Brainbin
Replying on this, as a fan of both series I think the difference is that with ST you have dramatically extended its duration, for the original series and also improved the quality. Even the 5th season TTL seems to be substantially better than the turd season of OTL.
With the Doctor you have removed two significant characters who each have prominent fan bases so there's bound to be some disquiet. Coupled with that adding what sounds like a very weak companion, although I hope Dale and Seymour would make a strong combination for the next stage. It would be a bit like re-casting a couple of the core cast of ST with different actors for reasons other than possibly death. True that is less likely in ST because, running for only 3 or 5 series there was no pressing need to replace the central characters but its the best comparison I can think of.
Don't you know the 1st rule when talking to the man with the glazed expression and big axe is never to upset him.
Steve
Making my decision to include Doctor Who as part of this timeline in hopes of drawing a larger audience was definitely a double-edged sword! One amusing anecdote in the eternal Star Trek vs. Doctor Who wars is that the good number of Star Trek fans who have been following this thread were far more receptive to the show's development ITTL. I'm not sure whether it's because of my very precisely chosen POD (all that's good and familiar about the OTL show, with virtually all changes made for the better, in as close a sense to objective as is possible), or whether it's because there's some intrinsic difference to the culture of Star Trek fandom.
Replying on this, as a fan of both series I think the difference is that with ST you have dramatically extended its duration, for the original series and also improved the quality. Even the 5th season TTL seems to be substantially better than the turd season of OTL.
With the Doctor you have removed two significant characters who each have prominent fan bases so there's bound to be some disquiet. Coupled with that adding what sounds like a very weak companion, although I hope Dale and Seymour would make a strong combination for the next stage. It would be a bit like re-casting a couple of the core cast of ST with different actors for reasons other than possibly death. True that is less likely in ST because, running for only 3 or 5 series there was no pressing need to replace the central characters but its the best comparison I can think of.
Why do you always advocate such violent solutions to problems?
Don't you know the 1st rule when talking to the man with the glazed expression and big axe is never to upset him.
Steve