Argentina defeats Germany in quarter-final of 2006 World Cup. How Argentina fares against next opponent-Italy? And with Argentina advancing to best four I guess Pekerman is not fired? Under Pekerman would Argentinian national football team function better than IOTL? I'm pretty sure he'd be better in his job than Maradona was and would better use teams' potential.
@Ruperto Pesto
Argentina was a little bit superior than Germany in this QF, specially if you count that Germany was the host. Abbodanzieri's injure had - perhaps - a lot to do because he was a way better goalkeeper than Franco and a way better penalty stopper (e.g. Milan vs Boca in 2003). In OTL, Germany showed that the team had a not good enough physical fit, and Italy took note of that, that's why Manager Lippi put 3 strikers in the last 25 minutes: Gilardino, Iaquinta and Del Piero (in extra time), and paid off
One of the greatest what if of Argentina vs Germany in 2006, actually were three, was Juan Roman Riquelme being substituted by Esteban Cambiasso...and why Messi didn't come in instead of Julio Cruz (the image of Messi, like a sad, frustrated, little child in this match was unique)
Argentina in 2006 had one of their most equilibrated teams in the last 20 years... (perhaps Argentina in 1998 was the other one), one critic to Pekerman was that Zanetti wasn't call for this WC (and Maradona did the same...but well, Maradona was unpredictable...for good and for WORSE). So in my opinion, if Argentina would have reach semifinals, they would have been superior to Italy (perhaps 2-0...two goals by Riquelme -two free kicks - well, dreaming is for free)...and in the final, Argentina would prevail...
Pretty optimistic perhaps, but with reaching semifinals, would be enough to make pressure to Pekerman to stay. He wasn't fire, he quit... some say because after QF Grondona wanted to digitate him some names, that he wasn't agree with some things in AFA. But being into best 4 was enough to Pekerman to regain some power, and to stay.
For 2010, one thing is sure in ATL Pekerman...Argentina won't be defeated 4-0 by Germany, perhaps being Champions in Copa America 2007, and a way better path in WCQ...and probaby, because it depends of other factors, Argentina would be into best 4 this time in Africa. Let's see, Spain the OTL World Champions, did 8 goals in the tournament (Argentina in 1990 with all the injured players they had, and the negative tactics they used due this factors, did 5 goals and was heavy criticized), and was extremely luck not to loose with Paraguay in QF, who missed a penalty when match was 0-0...so thing could have been way different.
Well, perhaps I was very positive but that's my opinion