The 3 Edwards

Say by some chance Edward V, the young 17th Earl of Warwick and Edward of Middleham survive to adulthood and have families of their own, might we see a Cousins' War 2.0 due to their rivalries (esp. Warwick and Middleham's due to their shared Neville inheritance)? After all, the three sons of York fell to bickering and squabbling amongst themselves (particularly Clarence vs. EIV and RicIII) almost as soon as the crown was in their family - a case of falling out amongst thieves.

What might the future hold for the three Edwards?
 
So much would depend on Bosworth.

If Richard III won then his son would become Prince of Wales.

But how could Richard have become king if any male off-spring of his elder brother was alive. If he was acting as the regent to Edward V then there would be no conflict and the king would take the reigns of power on his majority.

If Bosworth was lost I can see all three being driven into excile or killed by Henry VII to secure his throne.
 
So much would depend on Bosworth.

If Richard III won then his son would become Prince of Wales.

But how could Richard have become king if any male off-spring of his elder brother was alive. If he was acting as the regent to Edward V then there would be no conflict and the king would take the reigns of power on his majority.

If Bosworth was lost I can see all three being driven into excile or killed by Henry VII to secure his throne.

From what I can make out from the original post, the POD is seemingly Edward V never gets deposed by Richard III.

But by Bosworth Edward of Middleham was dead already. And seemingly, Richard used the Act of Attainder that had been passed against Clarence as an excuse to remove Warwick from the succession - although (AFAIK) the attainder passed on Clarence didn't prevent his kids from inheriting the crown.
 
Well, Edward of Middleham and the Earl of Warwick are definitely set for a collision course over the Neville inheritance. Not necessarily a violent collision, but at the very least there will probably be some legal wrangling. That said, given that Warwick will be the mentally-handicapped son of a traitor, whereas Middleham will be the son of a major lord, I expect this is one that Middleham will come off better on, unless e.g. the Woodvilles decide to use it as part of any conflict with Richard.

Depending on when Edward IV dies, if the Lancastrians/Tudors have some power, a loser in that struggle might consider intriguing with them, in lieu of full-fledged rebellion in their own right.
 
Top