The flame of British Liberalism burns steady and brighter: A timeline from 1945

In this TL, the Suez crisis happened as it did in OTL. (1) The government won a Labour vote of censure in the House of Commons on its Suez policy, on 1 November 1956, by 298 votes to 290 votes. This was two less than its nominal majority of ten.

(1) See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suez_Crisis.
 
Last edited:
The by-election in Chester caused by the appointment of Basil Nield (Conservative) as Recorder of Manchester took place on 15 November 1956. The result was that the Conservative majority over Liberal fell from 21.9% to 2.0%.

Anthony Nutting, an Under-Secretary of State at the Foreign Office, resigned from the government on 3 November 1956, because he opposed the government's Suez policy. Eden appointed Anthony Noble as Foreign Office Under-Secretary. A few days later Nutting resigned as Conservative MP for Melton. In the subsequent by-election on 19 December, the Conservative majority over Labour fell from 16.0% to 1.4%.

Anthony Eden resigned as leader of the Conservative Party and Prime Minister on 9 January 1957, because of ill health. The leader of the House of Commons, Rab Butler, was the only contender to succeed Eden. So he became Tory Party leader and
Prime Minister on 10 January.
 
Here is Rab Butler's cabinet appointed 11 and 12 January 1957:
Prime Minister: Richard Austen Butler
Lord Chancellor: Viscount Kilmuir (formerly Sir David Maxwell Fyfe)
Lord President of the Council: Marquess of Salisbury
Lord Privy Seal and Leader of the House of Commons: Harold Macmillan
Chancellor of the Exchequer: Peter Thorneycroft
Foreign Secretary: Earl of Home
Home Secretary: Osbert Peake
Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food: Derek Heathcote Amory
Colonial Secretary: Alan Lennox-Boyd
Commonwealth Relations Secretary: Harry Hopkinson
Minister of Defence: Geoffrey Lloyd
Minister of Education: John Maclay
Minister of Housing and Local Government: Duncan Sandys
Minister of Labour and National Service: Iain Macleod
Minister of Power: Reginald Maudling
Secretary of State for Scotland: Thomas Galbraith
President of the Board of Trade: Nigel Birch
Minister of Transport and Civil Aviation: Sir David Eccles.
 
Last edited:
Here are ministers outside the cabinet appointed 13 and 14 January 1957:
First Lord of the Admiralty; George Ward
Secretary of State fir Air: Viscount Hailsham
Attorney-General; Sir Rwginald Manningham-Buller
Minister of Health: Florence Horsbrugh
Paymaster-General: Lord Carrington
Minister of Pensions and National Insurance: Harold Watkinson
Minister without Portfolio: Lord Mancroft
Postmaster-General: Charles Hill
Solicitor-General: Sir William Miĺligan
Minister of Supply: John Boyd-Carpenter
Secretary of State for War: Anthony Head
Minister of Works: Ernest Marples,

A few junior ministers:
Economic Secretary to the Treasury: Enoch Powell
Financial Secretary to the Treasury: Henry Brooke
Parliamentary Secretary to the Treasury (Government Chief Whip): Derek Vosper
Ministers of State Foreign Office: David Ormsby-Gore and Earl of Perth.
 
Last edited:
The Lewisham North by-election on 14 February 1957 caused by the death of Austin Hudson on 29 November 1956, was a Labour gain from Conservative. A Conservative majority of 8.7% in the 1955 general election became a Labour majority of 8.2%.

Rhys Hopkin Morris, the Liberal MP for Carmarthen, died on 22 November 1956. The subsequent by-election was held on 28 February 1957. The percentage votes for each party were as follows (1955 general election):
John Morgan Davies (Liberal): 46.1 (55.4)
Labour candidate: 42.4 (36.8)
Plaid Cymru candidate: 11.5 (7.8)
------------------------------------
Liberal majority: 3.7 (18.6)
-----------------------------------
The swing from Liberal to Labour to 7.45%. The Conservatives had not contested the constituency since the 1935 general election. Davies' candidature was controversial. He had taken a pro-government line on the Suez crisis, and some Liberals thought that the Liberal leader, Frank Byers, should have disowned him. (1)

The Wednesbury by-election caused by the resignation of Stanley Evans (Labour) on 26 November 1956, was held on 28 February 1957. Anthony Crosland held the seat for Labour. ( 2) His majority over Liberal was 30.2%. Evans had a majority over Conservative of 22.8% in the 1955 general election.

(1) In OTL Carmarthen was a Labour gain from Liberal, with Lady Megan Lloyd George the successful Labour candidate.

(2) In OTL, John Stonehouse was elected Labour MP for Wednesbury in the by-election.
 
There were three by-elections on 7 March 1957, all in Conservative seats. Bristol West caused by the resignation of Sir Walter Monckton; Liverpool West Derby caused by the appointment of Sir David Maxwell Fyfe as Lord Chancellor, and his elevation to the peerage as Viscount Kilmuir; and Warwick and Leamington caused by the resignation of Sir Anthony Eden, who was created Earl of Avon.

In Briatol West the Conservative majority over Labour fell from 32.1% to 18.2%. The Liberal vote rose from 17.1% to 21.2%.

Liverpool West Derby was a Labour gain from Conservative. In a straight fight a Conservative majority of 4,0% in the 1955 general election became a Labour majority of 9.6% in the by-election.

Warwick and Leamington was held by the Tories, but their majority over Labour fell from 40.0% to 23.1%. The Liberal vote fell from 14.8% to 13.5%.

Two by-elections were held on 21 Match 1957. In the Beckenham by-election caused by the elevation of Patrick Buchan-Hepburn to the peerage, the Conservative majority over Labour dropped from 34.7% to 26.2%.. The Liberal vote increased from 18.7% to 23.4%..

In the Crosby by-election caused by the elevation of Gwilym Lloyd-George to the peerage, the Conservative majority over Liberal fell from 35.5% to 17.9%.
 
Disappointed you butterflied away the Hereford by-election of February 1956 - Frank Owen might well have won that and passed the seat to Robin Day.
 
Disappointed you butterflied away the Hereford by-election of February 1956 - Frank Owen might well have won that and passed the seat to Robin Day.
The Hereford by-election of February 1956 is in post #40 on page 2. It was won by Frank Owen.
 
The Edinburgh South by-election on 29 May 1957 was won by the Tories, with the Liberals going up from third to second place. The East Ham North by-election on 12 September 1957 was held by Ashley Bramall for Labour. (1) He was Parliamentary Secretary Ministry of Housing and Local Government from August 1953 to February 1955. He lost his Bexley seat in the general election.

Jack Diamond held Gloucester for Labour in the by-election held on 12 September 1957. He was Parliamentary Secretary Ministry of Works from August 1953 to February 1955. The Liberals took second place from the Tories.

Richard Stokes, who was Minister of Works from February 1950 to April 1951, Lord Privy Seal from April 1951 to August 1953, and Home Secretary from August 1953 to February 1955 died on 3 August 1957. He was not in the Labour shadow cabinet because he did not stand in the shadow cabinet election in November 1956. He was MP for Ipswich. In the by-election on 24 October 1957, the seat was held for Labour by Reg Prentice. The Liberals went up from third to second place.

The Conservatives won the Liverpool Garston by-election on 5 December 1957. But their majority over Labour fell from 29.2% to 10.6% and the Liberal vote increased from 18.8% to 27.0%.

The Glasgow Kelvingrove by-election on 13 March 1958 was the first election to be televised. There was a televised debate between the candidates. They were Katherine Elliot, the widow of the former MP, Walter Elliot; Mary McAlister (Labour), David Murray (Liberal), William Park (Independent Labour Park). The result was a Labour gain from Conservative with a majority of 7.6%. Walter Elliot's majority in the general election was 7.3%. The Liberal vote rose from 10.7% to 12.6%..

George Lambert, the National Liberal and Conservative MP for Torrington, succeeded to a hereditary peerage, thus causing a by-election in the constituency. In the 1955 general election the Liberals were in second place, 15.1% behind Lambert, and they had high hopes of taking the seat from the Conservatives. There were over sixty applicants for the Liberal candidature, which was whittled down to a short list of five. This was as follows, in alphabetical order of surname:
Desmond Banks, candidate for St.Ives in the general election. He co-founded the Radical Reform Group in the Liberal Party in 1952.
Peter Bessell, candidate for Torquay in the general election.
Richard Moore, who contested Tavistock in the general election. He had been leader writer for the Liberal Party supporting News Chronicle since 1956.
Mrs Elizabeth Rashleigh. She contested the constituency in the 1950 and 1955 general elections, and came second both times. She was a Justice of the Peace, and a speaker for the bWomen's Institute. She was married to a doctor. In World War II she helped the Red Cross. She was the only local candidate. (2)
Jeremy Thorpe, who was the Liberal candidate for Tiverton in the general election.

The Torrington Liberal Association chose Mrs Rashleigh as their candidate for the by-election. The result of the election was a Liberal gain from Conservative. The percentage votes for each candidate were as follows (1955 general election):
Elizabeth Rashleigh (Liberal): 44. 4 (33.6)
Anthony Royle (Conservative): 38.9 (48.7)
Labour candidate: 16.7 (17.6)
------------------------------------------------------
Liberal majority: 5.5% (National Liberal and Conservative majority 15.1%)
------------‐-----------------------------------------
The swing from Conservative to Liberal was 10.3%.

(1) In OTL, Reg Prentice was elected Labour MP in the by-election.

(2) Here is a 1950 newspaper article about her: http://bidefordarchive.org.uk/searc...1390-torrington-division-political-candidates
 
Last edited:
The Chancellor of the Exchequer, Peter Thorneycroft; the President of the Board of Trade, Nigel Birch; and the Economic Secretary to the Treasury, Enoch Powell, all resigned from the government on 6 January 1958 in opposition to the policy of increasing government expenditure. The Prime Minister, Rab Butler, made the following changes to the government:
Harold Macmillan from Lord Privy Seal and Leader of the House of Commons to Chancellor of the Exchequer
Osbert Peake from Home Secretary to Lord Privy Seal and Leader of the House of Commons
Iain Macleod from Minister of Labour and National Service to Home Secretary
Sir David Eccles from Minister of Transport to Minister of Labour and National Service
John Boyd-Carpenter from Minister of Supply [outside cabinet] to Minister of Transport [inside cabinet]
Lord Mills appointed Minister of Supply.
Reginald Maudling from Minister of Power to President of the Board of Trade
John Hare from Parliamentary Secretary Minister of Transport to Minister of Power
Frederick Erroll from Minister of State Board of Trade to Economic Secretary to the Treasury.
 
The Hereford by-election of February 1956 is in post #40 on page 2. It was won by Frank Owen.
Apologies - I didn't look carefully enough.

Glad to see we still won Torrington and with a bigger vote share - I don't think the Liberals ever polled above 40% in Torrington and the seat quickly reverted to the Tories in 1959 and moved further away from the Liberals in the 60s.

I would have thought the Labour vote would have collapsed in Torrington in 1958 in the ATL given the amount of Liberal activity in the prededing period.

To nitpick slightly, you had the Conservatives gaining Huyton but not gaining Rochdale at the ATL 1955 election which is slightly odd. The latter means no 1958 by-election so are we going to get Ludovic Kennedy into Parliament?
 
Apologies - I didn't look carefully enough.

Glad to see we still won Torrington and with a bigger vote share - I don't think the Liberals ever polled above 40% in Torrington and the seat quickly reverted to the Tories in 1959 and moved further away from the Liberals in the 60s.

I would have thought the Labour vote would have collapsed in Torrington in 1958 in the ATL given the amount of Liberal activity in the prededing period.

To nitpick slightly, you had the Conservatives gaining Huyton but not gaining Rochdale at the ATL 1955 election which is slightly odd. The latter means no 1958 by-election so are we going to get Ludovic Kennedy into Parliament?
I wanted Labour to keep most of their general election vote in Torrington. In the by-election in OTL they received 24.6% of the vote.

Huyton was a Conservative gain because I wanted Harold Wilson to lose his seat and have a different career path, and not as MP for a Merseyside constituency. Also perhaps a rising Labour star will win back Huyton in the next general election. Some constituencies which went Conservative in 1951 and 1955 in OTL, stayed Labour in 1955 in this TL, and Rochdale was one of them. Ludovic Kennedy might be the Liberal candidate in Rochdale in the next general election, as he was in 1959 in OTL. In the 1955 general election in this TL, the Liberals received about 25 percent of the vote in Rochdale, though in third place.
 
The composition of the House of Commons after the Torrington by-election was as follows (after 1955 general election):
Conservative and Unionist: 315 (319)
Labour: 290 (287)
Liberal: 23 (21)
Irish Nationalist: 1 (2)
Speaker: 1 (1)
-‐-------------------
Total: 630 (630)
----------------------

There were five by-elections on 12 June 1958 - three in Conservative seats and two in Labour seats. All were held by the party defending them. The Liberals came second in the Conservative seats. In Argyll the Conservative majority was reduced from 35.6% over Labour to 9.4% over Liberal. In Ealing South the Tory majority fell from 26.1% over Labour to 9.0% over Liberal. In Weston-super-Mare, the Tory majority over Liberal fell from 20.4% to 2.9%. Labour easily held their safe seats of Islington North and St. Helens. The Liberals came third in both constituencies.

There were by-elections in Chichester, and Morecambe and Lonsdale on 6 November 1958. Both were held by the Conservatives. In Chichestertheir majority dropped from 38.5% over Labour to 24.0% over Liberal. In Morecambe and Lonsdale the Tory majority fell from 36.1% over Labour to 12.4% over Liberal. Labour easily won the by-election in their very safe seat of Pontypool on 10 November 1958. The Liberals took over second place from the Tories. The Tory candidate lost his deposit.
 
In OTL, Harold Macmillan made Robert Boothby, the Conservative MP for Aberdeenshire East, a life peer. In this TL Rab Butler did not, because he did not want a by-election in Aberdeenshire East which the Conservatives could lose to the Liberals. In the 1955 general election the Conservative majority overLiberal was 14.7%.

In November 1958 Ian Harvey, who was Parliamentary Secretary to the Board of Trade and Conservative MP for Harrow East, was found in the bushes in St. James's Park in London with a 19 year old guardsman in the Coldstream Guards. Both men were arrested and charged with gross indecency and breach of the park regulations. Harvey resigned his ministerial post on 24 November and his parliamentary seat. At their trial on 10 December, the indecency charge was dropped. Both men were each fined £5. Harvey paid his co-defendent's fine. (1). Butler promoted Anthony Barber from the back benches to Parliamentary Secretary to the Board of Trade.

The Shoreditch and Finsbury by-election on 27 November 1958 was held by Labour. The Liberals replaced the Tories in second place.

On 20 January 1959, the composition of the House of Commons when MPs returned from the Christmas recess, was as follows:
Conservative and Unionist: 312
Labour: 290
Liberal: 23
Speaker: 1
Vacant: 4
--------------
Total: 630
---------------
(1) This was as in OTL. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ian_Harvey_(politician). However he had a different ministerial post in OTL.
 
Last edited:
Although Labour and Liberals combined had a majority of one over the Conservatives, the Labour MP for Penistone, Henry McGhee, would die on 6 February 1959, so presumably was too ill to vote. That means a vote of no confidence would be a tie, which would mean that the Speaker would give his casting vote in favour of the government, in accordance with parliamentary precedent.
 
In the Southend West by-election on 29 January 1959, the Conservative majority over Liberal fell from 26.1% to 9.8%. The Harrow East by-election on 19 March was a Labour gain from Conservative. But the Labour majority was only 2.9%. In the 1955 general election the Conservative majority was 6.4%. The swing of 4.65% from Conservative to Labour was considerably less than in by-elections over the previous three years or so. The Tories held Galloway in the by-election on 9 April. Their majority over Liberal fell from 27.9% to 15.3%.

The Penistone by-election took place on 11 June. This was won by Labour, but the swing from Conservative to Labour was 3.9%, with the Liberals in third place. A week later in the by-election in the Labour seat of Whitehaven, the swing from Conservative to Labour was 2.1% in a straight fight.

The electoral trend was definitely away from Labour and Liberal and towards the Tories. In July, August and September 1959, Gallup Polls showed a range from a 4 percent Labour lead over Conservative to a Conservative lead over Labour of 2.5%, and the Liberal voting intention was 16 to 19 percent, down from
an average of 26% in January to March 1959.

There was a lot of speculation in the press during the summer of 1959 that the Prime Minister, Rab Butler, would call an October general election. On 22 September, Butler made an official announcement to the press that Parliament would be dissolved on 2 October and a general election take place on 22 October 1959. The closing date for nominations was 12 October.
 
When all the votes had been counted in the general election, the Conservative and Unionist parties had a majority of two in the House of Commons. The number of seats for each party were as follows [after 1955 general election]:
Conservative and Unionist; 316 [319]
Labour: 295 [287]
Liberal: 19 [21]
[Irish Nationalist:2]
[ Speaker: 1]
---------------------
Total: 630 [630]
--------------------
The percentage votes for each party were as follows:
Conservative and Unionist: 40.3 [41.0]
Labour: 41.1 [40.5]
Liberal: 17.7 [17.2]
Others: 0.9 [1.3]
-------------------------
Total: 100.0 [100.0]
-------------------------
The turnout was 79.4 % [80.6%]
 
Last edited:
The number of votes for each party were as follows:
Conservative and Unionist: 11,326,499
Labour: 11,551,343
Liberal: 4,974,666
Others: 252,951.

Compared with the 1955 general election, Labour gained the following seats from Conservative: Buckingham, Clapham, Dulwich, Epping, Glasgow Woodside, Heywood and Royton, Huyton, Kingston upon Hull North, Lanark, Lowestoft, Norwich South, Renfrewshire West, Sunderland South, The Wrekin, Yarmouth. Total = 15. Labour gains from Liberal: Anglesey, Western Isles. The Speaker, James Milner, retired from the House of Commons, so Leeds South-East was nominally a Labour gain from the Speaker. Total Labour gains = 18.

The Tories gained these seats from: Bedfordshire South, Birmingham Sparkbrook, Brierley Hill, Bristol North-West, Dover, Ealing North, Holborn and St. Pancras South, Hornchurch, Middlesbrough West. Total =9. Tory gains from Liberal were Bedfordshire Mid, Bridlington, Caithness and Sutherland, Eye. Total = 4. Tory gains from Sinn Fein: Fermanagh and South Tyrone, Ulster Mid. Total Conservative gains = 15. Liberal gains from Conservative were Bodmin, Hereford, Torrington, Liberal gain from Labour: Rochdale.

Net gains and losses:
Labour: Net gain = 8
Conservative: Net loss = 3
Liberal: Net loss = 2
Sinn Fein lost 2 seats. The Speaker lost one seat.
 
John Maclay, the Minister of Education was the only cabinet minister to lose his seat - Renfrewshire West to Labour. However Geoffrey Rippon who was a minister in the 1959 to 1964 Conaervative government in OTL, lost Norwich Sputh to Labour, and Jim Prior, a future Conservative cabinet minister in OTL, was unsucessful in Lowestoft, unlike in OTL. Edward Heath gained Ealing North from Labour.

On the Labour side, Arthur Davidson was elected MP for Huyton instead of Harold Wilson in OTL, Michael Foot held Plymouth Devonport and Robert Maxwell gained Buckingham from the Tories. In OTL they were both defeated in those constituencies. Wilson was re-elected in Gateshead Wast.

Lady Megan Lloyd George was the most prominent Liberal defeated, losing Anglesey to Labour. Ludovic Kennedy gained Rochdale from Labour. Robin Day was unsucessful in Torquay. In OTL he was the Liberal candidate in Hereford. In this TL, Frank Owen who gained Hereford from the Tories in a by-election in February 1956, decided to stand in the general election, and was re-elected.
 
Rab Butler reshuffled his government because John Maclay, the Minister of Education had lost his seat, and Osbert Peake, the Lord Privy Seal and Leader of the House of Commons, and Florence Horsbrugh, the Minister of Health, did not stand for re-election to the House of Commons. Also other ministers resigned from the government. Cabinet
ministers on 26 October 1959 were follows [holder of post if different]:
Cabinet ministers:
Prime Minister: Richard Austen Butler
Lord Chancellor: Viscount Kilmuir
Lord President of the Council: Earl of Home [Marquess of Salisbury]
Lord Privy Seal and Leader of the House of Commons: Duncan Sandys [Osbert Peake]
Chancellor of the Exchequer: Harold Macmillan
Foreign Secretary: Harry Hopkinson [Earl of Home]
Home Secretary: Iain Macleod
Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food: Derek Heathcote Amery
Colonial Secretary: Alan Lennox-Boyd
Commonwealth Relations Secretary: Lord Carrington [Harry Hopkinson]
Minister of Defence: Geoffrey LLoyd
Minister of Education and Science: Frederick Erroll [John Maclay]
Minister of Housing, Local Government and Welsh Affairs: Robert Carr [Duncan Sandys]
Minister of Labour: Sir David Eccles
Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster: Earl of Selkirk
Paymaster-General: Lord Mills [Lord Carrington]
Minister of Power: John Hare
Secretary of State for Scotland: Thomas Galbraith
President of the Board of Trade: Reginald Maudling
To be continued.
 
Top