The Czar's armies defeats the Bolsheviks

Bobbert

Banned
This scenario would only be possible if the Romonovs escaped before they were massacered and met up with the rest of the whit army. If this happened I beleive the White army would be able to regroup in the eastern/middle part of Russia where there could advance west and regain the major cities. Afterward there would likely be alot of reformation by the monarchy government.
 

Bobbert

Banned
COOK Im not talking about the october revolution

Im not talking about the october revolution. The romonovs were executed in july of 1918, the white army and the royalists(loyal to the czar) were trying to free him, but were too late.
 

Typo

Banned
They were pretty irrelevant anyway, the royalists wasn't that strong by that point anyway
 
This scenario would only be possible if the Romonovs escaped before they were massacered and met up with the rest of the whit army. If this happened I beleive the White army would be able to regroup in the eastern/middle part of Russia where there could advance west and regain the major cities. Afterward there would likely be alot of reformation by the monarchy government.

What do you base this assumption on? The possibility of the Russian monarchy being restored post March 1917 is next to nil.
 

Cook

Banned
What do you base this assumption on? The possibility of the Russian monarchy being restored post March 1917 is next to nil.

Which was entirely my point.

You can have the Provisional Government slugging it out with the Bolsheviks but the Romanovs had zero credibility with regard to either running the country or managing a war.
 
Which was entirely my point.

You can have the Provisional Government slugging it out with the Bolsheviks but the Romanovs had zero credibility with regard to either running the country or managing a war.

I agree w/you 100%; I was only asking Bobbert to explain scenario (as implausible and possibly ASB dependent as it may be).
 

The Vulture

Banned
So the presence of the tsar is enough to bring a White victory? Did not know Nicholas was such a powerful wizard.
 

yourworstnightmare

Banned
Donor
White victory is pretty ASB, and the more the Whites are tied to the Czar, the less support they'll get. The Romanovs were not in a position to make a comeback. Even if the White had won, they'd probably not be restored.
 
Top