alternatehistory.com

During the Third Anglo Dutch War, the Dutch re-captured New York, which they renamed New Orange, but the British took the Dutch colony of Suriname. At the Treaty of Westminster ending the war, the English and Dutch swapped the colonies and went back to the status quo ante.

As it happens, the Third Anglo-Dutch War was the last one between the countries until 1780.

What if the Dutch had kept the city we know as New York and the English had kept Suriname?
Top