alternatehistory.com

Constitutional Crisis

Way back in 1803, the United States Supreme Court decided Marbury vs. Madison on the basis that a law was unconstitutional, and its right to make that decision has been an integral part of the functioning of the United States government ever since. But this power is never explicitly given to the court…

What might happen in the court declares a law unconstitutional and Congress and the President decide to take action. Specifically, Congress passes (let’s say by a large majority) and the president signs a law specifically removing the court’s power to make such a declaration. I could see this happen if the court was almost entirely conservative, and Congress and the President almost entirely liberal, or vice-versa. It might be even more likely if the court makes a bad decision for political reasons on the bench, and/or it’s a close decision.

This is a constitutional crisis that I can’t see any good way to resolve—any ideas?

Clearly, this could happen any time from 1804 to the present. If anyone wants to use this in a timeline, please do.
Top