Sixes and Snake eyes Rommel's luck in an alternate 1942 desert war

Status
Not open for further replies.
Sat down with tasty sandwiches for lunch, and had the welcome surprise of seeing an update. Welcome back! Good to see this active!
 
20 Auchinlek and Fellers Evac Cairo

cardcarrier

Banned
Chapter 20

6-12-42 23:59 hrs British 8th army and Middle East HQ Cairo Egypt Reporting back to American President Roosevelt and Joint Chiefs of Staff; Brig General Bonner Fellers, American military attache to MEGHQ and Pending Chief of Staff GSO1 to American Expeditionary Corps of Egypt

Urgent report and personal observations:

EVACUATION OF CAIRO GHQ BLOCKS HAS BEGUN!
due to incredibly chaotic security situation, reports and briefings are off schedule, will continue to report 2-3 times per day as necessary or ordered
will provide full update on status of British 8th army and forces in Egypt once our command convoy arrives in Suez
will provide full update on status of American military mission status once our command convoy arrives in Suez
deployment of American Expeditionary Corps will need to be completely re-evaluated due to loss of basing facilities in upper Egypt and collapse of internal order in Egypt. we will need additional Naval and Logistics officers to evaluate options along the Red Sea and their relevant potential lines of communication to the war fronts
General Smith has 110 armored vehicles and 8500 fresh infantry in Suez some of which have gradually formed a secure convoy corridor to evacuate the GHQ and our marooned piles of civilians that have wandered into the perimeter
Convoy vehicles are frequently pelted with rocks and sometimes bullets
Some of Auchinlek's final deep reserves arriving in Suez to help bolster security situation, some Royal Navy ships providing cannon cover. Suez is declared safely in British hands
Auchinlek has ordered army to disarm Egyptian Army and Civilians where necessary
Auchinlek has ordered all elements of operation Rapier such as they are within the army's power to execute to be done
Fast reaction group finds SANDBAGS not paratroopers at El Dabba (these where cleverly wrapped in Axis uniforms) this reaffirms our staffs previous observations that there is a major spy presence in GHQ and that all security measures and communications safeguards should be redoubled once we arrive in Suez
El Dabba fast reaction group heavily engaged by axis bombers
Vigorous air fighting over El Dabba, many axis planes shot down
Axis mobile columns explosively move forward trying to engage El Dabba reaction group
On Auchinlek's orders El Dabba group withdraws, utilizing mobile delaying tactics and remains in tact
British engineer sapper teams all along the Nile are ordered to be escorted by army manpower to the degree possible
Auchinlek orders special attention to be paid to the dams and sluices of the nile and the nile crossings/terminals, food stocks and water works, all along it's western most shores
Auchinlek orders all possible materials which might be valuable to Rommel west of the Nile to be destroyed, including food stocks, water works, fuel stockpiles and any remaining army materials
Royal Navy Rapier operations in Alexandria are largely complete, as much as 85 percent of the cities infrastructures are destroyed, and many of the remaining buildings are rigged with timed or booby trapped explosives
Hundreds of Royal Navy sappers, and army escorts have been killed or wounded in pitched battles with civilians/Egyptian army elements trying to delay Rapier
The above all portends for incredible hardships for the Egyptian civilian population, this factor according some staffers in private discussions causes Auchinlek and Lampson and London incredible political difficulties
Farouk is broadcasting on the radio nearly every hour, revoking the 1936 treaty, and calling for his entire population to rise up and remove all Europeans from Egypt, and listing the terrible damage wrought upon Alexandria. Smith and Auchinlek where able to get some scout cars near the Radio Cairo main exchange, but it is currently surrounded by an estimated 40,000 Egyptian Civilians, and would likely require a massacre to take back which they do not have the appetite for. Hundreds of thousands of Egyptian civilians from the outer suburbs have wondered into Cairo the last 36 hours to heed the King's message and there are 90,000+ civilians around the Abdeen Palace, which again would require a significant military massacre in order to reach Farouk
Security situation in Egypt's large cities (except Suez) is so dire that Auchinlek will likely require at least 3 additional corps of troops to regain domestic order, and another several divisions to make up for the laborer work previously done by Egyptians. Auchinlek's requests for manpower currently in place with London per a private disclosure by a staffer top 500,000 men, not accounting for future American troops
The above will be incredibly difficult to supply and stage until the port deployments are reorganized
Auchinlek for the first time admits that situation at Malta is now beyond recovery and that his battalions would be hard pressed to offer even token resistance given the fuel and food conditions on the Island. He is in discussions with London about how the Island's gallant citizens might be spared an invasion or more comprehensive starvation
Our own staff is in agreement that based on the 8th army's failures in Egypt, and the fleet evacuation that continued high risk and high loss runs to Malta can no longer be justified and that the Island is untenable
Auchinlek, with a heavy heart as instructed the 4 war divisions at Alamein to prepare to withdraw across the Nile, in best order. The security situation in their rear is too tenuous, which creates incredible risk of any breakthrough leading to their encirclement and loss. The 9th Australian division and the entirety of the Army's AAA assets, and many Desert Air Force Assets will be used to cover the army's retreat. Certain bridges across the Nile will be temporarily left standing to facilitate the army's withdrawal and then demolished in Rommel's face
Auchinlek intends to simultaneously restore order in the Eastern Half of Egypt, and gradually form a defensive front along the Eastern shores of the Nile
Rommel is known by intelligence to not have much bridging equipment and no army could so breathlessly hop from Gazala to the Nile without a long pause to bring forward the structures of their army and air force
Auchinlek is hopeful that for the incredibly heavy price of Rapier that Rommel will become marooned on his side of the Nile, and will have to detach most of his forces to maintain some semblence of internal order in his own sectors and become vulnerable to being counter attacked, there will be plenty of angry Egyptians in his own rear areas.... Farouk's addresses have been directed at ALL Europeans which would include the Africa Corps and the Italians as much as it does the British

End Transmission
 
Chapter 20

6-12-42 23:59 hrs British 8th army and Middle East HQ Cairo Egypt Reporting back to American President Roosevelt and Joint Chiefs of Staff; Brig General Bonner Fellers, American military attache to MEGHQ and Pending Chief of Staff GSO1 to American Expeditionary Corps of Egypt

Urgent report and personal observations:

EVACUATION OF CAIRO GHQ BLOCKS HAS BEGUN!
due to incredibly chaotic security situation, reports and briefings are off schedule, will continue to report 2-3 times per day as necessary or ordered
will provide full update on status of British 8th army and forces in Egypt once our command convoy arrives in Suez
will provide full update on status of American military mission status once our command convoy arrives in Suez
deployment of American Expeditionary Corps will need to be completely re-evaluated due to loss of basing facilities in upper Egypt and collapse of internal order in Egypt. we will need additional Naval and Logistics officers to evaluate options along the Red Sea and their relevant potential lines of communication to the war fronts
General Smith has 110 armored vehicles and 8500 fresh infantry in Suez some of which have gradually formed a secure convoy corridor to evacuate the GHQ and our marooned piles of civilians that have wandered into the perimeter
Convoy vehicles are frequently pelted with rocks and sometimes bullets
Some of Auchinlek's final deep reserves arriving in Suez to help bolster security situation, some Royal Navy ships providing cannon cover. Suez is declared safely in British hands
Auchinlek has ordered army to disarm Egyptian Army and Civilians where necessary
Auchinlek has ordered all elements of operation Rapier such as they are within the army's power to execute to be done
Fast reaction group finds SANDBAGS not paratroopers at El Dabba (these where cleverly wrapped in Axis uniforms) this reaffirms our staffs previous observations that there is a major spy presence in GHQ and that all security measures and communications safeguards should be redoubled once we arrive in Suez
El Dabba fast reaction group heavily engaged by axis bombers
Vigorous air fighting over El Dabba, many axis planes shot down
Axis mobile columns explosively move forward trying to engage El Dabba reaction group
On Auchinlek's orders El Dabba group withdraws, utilizing mobile delaying tactics and remains in tact
British engineer sapper teams all along the Nile are ordered to be escorted by army manpower to the degree possible
Auchinlek orders special attention to be paid to the dams and sluices of the nile and the nile crossings/terminals, food stocks and water works, all along it's western most shores
Auchinlek orders all possible materials which might be valuable to Rommel west of the Nile to be destroyed, including food stocks, water works, fuel stockpiles and any remaining army materials
Royal Navy Rapier operations in Alexandria are largely complete, as much as 85 percent of the cities infrastructures are destroyed, and many of the remaining buildings are rigged with timed or booby trapped explosives
Hundreds of Royal Navy sappers, and army escorts have been killed or wounded in pitched battles with civilians/Egyptian army elements trying to delay Rapier
The above all portends for incredible hardships for the Egyptian civilian population, this factor according some staffers in private discussions causes Auchinlek and Lampson and London incredible political difficulties
Farouk is broadcasting on the radio nearly every hour, revoking the 1936 treaty, and calling for his entire population to rise up and remove all Europeans from Egypt, and listing the terrible damage wrought upon Alexandria. Smith and Auchinlek where able to get some scout cars near the Radio Cairo main exchange, but it is currently surrounded by an estimated 40,000 Egyptian Civilians, and would likely require a massacre to take back which they do not have the appetite for. Hundreds of thousands of Egyptian civilians from the outer suburbs have wondered into Cairo the last 36 hours to heed the King's message and there are 90,000+ civilians around the Abdeen Palace, which again would require a significant military massacre in order to reach Farouk
Security situation in Egypt's large cities (except Suez) is so dire that Auchinlek will likely require at least 3 additional corps of troops to regain domestic order, and another several divisions to make up for the laborer work previously done by Egyptians. Auchinlek's requests for manpower currently in place with London per a private disclosure by a staffer top 500,000 men, not accounting for future American troops
The above will be incredibly difficult to supply and stage until the port deployments are reorganized
Auchinlek for the first time admits that situation at Malta is now beyond recovery and that his battalions would be hard pressed to offer even token resistance given the fuel and food conditions on the Island. He is in discussions with London about how the Island's gallant citizens might be spared an invasion or more comprehensive starvation
Our own staff is in agreement that based on the 8th army's failures in Egypt, and the fleet evacuation that continued high risk and high loss runs to Malta can no longer be justified and that the Island is untenable
Auchinlek, with a heavy heart as instructed the 4 war divisions at Alamein to prepare to withdraw across the Nile, in best order. The security situation in their rear is too tenuous, which creates incredible risk of any breakthrough leading to their encirclement and loss. The 9th Australian division and the entirety of the Army's AAA assets, and many Desert Air Force Assets will be used to cover the army's retreat. Certain bridges across the Nile will be temporarily left standing to facilitate the army's withdrawal and then demolished in Rommel's face
Auchinlek intends to simultaneously restore order in the Eastern Half of Egypt, and gradually form a defensive front along the Eastern shores of the Nile
Rommel is known by intelligence to not have much bridging equipment and no army could so breathlessly hop from Gazala to the Nile without a long pause to bring forward the structures of their army and air force
Auchinlek is hopeful that for the incredibly heavy price of Rapier that Rommel will become marooned on his side of the Nile, and will have to detach most of his forces to maintain some semblence of internal order in his own sectors and become vulnerable to being counter attacked, there will be plenty of angry Egyptians in his own rear areas.... Farouk's addresses have been directed at ALL Europeans which would include the Africa Corps and the Italians as much as it does the British

End Transmission
All the destructions of Rapier, specially of food stocks and water works could mean the death of many 100s thousands and even millions of Egyptians for which the Axis don't have neither the resources nor will to save.

I doubt very much that this type of measures under the same conditions would be carried in Britain for the sake of "humanity". But in Egypt there is no such qualms. I think this will be remembered as one of allies war crimes.
 

Satrap

Donor
All the destructions of Rapier, specially of food stocks and water works could mean the death of many 100s thousands and even millions of Egyptians for which the Axis don't have neither the resources nor will to save.

I doubt very much that this type of measures under the same conditions would be carried in Britain for the sake of "humanity". But in Egypt there is no such qualms. I think this will be remembered as one of allies war crimes.
It could likely instigate a revolt across the entire Arab world
 
All the destructions of Rapier, specially of food stocks and water works could mean the death of many 100s thousands and even millions of Egyptians for which the Axis don't have neither the resources nor will to save.

I doubt very much that this type of measures under the same conditions would be carried in Britain for the sake of "humanity". But in Egypt there is no such qualms. I think this will be remembered as one of allies war crimes.
and very likely will have long term consequences
It could likely instigate a revolt across the entire Arab world

Well this alongside the United Nations Partition Plan for Palestine will be a double whammy for West and Arab relations with the Americans being the only ones left to diplomatically salvage anything.

Reparations will have to be paid post-war but pictures of starving Egyptians will likely be printed on the History books of WW2 and tarnished the image of the British Empire during the war, let's not forget of the other British related failures that led to the Bengal famine of 1943.

The Arab world will likely be more firm in the grip of Eastern bloc influence during the Cold War if the Americans fail to leave a good lasting image for the coming humanitarian crisis.
 
i wonder if a point comes where the americans will say this is enough atrocities. and destroying waterworks etc under the rapier plan does sound like a massive violation of the Geneva convention.

a remark of Gen Fellers in one of his dispatches comparing the brits with the Germans (or even saying that they are behaving worse like them) would be interesting, and of course Rommel's comment when he reads it.
 

kham_coc

Banned
i wonder if a point comes where the americans will say this is enough atrocities. and destroying waterworks etc under the rapier plan does sound like a massive violation of the Geneva convention.

a remark of Gen Fellers in one of his dispatches comparing the brits with the Germans (or even saying that they are behaving worse like them) would be interesting, and of course Rommel's comment when he reads it.
Personally I think this should mean the end of US interest in Egypt - retaking it doesn't seem to serve any strategic interest, Malta will fall, it won't be a viable springboard for further advances for either side, and it saves hugely on political capital.
 

kham_coc

Banned
Reparations will have to be paid post-war but pictures of starving Egyptians will likely be printed on the History books of WW2 and tarnished the image of the British Empire during the war, let's not forget of the other British related failures that led to the Bengal famine of 1943.
I think the opposite, just like the bengal famines have been airbrushed out of general knowledge so will this.
 
pictures of starving Egyptians will likely be printed on the History books of WW2 and tarnished the image of the British Empire during the war, let's not forget of the other British related failures that led to the Bengal famine of 1943.
Don't count on it. Outside India, unless someone goes searching for it not many people have heard of the bengal famine and the role the Empire played during WWII to cause it and Churchill's callous disregard of it. I'm talking the kind of people who don't visit sites like this which is 99% of the population. It is something which has faded into history and isn't what comes to a normal person's mind when asked about Churchill's role during WW2.

But in this thread's context simply because a rioting population is affecting the British directly and may lead to them losing Egypt in its entirety, it'll be dissected inn military academies and historians for decades to come.
 

cardcarrier

Banned
i wonder if a point comes where the americans will say this is enough atrocities. and destroying waterworks etc under the rapier plan does sound like a massive violation of the Geneva convention.

a remark of Gen Fellers in one of his dispatches comparing the brits with the Germans (or even saying that they are behaving worse like them) would be interesting, and of course Rommel's comment when he reads it.
that has come up earlier in the thread in chapter 17

"Our staff ended up in an unfortunate heated exchange with general Smith when I asked him about their plans to deal with Egyptian civilians who become refugees as a result of rapier or heavy fighting in their cities. He asked me if I was familiar with Operation Alberich from the great war, to which I replied that I only knew of it in passing because I hadn't graduated the military academy until 1918; he explained how the Germans had scorched earth many kilometers of the French countryside in the most diabolical of ways, and thrust the many refugees they created into the French lines of advance, letting the mass of human suffering be it's own roadblock, which lead to their eventual heavy defeat at the second battle of the Aisne. When I asked, inferring that meant his plan was to destroy the way of life of the Egyptians on the nile and then thrust them into Rommel's arms as a roadblock he became the most heated I have ever seen him and kicked our staff out of the building screaming that Rapier wasn't his idea, blaming the Navy and London for being ignorant of ground fighting and local conditions in Egypt. There could hardly be a man in GHQ or an Egyptian outside within a city block who didn't hear him"

that and Fellers earlier reports/recommendations against Rapier where the underpinning for Marshal to order Fellers to not allow any American military members to participate in any way with Rapier
 

cardcarrier

Banned
Personally I think this should mean the end of US interest in Egypt - retaking it doesn't seem to serve any strategic interest, Malta will fall, it won't be a viable springboard for further advances for either side, and it saves hugely on political capital.
in hindsight we know that completely, but given that the Soviets where just crushed at Kharkov, have Sevastopol actively collapsing and will shortly have grave difficulties in front of Paulus/Kliest initial advances, they are merely a few weeks away from Stalin's demand of Churchill that 30 allied divisions be sent to his southern front. Attache reports where very negative in the face of case blue, the possibility of a Russian collapse (which we know was never close) was regarded as a significant possibility; Fellers superiors would want to ensure the permanent long term security of the lend lease supply lines to Russia via Persia, and even if hindsight it would be nonsense, they and their British partners took Rommel seriously enough where they wouldn't leave him to wither on the vine
 
20.1 Eppler captured

cardcarrier

Banned
Chapter 20.1

6-12-42 23:59 hrs Cairo Egypt Houseboat #61 on the Nile Operation Salaam Abwehr Secret Agent Johannes Eppler

Eppler was in mortal fear for his life. He had heard the King's address the same as the rest of Cairo, and a number of houseboats had been burned by furious Egyptian civilians in the past 48 hours, as they where popular rentals with middle ranking GHQ officers.

The thought of being burned, beaten or shot by Egyptians was only one of at least 4 on going threats to his life, number 2 as he noted for at least the last 72 hours was that he and his partner where being shadowed by one of Lieutenant Saddat's younger brothers, and other Egyptian military members. They all seemed armed merely waiting for the order to board his boat and arrest or shoot him

The third threat to his life was from British security agents who had been sniffing around him for at least the last week and a half, egged on by his parades of prostitutes and lavishing spending of his abwehr cash. This had died down when some of the sweeps where curtailed at Ritchie's relief, but they where heavily interested in spies again, and Eppler was sticking out far too much.

The final threat was from his masters, Rommel and Seebohme; after giving Sadat the information on Rapier, Eppler had been drunk 25 hours a day and on top of a prostitute for 26, but in trying to extend his life had occasionally sent messages saying he was safe, trying to stay undercover, and working sympathetic local sources. He had seen Seebohme's face up close, the man was the truest of true believers in Hitler's Reich, he would quickly find out what Eppler had done, if he didn't know already; for all Eppler knew Sadat was separately communicating with Seebohme now, but it was certain in Eppler's mind, if Seebohme at Rommel's vanguard reached Cairo he would easily track him down and line him up against the nearest wall and shoot him like a dog

The options before Eppler where extraordinarily unappealing:
1. He could remain in Cairo and try to continue hiding, which left him with at least 3 of his 4 possible executioners in play, since the British seemed to be preparing to withdraw
2. He could try to make his way North and West to return to Rommel and Seebohme, but could get shot by furious Egyptian Civilians on the way, discovered by retreating British army formations and quite possibly be welcomed back by Seebohme with a 9mm barrel to the temple
3. He could try relocating to the east or south with British units, and away from the explosive Egyptian population, but he had largely consumed his cash reserves, and it would be difficult to set up another safe house now that the British and Egyptians where on high alert
4. He could go turn himself in to the British before they left town and they would hopefully take him, with them under armed escort, and keep him alive in return for information

A boat tied up, 3 units down from him went up in flames, and that became his last straw to act

Eppler through an incredible haze of scotch looked out the window waiting until Sadat's brother was momentarily distracted taking a smoke break, disembarked off his houseboat, in an appropriated British Army Leftenant's uniform and maneuvered along the back alleys and streets of Cairo that he knew from his youth. He pushed on keeping away from any crowds of Egyptian Civilians who would beat a lone man to death tonight, and got to the Imperial Gardens District, where the entirety of the GHQ and many European's living in Egypt where rapidly packing up for a great trek to the east. Eppler thrust himself to the closest guard post, held down by nervous infantry backed up by armored cars and a tank, demanding to speak to the commander of the perimeter guard, and then telling the surprised Captain that he was a German spy, on the personal payroll of Rommel, and demanding to be taken to the GHQ chief of intelligence as soon as possible; he was brought into the perimeter, under heavy guard, with 3 loaded Webley's trained on him at all times
 
21 fellers darkest day

cardcarrier

Banned
Chapter 21

6-13-42 23:59 hrs British 8th army and Middle East HQ Suez Egypt Reporting back to American President Roosevelt and Joint Chiefs of Staff; Brig General Bonner Fellers, American military attache to MEGHQ and Pending Chief of Staff GSO1 to American Expeditionary Corps of Egypt
Report sent via US ARMY CIPHER SYSTEM (UNBREAKABLE)

Urgent update and personal obserations:

A high ranking Nazi spy on Rommel's payroll turned himself in to British authorities yesterday as we were evacuating!
Spy turned over all of his transmission logs with corresponding dates, including his coding system back to his handlers with Rommel's headquarters
His logs, along with our previous reviews and concerns, along with cross checking with our allies confirm axis penetration of code black systems!
We recommend all USA assets, military and civilian immediately transition off of code black system
We advise all USA intelligence, military and government assets evaluate any transmissions sent on code black since at least February 1942 as extensively penetrated by axis agents
All attache/GSO1 reports for now will be sent via US Army Cipher until further instructions are provided
The spy claims to not know of any other spies on Rommel's payroll, but it stands to reason they are like rats or cockroaches, Auchinlek has vowed to redouble security efforts in conjunction with stabilizing security situation in Egypt
Auchinlek is ordering extensive changes to 8th army, GHQ, and Desert Air Force radio security procedures going forward
Captured spy knew of Rapier and spread it to Egyptian Army Officers who where sympathetic to the axis, who in turn likely leaked it to Farouk's court, (although based on the chaos and smoky atmosphere at GHQ, this could have leaked from a number of parallel directions
Spy claims that those same army officers where stalking him, preparing for his execution
This spy was being sniffed at by local British security services since at least June 1st; our own intelligence agents and British agents consider his confessions so far to be legitimate
Auchinlek has vowed to make no more use of any Egyptian laborers or servants. He is also issuing a permanent order that officers may no longer visit Egyptian bars clubs and brothels going forward, to avoid loose lips in the presence of Rommel's ears
USA and main GHQ convoys have safely arrived in Suez
We are still reorienting our staff, all senior attache staff are accounted for, Auchinlek is securing a significant amount of office space inside the military port area for our group. Oswald is seeing to acquiring more space in Port Sudan
8th army GHQ staff nearly to a man is extraordinarily shaken
Baxter and Oswald are beginning the staff study of how to now properly deploy the American Air and Army forces to defeat Rommel in light of the great strategic shifts that have been occurring;
Baxter advises that previous schemes to bomb Tripoli from Egypt are no longer viable due to the loss of the base structures in the delta, increasing ranges and reducing directions which won't encounter substantial fighter opposition; Rommel now that he is so deep in to Egypt will likely no longer use Tripoli as his main staging base anyway, this will likely shift to Bengahzi and Tobruk supplemented by whatever small piers he has taken along the Egyptian coast and some of the small fishing villages on the frontier
Bengahzi and Toburk are in range of our bombers once they can be properly deployed and have their stockpiles safely amassed
Rommel's columns are less than 110 miles from alexandria and less than 25 miles from the Alamein line per air recon and contacts with Auchinlek's recon forces
There are still huge ongoing domestic disturbances throughout Egypt, especially in the large cities (except Suez); air bases around Port Said, and other points along the canal (except the Suez perimeter itself) are frequently being targeted by massed throngs of Egyptian Civilians and some elements of their military, equipped with pilfered British weapons
There is some possibility that Egyptian laborers in the service of the British army had diverted some weapon shipments intended for the Alamein line specifically to fight rapier, they have utilized some mortars and machine guns against British patrols, bases, depots and European civilians living in Egypt; based on the conditions with the spy and other leaks, this may have been going on for 10 days or perhaps longer
Oswald's current middle case assessment is that Rommel has the fuel to move his entire army such as it is known now to the Delta, since he hasn't had to maneuver off the high way much and has been seen utilizing some of the intact parts of the desert rail road between Tobruk and Sollum; rapier has seen to all the rail line inside of Egypt itself, as far back as the nile
Our own staff in partnership with GHQ is going to assess divisions presumed to be in Axis reserve, there is mixed opinion that once Rommel reaches the Nile that axis will release additional divisions to Rommel for internal security purposes and to stiffen his drive to Cairo and the Canal in conjunction with other Axis movements in South Russia
Because of Rommel's penetration of code black, he has maintained detailed knowledge of British armored strength and deployments
It is very likely that due to Rommel's spy insights into GHQ that he has been successfully able to mask his true armored strength and maneuver intentions, at least since the second battle of El Aghelia
It should be properly assessed and regarded that despite Farouk's calls to get every European out of Egypt, that there are significant elements of his army and civilian population who are hearing the radio Berlin broadcasts and familiar with the current difficulties of the ground war, and are or have become sympathetic to the axis, and would likely be willing to provide material support to Rommel as he penetrates into the civilian population centers
The potential of Rommel receiving additional reinforcements should be balanced against his known constraints of fuel and other items of supply, which even if Tripoli is now largely secure for him remain difficult for the forces he already has
The ability of the Egyptian population to provide material support to Rommel plus anything left behind or omitted by Rapier may also affect our considerations for him to receive and utilize reinforcements
Oswald estimates that Rommel will need a minimum of 8 weeks to rest and rebuild his army once he reaches the nile assuming minimal losses as the 8th army withdraws
Our assessment is that by that time, in conjunction with the arrival of fresh British and USA troops the 8th army would outnumber Rommel by a factor of at least 3 to 1 in men and 4 to 1 in armor; assuming he reinforces as fast as he did in March and April
The incredible flooding inflicted on the delta by Rapier has and is turning the Nile into a massive obstacle, Auchinlek's withdrawal, intact behind it will represent a powerful defensive position; but in turn should Rommel remain on the defensive it will serve the same purpose for him as well; creative maneuvers may be require to circumvent that once the 8th army gains the initiative
The desert air force would be making more runs on Rommel's columns but many of their facilities are under siege or have been evacuated in the face of rampaging Egyptians and relocated to the overcrowded Suez area
Oswalds middle case estimate is that Rommel still has 100-140 German tanks and 200-250 Italian tanks still operating and that his army with it's replacements is 65-85k men strong; Baxter advises that Rommel has received a number of air squadron reinforcements but that a full assessment is still a few days away; he thinks Rommel may have stood down some squadrons for rest after the hectic fighting over Gazala and Toburk.
The Axis have set up and advanced air strip at El Dabbah per recon flights late this afternoon, this gives them their first true potential to bomb the canal zone from Egyptian bases, instead of bombing it from Crete
Once the axis set up air strips closer or within Alexandria, those strikes against the canal zone can be escorted by fighters with fuel drop tanks; this would greatly complicate any future attempts to provide seaborne supply convoys to Malta from our area of Operations or to stage Royal Navy Submarines into the theater
Chaos of rampaging Egyptian civilians renders the canal unusable for now anyway, but there is a significant medium term risk there from the axis air forces in terms of bombing and observation
Rommel's future intentions are not known, in that sense that once he feels himself ready for an offensive, if he would strike south towards Cairo, looking to scoop up the jewel of Britain's presence on the Nile, or if he would try to cross the many water ways of the Nile and drive east towards Port Said and get at the Suez Canal itself; Rommel's spy claims to not know any of his offensive plans after he reached
Auchinlek has set requests to ICGS asking for London's preferred defensive priorities in regards to this, pending his getting the boiling domestic turmoil in Egypt under control
Auchinlek and Smith have been working many hours under grave circumstances the last 96 hours, they appear completely exhausted
GHQ rumors are that London is going to whole sale replace the command structure of the 8th army once the front stabilizes and the entaglements with the civilian population are ended
Rapier is still ongoing, against fanatical resistance by the Egyptian public and it's army, there are pitched gun battles and even hand to hand fighting all along the Nile. There are 10s perhaps hundreds of thousands of refugees streaming out of Alexandria and Cairo, the whole country is moving about progressively becoming more armed and certainly more blood thirsty.
Radio Berlin propaganda and certain other propagandas fueled by the axis (per our previous reports) have fueled a certain amount of shocking violent tendancies, as were seen in the riots in Cairo the last 72 hours, the entire Jewish quarter was burned, and many hundreds of Jews, just as much as British soldiers where yanked into the streets and beaten up or in some cases lined up against walls and shot, nothing Farouk has broadcast does anything to cool these tempers
Those tempers are being fueled in mosques throughout the country, but especially in Cairo with leaflets saying that the British and the Jews are burning mosques in palestine, and slaughtering Arab women and children
In one of Farouk's later broadcasts tonight he advised that the government of Egypt was going to nationalize and confiscate all the holdings of the Suez Canal company and all British/Commonwealth investments in Egypt as just compensation for Rapier. He called upon the Egyptian nation to confiscate the Canal in it's totality by force and to block any further British destruction of infrastructures on the Nile
Trying to discuss that matter with Smith or Auchinlek was impossible, they simply said it's a matter for the Navy and London for now until they can get more troops deployed
Whole rapier parties are being over-run and killed by furious Egyptian civilians along the nile per GHQ private staffer conversations, the troops suffer savage beatings, typically having their legs smashed and there have even been some reports that they are being tied up and tossed to Nile Crocodiles
This disruption and indeed heavy losses to much of Auchinlek's rear support structures are in their own way more damaging than what happened to his army at Belhamed, it will take the 8th army a long time to be strong to the core again, even under new leadership
I tied asking Smith if the possibility of Rommel raising arab/Egyptian legions for his army has been seriously considered, particularly since he will now control some population centers and that British prestige in the region has taken a hit
Smith advised that, that could present grave difficulties and that it was essential to drive Rommel back as soon as possible
There was a long heated meeting about Malta this evening, the Navy says they have no viable way to evacuate the battalions or any substantial part of the civilian population off the island with the loss of the Delta fleet base and the projection Rommel's air force
The navy was even more furious about the spy issues than the army or air force believing that they have lost many ships in the face of their sailings being disclosed
Their recommendation in light of the prospect of mass starvation on the is to try to make an arrangement with the government of Turkey to take custody of the island for the remainder of the war, if that can be arranged with the British and Axis ambassadors in Ankara, direct negotiation/handing the islands over to the Italians to ease the starvation is forbidden by London
The previous prospect of the long rumored operation Herkules is probably less than it was in the spring per our own assessments and GHQ, Rommel has received a lot of the forces we had identified as being labeled for that attack, and with Rommel being on the cusp of taking Alexandria, the Island's ability to dominate his lines of relevant supply is gone; a number of GHQ staffers and Royal Navy staffers believe the Turkish solution would be agreeable to all sides and would let all parties focus their efforts on the current issues at hand; or in the words of Admiral Harwood tonight, the citizens of Malta have endured 15,000 axis bombing sorties, they do not deserve to starve to death

end transmission
 
Glad to see this back. Is the revelation that code Black is broken as OTL? How again can they ascertain that it is broken from the spy? He gave little usefull information and rapier had many possible leaks?
 

kham_coc

Banned
I can't see how the Turkish solution would be acceptable to the Italians, they after all regard it as Italian and they know the futility of resistance. So Londons hope of avoiding another high profile failure seems forlorn.
 
of course the moment they get a message with a non-breakable code (for now) they know that something is up, and combine it with the non-contact of their spy can probably add up to the correct conclusion.
 

cardcarrier

Banned
Glad to see this back. Is the revelation that code Black is broken as OTL? How again can they ascertain that it is broken from the spy? He gave little usefull information and rapier had many possible leaks?
by date it's otl; it was extraordinarily controversial inside American circles because other attache's (not just Fellers) thought the British had cracked code black themselves and where comparing possible leaks from it against ultra (or other sources of intelligence) to see if the Americans where a security problem. the british discovered fellers leaks by via ultra disclosures about "good source in cairo" and Rommel/Luftwaffe being in the right place at the right time too many times, especially with the destruction of the Operation Julius convoys to Malta; for our purposes Eppler adds to a small degree what was already happening in Fellers/Auchinlek's circles anyway, they knew there
was a leak and they found it 6-12/6-15

Fellers himself was convinced as early as February that he was compromised and repeated that complaint to his superiors again in May, and was told to piss off, and continue using code black. Fellers unfortunately as we have discussed above took his war experiences to the grave, so it's unknown what triggered his complaints to his superiors; my best guess based on the blowback in the attache community about black being compromised and the tense conversations between Roosevelt and Churchill is that Fellers got tipped off by a British source in GHQ that they had or where close to penetrating code black and that the US should change codes

Churchill swore to Roosevelt on a stack of bibles soon after Fellers first round of complaints in February that the British where no longer breaking American codes; so if they had or where close to penetrating black at that time, it was swept under the rug and stopped after February

I can't see how the Turkish solution would be acceptable to the Italians, they after all regard it as Italian and they know the futility of resistance. So Londons hope of avoiding another high profile failure seems forlorn.
it would save them not inconsiderable quantities of fuel and garrison troops that they don't really have, and needing to feed the island; when it no longer has military value, not to say they would accept... Lord Gort never put any of the actual surrender of Malta plans to paper (even though it most certainly was discussed during the dark days in May and June) so I am hazarding a guess at a face saving measure
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top