The Eagle Stumbles: A Spanish-American War TL

Through the end of the 19th century, tensions between the US and Spain were high. In a way, they were opposites; the United States was a rising star in the global community and was soon to have the largest economy of any nation, while the Kingdom of Spain's empire was crumbling and limited to a few relatively small bits and pieces of Africa, Asia, and the Caribbean.

Despite their differences, both powers had their eyes locked on the island of Cuba. The largest island in the Caribbean, Cuba had been a Spanish colony ever since the late 1400s. Lately, however, things were changing. Cuba was in open rebellion, and a growingly desparate Spanish military began using more drastic measures, reports of which appalled Americans.

History was made on February 15th, 1898, when the USS Maine, which was at the time in Havana, exploded for reasons which may never be known. Despite a lack of evidence, the US believed that Spain attacked the ship, and this led to Congress declaring a state of war on April 25. Despite the immediate wave of patriotism that fell over America, the American public had no idea that this would be the United States' first defeat to a foreign power.​
 
At sea pretty much impossible to arrange.

On land, if the estimated 5000 Spanish soldiers in the province the Americans landed in arrive to contest the landing, extremely simply to arrange.
 


History was made on February 15th, 1898, when the USS Maine, which was at the time in Havana, exploded for reasons which may never be known. Despite a lack of evidence, the US believed that Spain attacked the ship, and this led to Congress declaring a state of war on April 25. Despite the immediate wave of patriotism that fell over America, the American public had no idea that this would be the United States' first defeat to a foreign power.​

Very interesting! Of course, that foreign power might turn out not to be Spain...

Best Regards
Grey Wolf
 
A mild spoiler: TLL won't be limited to this puny war. I intend to stretch it all the way up to the present day. The butterflies will be numerous.;)

Next update will hopefully be today.
 
I remember watching on TV (the History Channel?) that the land war would have gone badly if the Spanish troops in Cuba had the new Maxim guns that the Spanish troops in Spain had.

If the US fleet obliterates the Spanish Navy and lands an army in Cuba and Puerto Rico that proceeds to be savaged by Spanish defenders and by disease, we might see some kind of compromise.
 
If the Rough Riders get annihilated would history be rewritten (ATL history I mean...so we're talking ATL historiography) to downplay the significance of the invasion as with the Bay of Pigs?

Best Regards
Grey Wolf
 
He'll stagger back to the boats, the sole survivor, his recovery from more than thirty bullet wounds alone ensuring his future fame.
 
Interesting. What would it do to American psychology to unequivocally lose a war at that point?

I look forward to more.
 
Interesting. What would it do to American psychology to unequivocally lose a war at that point?

I look forward to more.

Could go either way - some sort of Irredentism and repressed desire for Empire leading to more interventionist role in the Americas and elsewhere earlier, or alternatively a slide into total isolationism. I'm looking forward to finding out which. :D
 
Could go either way - some sort of Irredentism and repressed desire for Empire leading to more interventionist role in the Americas and elsewhere earlier, or alternatively a slide into total isolationism. I'm looking forward to finding out which. :D

I think than in the short range, the north-south fractures would be more important than the choice of empire/isolationism. The S-A war was a turning point of the reconciliation in the nation'ss imaginary, with constant (no doubt intentional) reports about northern and southern soldiers fighting together.

If they lose the war, that dissapears. Worse, should Spain make even one single sucessful naval raid, logic (and logistics) say than it will happen in a Southern city. Now instead of reconciliation we have southern cities burned by filthy furriners in a war started by northern politicians... let's hope it does not happen to Atlanta! (ahem... is Atlanta even on the coast?)
 
Top