The Economic Potential of Red Germany (1919)

stinnes_kpd1920.JPG


How awesomely sureal are these 20th century propoganda pics? :D

Anyway..

In a situation where Germany goes completely Red during the Sparticist Uprising, what would be the economic potential of this Rosa Luxemburg Led - KPD Communist Reich short term and Long Term?
 
Last edited:

Deleted member 1487

Frankly its utterly impossible for German to go communist unless invaded by the USSR, which doesn't yet exist. There was nowhere near enough support for communism in Germany.
 
Depend which borders they keep, if they keep 1914 sans A-L. they would be a great power and a superpower in alliance with soviet union, if not, like otl post war one, they will be pretty weak and would be toppled by the Stalthelm
 

RavenMM

Banned
Depend which borders they keep, if they keep 1914 sans A-L. they would be a great power and a superpower in alliance with soviet union, if not, like otl post war one, they will be pretty weak and would be toppled by the Stalthelm

you really think some parts in poland, where most area was lost, is so important? Or do you think about the occupied ruhr area?

But I agree, together with the USSR, communism has a chance. especially if it both countries link up.

I have no idea how communists would rise to power in germany, but I would totally read such a TL. Even if it'S a commi-wank ;)
 
you really think some parts in poland, where most area was lost, is so important? Or do you think about the occupied ruhr area?

But I agree, together with the USSR, communism has a chance. especially if it both countries link up.

I have no idea how communists would rise to power in germany, but I would totally read such a TL. Even if it'S a commi-wank ;)

Both, that leave the whole silesian basin vunerable and french neo-bonapartist didn't help too.

write it, would be fun.
 
you really think some parts in poland, where most area was lost, is so important? Or do you think about the occupied ruhr area?

But I agree, together with the USSR, communism has a chance. especially if it both countries link up.

I have no idea how communists would rise to power in germany, but I would totally read such a TL. Even if it'S a commi-wank ;)

Hmmm..

Red Germany TL: Rosa's Reich
 

Ryan

Donor
how long would Germany and the SU work together for? surely at some point one would try to dominate the other and it wouldn't be taken kindly.
 
how long would Germany and the SU work together for? surely at some point one would try to dominate the other and it wouldn't be taken kindly.

I'd almost imagine Rosa et. al establishing a 4th communist international to compete with Bolshevik dogma. Something she so fervently disagreed with.
 
Top