armoured. The German landings were causing huge difficulties for the French infantry force around Antwerp, their rear echelon attacked, many of the men either surrendering or dispersing to avoid the much better organised and trained German force, and a renewed push by the German infantry to their east hadn't helped matters at all. For the time being, the sudden loss of their logistical and support train was bearable, but in a day or so they would run low on artillery shells and some of the other supplies. General Lanquetot had already informed General Billotte that unless his supply lie could be re-established, he would either have to withdraw into Antwerp or fight his way out of what was starting to look like an encirclement of his men.
I think the French might be able to use the ample belgian shell stocks stored in the Antwerp Fortified Area. After all, they use the same artillery calibers as the Belgians.

More infantry divisions were coming up, and General Billotte intended to use these to push the airborne troops back.
By that point, Billotte should be able to move some good divisions in central and north Belgium. In that point in OTL, the following divisions joined the fight across the Somme (OTL Altmayer's 10th Army and the new 7th Army since the original was destroyed):

- 31e Division d’Infanterie Alpine (31e DIAlp)
- 5e Division d’Infanterie Coloniale (5e DIC)
- 13e Division d’Infanterie (13e DI)
- 16e Division d’infanterie (16e DI)
- 24e Division d’infanterie (24e DI)
- 4e Division d’infanterie coloniale (4e DIC)
- 11e Division d’Infanterie (11e DI)
- 19e Division d’Infanterie (19e DI)
- 29e Division d’Infanterie Alpine (29e DIAlp)
- 47e Division d’Infanterie (47e DI)
- 3e Division Légère d’Infanterie (3e DLI)
- 23e Division d’Infanterie (23e DI)


In OTL the gutted DLCs were added in the 10th Army, but I don't think there is a reason for that now that the situation is not catastrophic. I guess they can be kept in reserve and slowly reformed into DLMs over the 1940-1941 winter according to the original plan.

The interesting detail, is that the aforementioned divisions are either Active or A Series Reserve formations. The rest of the uncommitted B Series and newlly raised colonial divisions can be kept in the general reserve. Billotte can move the 12 good (or very good) infantry divisions to address the new challenge, while Touchon's 6th Army can plug the front between the 9th Army remnants and the 2nd Army. The 7th can become again a mobile reserve. Overall, without the OTL loss of dozens of divisions, the Allies can present a very dense frontline that has basically twice as much artillery as the Germans.

The Belgians on their own, already outnumber the german troops committed against Antwerp. Between the three divisions of the 7th Army Corps, the mighty 1st Armoured, the V Corps and Billotte's new divisions, the Allies enjoy tremendous superiority in men and material. Not to mention an absolute superiority in good-quality divisions, as most of the good german infantry divisions are marching northwards on foot.
 
Ideally., yes. The tactic would be to hold position -preferably in cover - and call in the guns. An alternative would be an infantry assault.
However there is also the need to cut through the panzer thrust, so in practice this will cause more losses. Not a huge number, but the Germans are prepared, and the Brigade only has so much artillery. The big advantage of the SP guns is they can move quickly, so counterbattery fire is less effective.

9th Panzer is also using artillery, not just 88's, and they have laid some mines. So the British tanks have to grind through a defensive position. Which is why they've called in the infantry tanks, these are better suited for the task. This was the pre-war doctrine if the position is too tough for the cruiser tanks to take easily.

Awesome! Thank you Astrodragon! I had not thought of using non-88 artillery in a direct fire role, but given the initial German experience with the armour of British tanks, the fact they would make that adjustment makes a huge amount of sense.
 
Awesome! Thank you Astrodragon! I had not thought of using non-88 artillery in a direct fire role, but given the initial German experience with the armour of British tanks, the fact they would make that adjustment makes a huge amount of sense.
Of course if they're using artillery in an anti-tank role then they're not available for artillery support which will be another problem.
 
Top