The Edelweiss Blooms: the Reign of Emperor Maximilian of Austria

All right, a lot of you probably seen me discuss the possibility of a TL where Maximilian is crowned Emperor of Austria after the assassination attempt on Franz Joseph succeeds, but thanks to my l33t procrastination skills, I unfortunately delayed making this TL for a long time. However, with PISOT2 coming up on the horizon, I finally decided to write this TL down and publish it on the site.

I know the "History Book" approach to writing ATLs is popular, and I initially wanted to write it like this, but I unfortunately found it difficult to write this in that fashion, so I had to fall back on the "Year XXXX: Event" format, but maybe I can revisit this in the future, when I finish this. :)

Of course, I'm not the greatest expert in this period, so constructive criticism is welcomed.

Part 1: Into the Valley of Death: Maximilian and the Russian War

1853: While walking on the battlements of Vienna with officer Maximilian O'Donell, Franz Joseph is assaulted by a Hungarian nationalist and ex-Hussar. He strikes Maximilian in the back with a knife, before being struck down by O'Donell's sabre. Despite this, Franz Joseph dies of his wounds later that afternoon, and his brother Maximilian is crowned Emperor of Austria.

One of the first pressing events that he must face is the Russian occupation of the Danube Principalities in July (ostensibly to protect the Orthodox holy sites there), prompting the Ottoman Empire to start fortifying the mouth of the Danube. The neutral European powers (Prussia, Austria, Britain and France) spearheaded by Maximilian attempt to prevent the tenuous relations between Russia and Turkey from becoming a full-scale war. However, these attempts fail, and within two weeks, the Russian War begins as the Turks cross the Danube River and the Russians sink several Turkish ships off the coast of Anatolia.

Maximilian and the other allies, though, do not declare war immediately, preferring to attempt to solve the crisis between the Russians and Turks peacefully, though this is largely fruitless. Maximilian attempts several financial reforms in order to fund the modernisation of the Austrian Army, as the Austrian government is deeply in debt at this time.

On a happier note, Maximilian meets Duchess Helene of Bavaria, who was slated to be Franz Joseph's bride before his assassination, and they agree to marry once the war is over.

1854: The Russian War begins in earnest as the Russians turn down an ultimatum to end the war in March. After months of preparation, the Allies spring into action. The Austrian Army pours into Moldavia, with elements assisting the Ottomans in attacking Wallachia. However, the Austrian advance is ground to a halt at the Siege of Iashi, although due to attacks elsewhere the Russians find increasingly difficult to relieve the Danube Principalities. Due to difficulties in Austrian training and logistics, Iasi becomes a bloodbath, with many soldiers succumbing to disease and cold. The remainder of the Austrian troops dig in.

Meanwhile, the British and French bombard Russian defences at Bomarsund, and Allied troops invade Sevastopol and the Crimean peninsula. Although this was expected to take approximately 3 months, it ends up lasting for several more months due to logistic difficulties.

1855: In April, Iashi finally falls to the Austrian forces, while most of Wallachia save for some cities on the coast fall to combined Austro-Ottoman forces later on in the summer. Due to the stretching out of Russian forces, Sevastopol falls in May.

1856: The Treaty of Paris ends the Russian War. In order to provide a buffer state in Eastern Europe between Russia and the Ottomans, Wallachia and Moldavia are joined to create the United Principalities under the rule of Rainer Ferdinand von Habsburg. Russia also pays a good amount of money to the Allied powers and Austria in particular.

However, the Allies learn many hard lessons about modern warfare, including the importance of logistics and sanitations. The Austrian General Staff agrees to start modernising the army as soon as possible.

In the months following the conclusion of the Russian War, Maximilian proceeds to introduce a number of liberal reforms, first and foremost the institution of universal public education across the Empire, with the emancipation of the Jews following.

1857: General peace in Austria reigns. Maximilian finally marries Duchess Helene of Bavaria.

With the war over, Maximilian continues paying off Austria’s debts and reforming Austria’s economy in order to make the aforementioned debt paying easier. In the meantime, he meets Georges-Eugene Haussmann and discusses the possibility of renovating Vienna like he did with Paris. Both agree to wait until at least the 1860s.

Maximilian also declares a Constitutional Monarchy in June, with most of his former power being in the power of an elected Diet. This is seen as being a major landmark in the liberalisation of Austria, and is later commemorated as Democracy Day.

In Wallachia-Moldavia, despite the relatively enlightened and progressive rule of Rainer Ferdinand, many still resent what they perceive as a Habsburg's absolute rule over Romanian land. Several protests (i.e. riots) break out, but as of yet, no major organised rebellion takes place.

1858: Maximilian makes several visits to France to discuss the possibility of a Franco-Austrian alliance with Napoleon III. Napoleon has his doubts, but is nonetheless relatively open to the concept. He also decides to visit Sardinia-Piedmont to meet with Cavour. However, Cavour is much less open to the idea of a Sardinian-Austrian alliance on account of the Austrian domination of Lombardy-Venetia. Despite granting local autonomy that basically made Lombardy-Venetia an independent nation in personal union with Austria and the enacting of liberal reforms, the region is still heavily influenced by Austria, and this does little to stop the high anti-Austrian sentiments in the area anyway.

As tensions between Italy and Austria runs high, Maximilian also oversees the continuing modernisation of the Austrian military, including the purchasing of several steamships, the gradual addition of newer, breechloading rifles, and the construction of several new armaments factories that produce the aforementioned weapons to a higher quality than before.

On a lighter note, the Austrian Diet passes a bill declaring “customary languages” to be of equal status in the Empire, though exactly what counts as a “customary language” is up to debate; at least Hungarian, Italian, and to a lesser extent, Czech are generally agreed to count as them.
 
Last edited:
Interesting, but I suggest you to change the identity of Maximilian's bride: Franz Joseph die to early for meet and fall in love with Elizabeth and thus is likely who Archduchess Sophie will have her desired niece as daughter-in-law, Duchess Helena of Bavaria (Sissi's elder sister and the original choice of Sophie) who surely will be a much better Empress than her sister
 
Last edited:
Ah. Helene was my original choice, but I went with Sisi since Helene was already engaged. I changed it now. :)

Helene's OTL engagement ITTL will never happen in any case because her OTL husband was considered not exactly suitable for her from the King of Bavaria and only Franz and Sisi's intervention (Helene's was a love wedding and they would like see her happy because were both close to her and feeling a little guilty because Franz had married Sisi instead of Helene) persuade the King to give his consent.
 

Razgriz 2K9

Banned
Haha, for a second there I thought that someone confused Alternate History with a Valkyria Chronicles fanfic.

Still, I find the idea of a "customary language" hard to implement in Europe. But I'll see where this goes, something tells me the Austrian Empire will become more federalized. I also find the deal with Austria fighting Russia to be a bit implausible on the account of Austrian troops being used to keep down the Hungarians and maintain martial law. Does Austria have any extra troops for the purpose of fighting the Russians in the Danubian Principalities?
 
Haha, for a second there I thought that someone confused Alternate History with a Valkyria Chronicles fanfic.

Huh. I looked Valkyria Chronicles on TV Tropes, and what do you know, there's an evil Prince Maximilian and an Edelweiss tank. Maybe there's an ASB TL in the works here. :p

Still, I find the idea of a "customary language" hard to implement in Europe. But I'll see where this goes, something tells me the Austrian Empire will become more federalized. I also find the deal with Austria fighting Russia to be a bit implausible on the account of Austrian troops being used to keep down the Hungarians and maintain martial law. Does Austria have any extra troops for the purpose of fighting the Russians in the Danubian Principalities?
  • The "customary language" was taken from an OTL act of the Austro-Hungarian Empire in 1867 that stated that all "customary languages" are equal.
  • It's implied that Austria was mobilising for war for months. But still, I may have to look into this a bit more. One of the reasons why the Danube Principalities fell so fast was on account of Russia's lines being stretched due to fighting the British and French in Crimea and the Austrians and Turks in Romania, which is also why Sevastopol fell earlier than OTL.
Also, I'm having troubles coming up with the history of Franco-Austrian relations: would Maximilian and Napoleon cooperate due to their liberal values and the rise of Prussia, or would they be enemies because of the inevitable conflict with Italy?
 
Last edited:

Razgriz 2K9

Banned
As a person who has explored a PoD at around the same time period (or rather the same decade), what I have to say is this.

Napoleon had always seen Austria as the bulwark against reconstructing Europe along Nationalist lines, pragmatically, he just wanted more influence in Italy, which was hard to pull off what with Austria directly controlling Lombardy-Venetia and having pro-Austrian rulers in Modena, Parma and Tuscany (ruled by relatives of the Hapsburgs...and the Bourbon-Parma).

With a liberal Austria...You might be able to placate the Italians to an extent, but trust me when I say that it will not last so long as Austria retains Lombardy-Venetia.

Now could France and a liberal Austria align together? Probably, if they were able to do so for Crimea, I think it would be able to survive for the rest of the of the mid-19th century or until Prussia is taken down a peg or two, whichever comes first.
 
Now could France and a liberal Austria align together? Probably, if they were able to do so for Crimea, I think it would be able to survive for the rest of the of the mid-19th century or until Prussia is taken down a peg or two, whichever comes first.

Two pegs :) : if you take down Prussia just one peg, it's still a potentially unifying menace, especially given the chance of a Prussian-Russian alliance if a Franco-Austrian entente frustrates ambitions to unify Germany under its rule.

Bruce
 
Two pegs :) : if you take down Prussia just one peg, it's still a potentially unifying menace, especially given the chance of a Prussian-Russian alliance if a Franco-Austrian entente frustrates ambitions to unify Germany under its rule.

Bruce

It might help A-H and France if Maximilian II of Bavaria lives longer. He was quiet pro-Austria.
 

Razgriz 2K9

Banned
Yeah, but even with a surviving Maximillian, I doubt Bavaria would be prepared to deal with the "mad" future king, Louis II.

Ironic character, Ludwig...despite running the Bavarian economy to the ground, he helped make Bavaria a popular tourist attraction.
 
Napoleon had thought up the idea of a kind of Italian federation: The pope as head of state, all states of the peninsula are members of it, and Austria joins the federation with its Italian parts - hence, Lombardo-Venetia. IOTL, Cavour's and Garibaldi's successes made the whole idea moot.
 
The Austrians maintained a 300.000 man army at russians border OTL, so they should be able to move TTL. Unfortunately this army further ruined Austrias economy - TTL I hope Austria gets some money out of Russia...

Helene is an excellent choice for Max.

Italy - if Austria and France are working together the Piemontese are not going to "unite" Italy - OTL the French saved Piemont in 1859 - and even in 1866 the Austrians were able to contain the Italians - until they were beaten by the Prussians. - Overall if Austria is in a little better shape than OTL they should be able to stand up to the Prussians.

Nice TL - it already has taken a different course than Zoidbergs - I will follow both...
 
The Austrians maintained a 300.000 man army at russians border OTL, so they should be able to move TTL. Unfortunately this army further ruined Austrias economy - TTL I hope Austria gets some money out of Russia...

Helene is an excellent choice for Max.

Italy - if Austria and France are working together the Piemontese are not going to "unite" Italy - OTL the French saved Piemont in 1859 - and even in 1866 the Austrians were able to contain the Italians - until they were beaten by the Prussians. - Overall if Austria is in a little better shape than OTL they should be able to stand up to the Prussians.

Nice TL - it already has taken a different course than Zoidbergs - I will follow both...

The problem with Italy is long term, basically the more A-H stay in Italy and more the only reward is getting another Hungary and another Serbia for the same price. Better try to play the nationalistic card and create a Kingdom of Italy, not be too greed and detach Lombardy - Venetia and with this Kingdom you have even a more workable access to the sea.
A-H must decide what want to be, hegemon of the German, premier player of the Balkans, overlord of Italy, she can be one of them plus some big influence in another but not all three as in this case she made enemies on all front and sooner or later luck run out.
You can set up an Italian kingdom, not an blatant puppet as otherwise none of the nationalist will bought the act (ca' niusciuno è fesso) and leave out the idea of the league it worked only in the mind of the diplomats, the Pope after the 48 was not a very beloved figure, better start with someone else but at least you get the best from a situation who soon will become unworkable. You can concentrate on the South German state, leaving the rest to Prussia (maybe sweetening the treaty with something) and in the Balkans realize that are not worth any of the problems and the diplomatic nightmares.
 
The problem with Italy is long term, basically the more A-H stay in Italy and more the only reward is getting another Hungary and another Serbia for the same price. Better try to play the nationalistic card and create a Kingdom of Italy, not be too greed and detach Lombardy - Venetia and with this Kingdom you have even a more workable access to the sea.
A-H must decide what want to be, hegemon of the German, premier player of the Balkans, overlord of Italy, she can be one of them plus some big influence in another but not all three as in this case she made enemies on all front and sooner or later luck run out.
You can set up an Italian kingdom, not an blatant puppet as otherwise none of the nationalist will bought the act (ca' niusciuno è fesso) and leave out the idea of the league it worked only in the mind of the diplomats, the Pope after the 48 was not a very beloved figure, better start with someone else but at least you get the best from a situation who soon will become unworkable. You can concentrate on the South German state, leaving the rest to Prussia (maybe sweetening the treaty with something) and in the Balkans realize that are not worth any of the problems and the diplomatic nightmares.

I think TTL Austria does not want to add Italian lands, I think the policy will be to keep it split up.

If France stays friendly to Austria it will not support Piemont thus Piemont will not be able to unite Italy. Maybe the Two Sicilies make an attempt ?

I am not sure if Austria will give up territory it holds without a defeat...

Germany will depend on Prussia - but I think PL did not give us info about Prussia.

THe BAlkans - well - we will have to wait

I am looking forwaard to more Infos :D
 
I think TTL Austria does not want to add Italian lands, I think the policy will be to keep it split up.

This is the problem, the split up had the days numbered as nationalism grow and grow, the more they try, the harder they suppress revolt and support 'their' monarch and more difficult the situation will become on the the long term.

If France stays friendly to Austria it will not support Piemont thus Piemont will not be able to unite Italy. Maybe the Two Sicilies make an attempt ?

Without Piedmont try to unify we can see a the various nationalists in Italy throw all their support towards the repubblicans of Mazzini, sure it will be a minor miracle if they succeed...but they can make the soujurn of the Austrian in Italy very interesting and not very pleasant. Regarding France, well any alliance will be short lived as that was the trend of the day, plus a Vienna-Paris axis mean that the British will try to support Prussia and the italian nationalist so to not make people in the continent too much confortable with the status quo.

I am not sure if Austria will give up territory it holds without a defeat...

Probably not, but this has been one of the main reason of the perennial diplomatic problem of A-H plus a big reason for Italy go away from the Triple alliance.
Maybe the new emperor can see the wisdom to give away something in the short time to obtain a long term advantage (and get rid of a lot of problem)
 
Where? Why? - want update NOW!

BTW - I think LD and me are constantly highlighting the Italian Question from the two relevant sides (me Austria - him Italy) - Basically I think we expect the same thing to happen - and it will not be nice - not OTL and not TTL.

:)
 
Top