CaliGuy
Banned
Some people here have previously made strong arguments that a Jewish state would have still been created in Palestine even either without a Holocaust or with a much smaller Holocaust. Thus, my question here is this:
What exactly would a Palestine partition have looked like in either a no-Holocaust scenario or in a much-smaller-Holocaust scenario? (For the record, the former can be achieved by killing Adolf Hitler in 1923--thus very likely completely butterflying away Nazi Germany--whereas the latter can be achieved by having France defend the Ardennes more in 1940 and thus having the Manstein Plan fail.)
Basically, I am curious about this since much more surviving Jews in Europe as well as the lack of Jewish worldview changes that occurred as a result of our TL's Holocaust could impact migration flows into Palestine, et cetera--thus resulting in somewhat different details of the Palestine partition in comparison to our TL.
Anyway, any thoughts on this?
What exactly would a Palestine partition have looked like in either a no-Holocaust scenario or in a much-smaller-Holocaust scenario? (For the record, the former can be achieved by killing Adolf Hitler in 1923--thus very likely completely butterflying away Nazi Germany--whereas the latter can be achieved by having France defend the Ardennes more in 1940 and thus having the Manstein Plan fail.)
Basically, I am curious about this since much more surviving Jews in Europe as well as the lack of Jewish worldview changes that occurred as a result of our TL's Holocaust could impact migration flows into Palestine, et cetera--thus resulting in somewhat different details of the Palestine partition in comparison to our TL.
Anyway, any thoughts on this?