Slavs End up like tibetans and Germans end like Manchus and Mongolians

Slavs end up like tibetans and Germans end like Manchus and Mongolians, how is it possible for Germans to be majority Romance speaking or the North HRE becomes majority Romance speaking but in the present results in a germanic speaking rump state like mongolia the slavs became controled or puppets by Romance speakers like tibet, how is this possible?
 
Most of your POD is ASB. You need the Romans to conquer Germania to expect any hopes of a Vulgar Latin distinct to that region to develop.
 

Beer

Banned
Hi!
This would be only possible if the roman Empire could conquer all of Germania and hold it for a long time to dictate vulgar latin on the tribes. Considering the resistance the germanic tribes put up in OTL (and not only at Teutoburg Forest, but before and after too) Rome would need a truckload of butterflies.
Even the west/southwestern tribes under roman rule (ca. 300 years at max.) in OTL kept speaking mainly their germanic tongues, since there is no latinazation found in the oldest germanic records beyond loan words.
 
Hi!
This would be only possible if the roman Empire could conquer all of Germania and hold it for a long time to dictate vulgar latin on the tribes. Considering the resistance the germanic tribes put up in OTL (and not only at Teutoburg Forest, but before and after too) Rome would need a truckload of butterflies.
Even the west/southwestern tribes under roman rule (ca. 300 years at max.) in OTL kept speaking mainly their germanic tongues, since there is no latinazation found in the oldest germanic records beyond loan words.

The POD is during the time of charlemagne...
 
Top